? And could it help or hinder your healthy eating goals?
What is decision fatigue?
Decision fatigue , also known as choice overload, describes what happens when we make many effortful decisions over time.
Whenever you make a decision, you use a small amount of mental energy . As that energy runs low, you tend to make worse decisions.
This means you’re more likely to act without thinking, or simply choose what is easy or familiar. You might also find it harder to plan ahead and resist certain impulses.
This means you might be more likely to grab a takeaway instead of the ingredients to make a meal, or default to familiar comfort foods instead of making intentional, healthy choices.
How might it affect my eating habits?
The average person makes hundreds of food decisions each day.
You may think you’re just choosing a meal. But that one decision involves making many layered choices about what and how much you eat, as well as where, when and how you eat it.
You may make these choices subconsciously or automatically. But they each require to you weigh up various factors , such as taste, costs, time, expectations and more.
When decision fatigue sets in, you’re less likely to make thoughtful, health-focused choices . Instead, you may gravitate towards options that require less effort and offer quick rewards. You may also become more influenced by outside cues . An example of this is advertising that promotes convenient but high-calorie options such as fast food, snacks or indulgent treats .
Having too much information can make these decisions even harder. Nutrition advice often assesses the value of foods by how much protein, fat, fibre or vitamins they contain. This way of thinking, sometimes called nutritionism , can make food choices more complex. Instead of choosing food as food, we try to calculate and juggle many numbers at once.
Not the only factor
Several other factors may affect your food choices.
One is stress. One study from 2022 showed parents who experience high levels of both stress and decision fatigue found it more difficult to stick to positive food-related behaviours, such as making meals from scratch or eating together as a family.
Another is tiredness. One 2017 study showed time of day affected meal choices. It found between mealtimes, and especially in the afternoon, people were more likely to choose the simpler default food choice than one that required more consideration. This suggests having lower blood sugar and less mental energy meant people made less considered decisions.
How can I reduce my decision fatigue?
Have healthy foods on hand
When we’re low on mental or physical energy, we usually turn to what’s easy or familiar. That’s why it’s important to have healthy food options within reach. Thankfully, this doesn’t need to be complicated. It could look like pre-cutting fruit or having some healthy frozen meals in the freezer. And research suggests removing unhealthy foods – for example from the pantry or fridge – can be just as helpful when you’re trying to make healthier food choices.
Plan your meals
Planning meals could help too. This may involve setting some weekend time aside to decide what meals you’ll cook and eat. That’s instead of making last-minute decisions at the supermarket or on the drive home. Meal kits and batch cooking, which both reduce the number of food-related decisions you have to make, may also reduce decision fatigue.
Reframe your eating choices
How you frame choices may also improve your eating habits. For example, you may be more likely to “eat a colourful meal” rather than simply telling yourself to “eat more vegetables”.
Outsource some of the decision-making
If you’re looking for healthy, tasty recipes, you don’t need to re-invent the wheel. You can find a wealth of free ideas on the Eat for Health , Heart Foundation and National Nutrition Foundation websites. And if making food decisions feels overwhelming, Accredited Practicing Dietitians and Registered Nutritionists can help you turn complex nutrition advice into manageable steps.
The bottom line
We often think eating should be simple and intuitive, but blame ourselves when it doesn’t feel that way. However, the concept of decision fatigue shows healthy eating is not just about willpower. It’s also about noticing when you’re tired, stressed or time-poor, and taking practical steps to make healthy foods the easiest option.
Emma Beckett is senior lecturer, Nutrition and Food Science, Australian Catholic University.
