Note to subscribers:
Today’s Political Roundup is by Geoffrey Miller, who is an international analyst at the Democracy Project. This is part of my revamp of the Political Roundup email, in which I will be occasionally getting other writers to contribute. Bryce.
Political Roundup: Nanaia Mahuta under pressure as Pacific’s geopolitical Great Game heats up
As a new ‘Great Game’ for control of the Pacific escalates, New Zealand’s foreign minister is coming under pressure from all sides.
For those keeping score, China has now signed co-operation agreements with Samoa and Kiribati, while the US has convinced Fiji to join its new Indo-Pacific Economic Framework for Prosperity (IPEF).
Most details of China’s new agreements have yet to be released, but they reportedly focus on economics and development – rather than hard security. But like the rather vague and weak IPEF on the Western side, the mere existence of the agreements is currently what counts.
As geopolitical competition and polarisation continue to deepen, timing and symbolism have been everything over the past week.
Last Monday, US President Joe Biden surprised observers with an apparent change in position in the US’s ‘strategic ambiguity’ policy towards Taiwan, when he said Washington was willing to intervene militarily to defend the island.
Then, on Tuesday – the same day as a Quad meeting was being held in Tokyo by Australia, India, Japan and the US – China formally announced an eight-country tour of the Pacific by its foreign minister, Wang Yi.
Wednesday saw the leaking to Reuters of a ‘China-Pacific Island Countries Common Development Vision’ – an ambitious blueprint from Beijing for multilateral co-operation in everything from policing and cybersecurity to climate change and trade.
A day later, on Thursday, Australia responded to China’s moves by dispatching its new foreign minister Penny Wong to Fiji – in advance of Wang Yi’s own trip to Suva. Wong had only just returned to Australia from the Quad meeting in Japan, which she attended together with new Labor Prime Minister Anthony Albanese.
In New Zealand, foreign minister Nanaia Mahuta was left to respond to the developments from the bigger players – and to fend off volleys of criticism from New Zealand’s former foreign ministers and diplomats over her perceived inaction.
Perhaps unsurprisingly, Winston Peters – Mahuta’s immediate predecessor as foreign minister – was one of the most scathing. On Friday, the New Zealand First party leader tweeted that ‘Mahuta’s incompetence has let this happen right under our noses’. The barb formed just one of many criticisms that Peters made throughout the week.
Meanwhile, Gerry Brownlee – like Peters, a former National Party foreign minister and a current political rival to Labour’s Nanaia Mahuta – said the minister should be visiting Pacific countries ‘in hot pursuit of the Chinese foreign minister’.
While defenders of Mahuta might write off criticism from Brownlee and Peters as standard partisan fare, the views of the former New Zealand diplomats are harder to ignore.
Marion Crawshaw, a former New Zealand diplomat with extensive Pacific experience gained in postings to Fiji, Solomon Islands and Papua New Guinea (PNG), tweeted: ‘Maintaining the ability to follow our own path in the Pacific has always required focus, attention & careful prioritisation. The need right now is for a visible lift to our attention & [relationships] right across the Pacific.’
For her part, Suzannah Jessep, a former New Zealand Deputy High Commissioner to India now working for the Asia New Zealand Foundation, wrote: ‘Feels weird that the Chinese foreign minister is visiting the Solomon Islands, Kiribati, Samoa, Fiji, Tonga, Vanuatu, PNG, and East Timor, but NZ has hardly done any ministerial in-person diplomacy. Hard to argue that the Pacific is our priority.’
And another former senior New Zealand diplomat, Nicola Hill, tweeted that Jacinda Ardern was offering ‘word salad diplomacy on the global stage at a critical moment about China in the Pacific’ that was ‘incoherent’. Like Jessep, Hill also highlighted inconsistency in New Zealand’s face-to-face diplomacy: ‘How often does New Zealand’s MFA [Minister of Foreign Affairs] visit PNG, Solomon Islands, Vanuatu or Kiribati? A flurry of visits in 2019.’
In a radio interview on Friday, Mahuta cited Covid-19 restrictions as the reason why she had not undertaken more travel in New Zealand’s neighbourhood.
The explanation holds for some countries, but not for others.
Kiribati, Samoa and Vanuatu are three examples of countries being wooed by China which are still generally closed to visitors because of Covid-19 border restrictions.
On the other hand, Papua New Guinea and the Cook Islands are very much open for business.
And while general entry restrictions are technically still in place for Solomon Islands, they did not stop Joe Biden’s Indo-Pacific Co-ordinator Kurt Campbell from leading a delegation to Honiara in April.
Indeed, given the pivotal role it has already played this year, Solomon Islands would seem like an essential destination for Mahuta to visit personally. Instead, the minister held a Zoom meeting with her Solomons counterpart on Wednesday, after it was reported that she had only sent a letter since it signed a security deal with China in April.
Mahuta has made only three trips outside New Zealand since she was appointed foreign minister in November 2020. Her inaugural trip last November to Australia, Asia, the Middle East and North America was followed by a Europe visit in February. Then, in late March, Mahuta made her only Pacific visit so far – to Fiji.
