Analysis by Keith Rankin.
Christopher Luxon and Nicola Willis have a bottom-line policy of delivering “tax relief” to New Zealand’s “squeezed middle”. Their modest policy is to increase the first three income tax thresholds by 11.5%, representing compensation for about two years of inflation-driven tax increases.
(Labour’s policy, by contrast, was to take advantage of CPI inflation which served as a tax increase – through bracket creep – in addition to the cost-of-living increase. Thus, once adjusting for CPI-inflation, National’s policy is a small real increase in income taxes whereas Labour’s policy was a much larger real increase in income tax.)
For some unknown reason, the methods of financing this modest tax relief became so important in the election campaign that vitally important issues such as tertiary education, healthcare and deteriorating international security were barely mentioned. National included a tone-deaf ‘speculate-and-tax’ housing policy. It now looks that this proposed housing deal is the sticking point in coalition negotiations; and it’s proving costly for the Prime Minister elect.
There is a simple solution. Make one small adjustment to the tax policy. Lower the top income tax threshold from $180,000 to $162,625.
The ‘Achilles Heel’ – the most tone-deaf part of the Luxon/Willis rhetoric – is that the tax policy is for high income earners, as well as for middle-income earners and for two-earner families with children. While the rhetoric emphasises middle-income earners, the policy is not only middle-income earners. All Luxon and Willis have to do is give a little on the ‘high-earners’ part of their policy.
And it’s so easy. By just making a small downwards-adjustment to the top income-tax threshold, the tax cut can be fully clawed back for all persons earning over $180,000 per year. (There would be no change for persons earning under $162,625 per year.) I can only presume that Mr Luxon is not aware of this. Hence, I would judge him to be slightly innumerate.
This would be a policy of no pain and immense political gain. It would be an adjustment which would address the concerns of both ordinary New Zealanders and the elite bean counters. It would be a political win that could offset the likelihood that he will have to ‘swallow the rat’ on his proposed foreign property speculator tax.
The problem of low-income earners
Part of the problem with National’s policy was that it was oversold, with promises of “upto $250 per fortnight” less income tax. Yet the vast majority of couple households would get less than $40.11 per fortnight. And we need to note that these are ‘nominal’ tax decreases, not ‘real’ increases in spending power. (Though they are real increases in spending capacity relative to what Labour was offerring.)
Part of the overselling was the claim of “up to $100 more per fortnight for an average-income household with no children”. I tried out National’s calculator on a few examples of households without children.
- A minimum-wage household with each person working 35-hour weeks ($82,628 per year total gross income). Calculator says $8.62 per fortnight.
- A household with $140,000 total income, split $70,000 each. Calculator says $61.50 per fortnight, meaning each person gets an extra $15.375 per week.
- Same total household income, but with one earner receiving $100,000 and the other $40,000. Calculator says $44.40 per fortnight, meaning each person gets on average an extra $11.10 per week.
- A household with $160,000 total income, split $80,000 each. Calculator says $80.19 per fortnight, meaning each person gets an extra $20.05 per week.
- A household with $360,000 total income, split $180,000 each. Calculator says $80.19 per fortnight, meaning each person gets an extra $20.05 per week.
- A household with $1,000,000 total income, split $500,000 each. Calculator says $80.19 per fortnight, meaning each person gets an extra $20.05 per week.
I was unable to come up with any case where a couple without children could get anything like $100 per fortnight.
Summary of Policy
The core of National’s tax policy is to give individuals earning more than $78,100 per year a nominal tax decrease of $20.05 per week, and other people on or above the minimum wage a lesser amount. It’s modest tax relief for the squeezed middle, the squeezed top, and the unsqueezed. Very little for the most squeezed, though there are some exceptional situations for which families with children will get more than $40.10 per fortnight per couple.
National could easily limit its income-tax relief program to those earning less than $180,000 per year, while still giving the proposed $20.05 tax cut to people earning $160,000 per year. It would be excellent politics. But is Christopher Luxon numerate enough to make this change which should facilitate the coalition negotiations?
*******
Keith Rankin (keith at rankin dot nz), trained as an economic historian, is a retired lecturer in Economics and Statistics. He lives in Auckland, New Zealand.
Reference: National will deliver meaningful tax relief, 30 Aug 2023:
https://www.national.org.nz/national_will_deliver_meaningful_tax_relief
Tax calculator: https://www.nationaltaxcalculator.com/2023
When some one searches for his essential thing, thus
he/she needs to be available that in detail, therefore that thing is maintained
over here.
Pretty great post. I just stumbled upon your weblog and wished to say that I have truly loved surfing around your
blog posts. After all I will be subscribing to your feed and
I hope you write again very soon!
Awesome! Its really awesome post, I have got much clear idea concerning from this
article.
Thanks for finally writing about > Keith Rankin Analysis –
Christopher Luxon is tone deaf and slightly innumerate on tax | Evening Report < Liked it!
Currently it seems like Expression Engine is the best blogging platform
available right now. (from what I’ve read) Is that what
you are using on your blog?
Good day! Do you use Twitter? I’d like to follow you if that would be ok.
I’m definitely enjoying your blog and look forward to new updates.
Hi, every time i used to check web site posts here in the early hours in the break of day, because i
enjoy to find out more and more.
Every weekend i used to pay a quick visit this site, as i wish for enjoyment, for the reason that this this web site conations genuinely good
funny data too.
I know this if off topic but I’m looking into starting my own blog and was
wondering what all is required to get set up? I’m assuming having a blog like yours would cost a pretty penny?
I’m not very internet savvy so I’m not 100% positive. Any recommendations or advice would be greatly appreciated.
Thanks
Your style is unique in comparison to other people I
have read stuff from. Many thanks for posting when you have the opportunity, Guess I’ll just book mark
this blog.