By contrast, trade minister Damien O’Connor is already on at least his fifth international trip.
As international travel gradually resumes following the lifting of Covid-19 restrictions, Mahuta is clearly passing up on travel opportunities.
In April, Mahuta attended a NATO foreign ministers’ meeting virtually – while Australia’s then foreign minister Marise Payne flew to Brussels to attend in person.
More recently, last week’s high-profile World Economic Forum (WEF) in Davos would have been an ideal networking opportunity for Mahuta to meet top global political and business leaders. Ardern’s current trip to the US meant that she could not attend the WEF herself – but she did attend in 2019.
One likely explanation for the relative lack of travel by Mahuta is her hefty domestic ministerial portfolio – Local Government – in which she is attempting to introduce major reform. Legislation for the ‘Three Waters’ plans is expected to be introduced to Parliament from the middle of this year, which will demand even more of Mahuta’s time.
It is true that previous foreign ministers – including Winston Peters – have frequently held extensive additional responsibilities in the past and have seemed to cope with their duties.
But as last week showed, geopolitical developments are speeding up.
If workload is the problem for Mahuta, the issue needs to be urgently addressed by Jacinda Ardern. This is especially true because the diplomatic travel schedule is typically heavily weighted towards the second half of the year, when annual meetings are traditionally held for multilateral groupings such as APEC, the ASEAN Regional Forum, the East Asia Summit and the Pacific Islands Forum.
Given the current geopolitical tensions, but also because most gatherings could only be held in virtual form in 2020 and 2021, New Zealand’s in-person participation at all of these summits – and more – is highly desirable.
To be fair, Mahuta’s difficulties are partly structural in nature. New Zealand currently has too many ministers tending to the foreign policy broth.
New Zealand has no fewer than eight MPs (including ministers, an associate minister and an under-secretary) who hold responsibilities that relate to foreign affairs – not including the Prime Minister.
There are separate foreign, defence, trade, disarmament and climate change ministers.
In particular, the separation of trade from the main foreign affairs portfolio is increasingly becoming an anachronism.
New Zealand split off the role from the main foreign affairs job in 1996.
The approach worked well during the post-Cold War era of technocracy that focused on expanding free trade under the then new World Trade Organisation (WTO) and establishing bilateral free trade agreements.
But with trade now often serving as a bargaining chip in the bigger geopolitical game – as China’s new draft agreement with Pacific nations and the US-led IPEF demonstrate – the division is now largely an artificial one and makes little sense.
A dedicated, full-time New Zealand Minister of Foreign Affairs and Trade would be far more effective – and more powerful.
Today’s new rivalry in the Pacific is very different from the original colonial Great Game, which pitted the British and Russian empires against each other in a quest for control of Afghanistan and Central Asia in the late 19th and early 20th centuries.
In the Great Game of the 21st century, face-to-face diplomacy is perhaps the single most valuable tool – as Australia’s Penny Wong and China’s Wang Yi successfully demonstrated over the past week.
The global geopolitical temperature is steadily rising.
New Zealand needs to ensure it can withstand the heat.
Geoffrey Miller is the Democracy Project’s international analyst and writes on current New Zealand foreign policy and related geopolitical issues. He has lived in Germany and the Middle East and is a learner of Arabic and Russian.
Further reading on China-Pacific-NZ
Mark Quinlivan (Newshub): China, Pacific security deals: Chinese politics specialist warns of NZ being ‘blockaded’ as Niue latest nation expected to ‘deepen cooperation’
1News: New focus on NZ’s security policy needed – China expert
Zane Small (Newshub): National’s Gerry Brownlee questions Nanaia Mahuta’s absence as China signs deal with Samoa in Pacific power grab
Zane Small (Newshub): Jacinda Ardern defends Nanaia Mahuta after Winston Peters accuses her of being absent on China’s Pacific power grab
Jamie Ensor (Newshub): Solomon Islands ‘anticipating high-level’ visit from New Zealand, Government won’t say if anything planned
Gordon Campbell: On The Panic In The Pacific Over China
Other items of interest and importance today
1) Tessa Parker (1News): Child poverty level worst in 18 years – KidsCan
2) Martyn Bradbury (Daily Blog): National/ACT Government vs Labour/Green/Maori Party Government in 2023 election
3) Karl du Fresne: Nanaia Mahuta and the smell test
4) Georgina Campbell: Julie Anne Genter’s Wellington transport secret letter not a storm in a teacup (paywalled)
5) Mitchell Alexander (Newshub): Documents reveal Let’s Get Wellington Moving has spent $39 million on consultants
6) Katie Scotcher and Russell Palmer (RNZ): Transport Minister Wood rebukes NZTA over $5k cost of Road to Zero signs
7) 1News: TVNZ managing ‘situation’ around Kamahl Santamaria resignation – Faafoi
8) Herald: Some TVNZ staff upset that Breakfast host Kamahl Santamaria was hired without consultation
9) Herald: Broadcasting Minister weighs in on sudden departure of new TVNZ Breakfast host Kamahl Santamaria
10) Donna Miles (Stuff): Let’s not delay lowering the voting age
11) Andrea Vance (Stuff): The death of more than 1000 New Zealanders merits an inquiry
12) Thomas Coughlan (Herald): Labour faces impossible inflation challenge in 2023 (paywalled)
13) Benn Bathgate (Stuff): Cost-of-living ‘tsunami’ will sweep National to power, says Christopher Luxon
14) Stefan Dimitrof (Māori Television): Christopher Luxon’s Māori tribute to Joe Hawke under attack
15) Thomas Coughlan (Herald): Budget 2022 not helping inflation fight, ex Reserve Bank governor Don Brash says
16) John Roughan (Herald): Democracy is a freedom worth fighting for (paywalled)
17) Damien Grant (Stuff): Adrian Orr may be happy to speak up, but there’s more we need to hear
18) Steve Braunias (Herald): The Secret Diary of Jacinda Ardern (paywalled)
19) Katrina Shanks (Stuff): How the Budget could affect your budget
20) Mike Houlahan (ODT): Health system reforms a step into the unknown
21) Liam Dann (Herald): Why slashing government spending right now would be a bad idea (paywalled)
22) Herald: NBR rich list 2022: Who’s made the list of New Zealand’s most wealthy
23) Maria Slade (NBR): The overview: Introducing the List (paywalled)
24) Andrea Fox (Herald): Is this the week agriculture hushes its critics on emissions action? (paywalled)
25) Jarrod Gilbert (Herald): We need a strong but careful approach to gang violence (paywalled)
26) Paula Bennett (Herald): On gang violence that is being ignored by the Government (paywalled)
27) 1News: Don Brash says fall in house prices ‘to be welcomed’
28) Russell Palmer (RNZ): Three waters Part II: What you need to know
29) Alisha Evans (Local Democracy Reporting): Little clarity on Three Waters ‘recipe for disaster’ – Anne Tolley
30) Glenn McConnell (Stuff): Mental health ‘invisible’ in major health reforms, National says
31) Laura Walters (Stuff): New Zealand again falls short of meeting commitment to refugees
32) Thomas Manch (Stuff): Defence Minister Peeni Henare says $525m Budget spend will ‘keep the lights on’
33) Peter Greener (Incline): Will there be a Labour Defence White Paper in 2023?
34) Ben Morgan (Daily Blog): Reviewing Peace Movement Aotearoa’s call to cut military funding
35) Duncan Garner (NBR): Labour faces public firing squad on law and order (paywalled)
36) Connor Stirling (1News): New buildings finally funded to solve Parliament’s space squeeze
37) Claire Trevett (Herald): Selling New Zealand to the US – Did PM Jacinda Ardern tick off her to-do list on her US trip?
38) Tracy Watkins (Stuff): US trip valuable, but don’t forget Australia
39) Luke Malpass (Stuff): New Zealand and California ink deal to cooperate on climate
40) Luke Malpass (Stuff): Why the Ardern-Biden White House meeting comes at crucial time for the Asia-Pacific
41) Janet Wilson (Stuff): Ardern couldn’t highlight US shootings, even if she’d been inclined to
42) Claire Trevett (Herald): PM Jacinda Ardern’s White House meeting chance to stop NZ being left out – but awkward China questions await (paywalled)
43) Luke Malpass (Stuff): Jacinda Ardern meets ‘silver fox’ California Governor Gavin Newsom, and sells NZ to Seattle tech bosses
44) Herald: Editorial: PM Jacinda Ardern’s trials and triumphs on US trip (paywalled)
45) Newshub: Political commentator Josie Pagani hits out at Jacinda Ardern’s savage dig at ‘keyboard warriors’
46) Claire Trevett (Herald): PM’s US trip: Jacinda Ardern update from Seattle after Amazon, Microsoft talks
47) Claire Trevett (Herald): PM’s US Trip: PM Jacinda Ardern’s big tech weekend with Twitter, Microsoft, Amazon
48) Vera Alves (Herald): Taylor Swift and Jacinda Ardern just got theirs — but do honorary degrees mean anything?
49) Craig McCulloch (RNZ): United States trip proves Jacinda Ardern’s pulling power
50) RNZ: More unanswered questions about public media plan
51) Sasha Borissenko (Herald): More for legal aid, courts, justice in Budget 2022, but still ‘oily rag’ rates (paywalled)
52) Alex Spence (Herald): Health officials say funding of child mental health services ‘has not kept pace’ with growing numbers in crisis (paywalled)
53) Seni Iasona (Stuff): Winston Peters reveals he didn’t run in Tauranga’s by-election because ‘there was no democratic reason for it’
54) RNZ: Scores of buildings share same floor weakness as Education Ministry’s office
55) Tom Hunt (Stuff): Wellington pipe price shock expected to be echoed around the country
56) Hayden Munro (Herald): Christopher Luxon dances around questions on National spending cuts (paywalled)
57) Stuff: Stan Rodger, ‘old school politician’ and former Labour minister, dies at 82
58) RNZ: Govt must step up to police social media – InternetNZ boss
59) Gareth Hughes; Steve Braunias (Newsroom): The day Rod Donald died
60) Mike White (Stuff): The steel behind the smile: Radical Jeanette Fitzsimons revealed in new book