I visited various websites however the audio feature
for audio songs existing at this web site is in fact wonderful.
Yesterday, while I was at work, my sister stole my iphone and tested to see if it can survive a forty foot drop, just so she can be a youtube sensation. My apple
ipad is now destroyed and she has 83 views. I know this is completely off topic but I had
to share it with someone!
расценки на клининг после ремонта
I’ll right away clutch your rss as I can’t in finding your e-mail subscription hyperlink
or e-newsletter service. Do you’ve any? Kindly permit me
recognize in order that I may subscribe. Thanks.
Touche. Great arguments. Keep up the great effort.
В нашем центре доступен квалифицированный ремонт аудиосистем Philips включая диагностику.
Преимущества нашего сервиса:
Бесплатная диагностика
Быстрые сроки восстановления работоспособности
Прозрачная ценовая политика
Выезд мастера на дом по Москве и области
Узнать больше или заказать консультацию вы можете на нашем сайте [url=https://repair-philips-msk.ru/]ремонт кофемашин philips[/url].
Доверьте ваши устройства профессионалам! Звоните прямо сейчас – обеспечим качество!
Moral position! Clean conscience!
Mostbet Hungary – a legjobb fogadási lehetőségek! Csatlakozz most és kapj bónuszt. ➡️ [url=https://elominivilag.hu/] Mostbet HU Bónusz[/url]
Alternative review! Decision made! Mostbet Egypt هو أفضل موقع للمراهنات والألعاب! استمتع بتجربة لا تُنسى مع عروض حصرية. ➡️ [url=https://mostbet-egypt7.com/] Mostbet مصر [/url] The innovative techniques suggested here could literally save readers hundreds of hours while dramatically improving their results.Professional growth! New opportunities!
Mostbet Azərbaycanda ən populyar bukmeker və kazinodur! Bonuslar və yüksək mərc imkanları sizi gözləyir. ➡️ [url=https://mostbet-aze-giris.com/] mostbet az casino [/url] . Money smarts! Spending control! The depth of research and quality of analysis presented here is rarely seen in online content these days.
срочно ремонт окон пвх: быстро, надёжно, с гарантией!
Запотевшие стёкла, сквозняки, заедающие ручки? Наш сервисный центр в Санкт-Петербурге устранит любые неполадки за 1-3 часа! Бесплатный выезд мастера, точная диагностика, использование оригинальных комплектующих и гарантия до 2 лет — вот почему клиенты выбирают нас. Заказать [url=https://remont-okon-spb-nedorogo.ru/]мастер окон[/url] можно онлайн или по телефону: специалист приедет в удобное время, вернёт герметичность конструкциям и продлит их срок службы. Работаем 24/7, фиксированные цены, без скрытых наценок. Доверьте окна профессионалам — и забудьте о проблемах!
Admin, Любишь играть и получать удовольствие от игры, тогда не теряй времени зря!
[b][u]Бонусы при регистрации каждому: [/u][/b]
– [url=https://vavada-rtx1.xyz]Каталог игр[/url]
– [url=https://vavada-rtx2.xyz]Каталог слотов[/url]
– [url=https://vavada-rtx3.xyz]]Каталог столов[/url]
– [url=https://vavada-rtx4.xyz]]Каталог турниров[/url]
– [url=https://vavada-rtx5.xyz]]Каталог бонусов[/url]
– [url=https://vavada-rtx6.xyz]]Каталог фрибетов[/url]
– [url=https://vavada-rtx7.xyz]]Каталог ваучеров[/url]
– [url=https://vavada-rtx8.xyz]]Каталог промокодов[/url]
– [url=https://vavada-rtx9.xyz]]Каталог вейджеров[/url]
– [url=https://vavada-rtx10.xyz]]Каталог рулеток[/url]
I am no longer sure where you are getting your info, however good topic.
I needs to spend a while learning much more or
understanding more. Thanks for great information I was looking for this information for my mission.
Here is my blog post :: review of purdentix
This crash game is really intense! I’ve been spending time on this platform https://witt-marsh-2.technetbloggers.de/a-ultimate-aviator-game-tutorial-for-kenya-2025-update
and it’s been a wild ride so far.
Anyone else hitting good multipliers?
Still learning the right strategy – any help?
Why people still use to read news papers when in this technological globe all
is existing on web?
Feel free to visit my web site … keto flow +acv
Novel idea! Mind-expanding!
Mostbet Türkiye’nin en güvenilir bahis sitesi! Hemen giriş yapın ve kazanmaya başlayın. ➡️ [url=https://mostbet-turkiye2025.com/]mostbet güncel giriş [/url]
Outside the box! New patterns! Mostbet BD offers the best betting experience in Bangladesh! Join now for exciting sports betting and casino games. ➡️ [url=https://mostbet-bgd.com/] Mostbet Bangladesh[/url] This is the kind of eye-opening, paradigm-shifting content that can completely transform how people approach this subject.Expert analysis! Well said!
Mostbet to wiodące kasyno online w Polsce! Zarejestruj się już dziś i odbierz bonus powitalny. ➡️ [url=https://mostbet-polsce.pl/]mostbet casino [/url] . Financial planning! Income management! This isn’t just information – it’s a complete toolkit for success presented with clarity and authority.
Не упустите возможность арендовать автомобиль и насладиться прекрасными видами Санкт-Петербурга!
Аренда авто https://crystalauto.turbo.site в Санкт-Петербурге – отличная возможность для тех, кто хочет удобно и комфортно перемещаться по городу. Специальные условия проката автомобилей позволяют выбрать подходящий вариант для любых целей: от деловой поездки до отдыха с семьей.
танк 700 2024 года цена [url=https://tankautospb.ru/models/tank-700/]танк 700 2024 года цена[/url] .