Page 169

‘Well-liked’ former publican dies in ‘preventable’ fall at crowded Taranaki Base Hospital ED

Source: Radio New Zealand

A coroner says the risk of catastrophic events happening at Taranaki Base Hospital’s Emergency Department remains high. Google Maps

* This story has been updated to correct the staffing levels at the time of the fall in ED.

A coroner has warned that five years after the death of a “sociable” and “straight-talking” former publican at Taranaki Base Hospital’s Emergency Department, the risk of catastrophic events happening there remains high.

Hāwera man Leonard Collett died following a fall at the ED in July 2020, aged 78, after being admitted with shortnesss of breath.

An inquest was held into his death in September.

Coroner Ian Telford found the primary cause of death was bleeding from injuries caused by the fall, which ultimately led to terminal cardiac arrest.

He said Collett’s fall was both “foreseeable and preventable” and shortcomings in the nursing care provided in the ED.

Telford referenced a report which found the department was fully staffed but with two casual nurses, and at the time of Mr Collett’s fall the department was five patients over capacity.

He was further concerned that in May 2025 the department was running short of 15 full-time staff.

There was evidence that significant changes had not been made and the risk of another ‘catastrophic event’ occurring remained high.

In a statement provided to the inquest and reproduced in full in the Coroner’s finding, Collett’s wife, Vicky, said “everyone knew Leonard as ‘Lenny’ or ‘Len’ and that she called him Len”.

The couple, who were married 39 years and had a blended family with four children, got into the pub business in New Plymouth 1976.

“We started at the Breakwater Tavern and had a real mix of patrons including all the ‘wharfies’. Len was well liked and respected by everyone. Len had a great sense of humour and a real way with words.

“He was sociable but a straight talker as well. He treated everyone the same regardless of their background. I remember that in our first week there Len had to jump the bar seven times to sort things out! It wasn’t unusual to have the bar full by 11 each morning.”

The couple took over the Ngāmotu Tavern in New Plymouth and Rahotu Tavern before retiring from the pub business about 20 years ago.

Collett was then employed at Works Infrastructure and the Manaia waste management centre, before retiring aged 67 due to health problems.

On the afternoon of 16 July 2020, Collett was referred to Hāwera Hospital by his GP Dr R Bruce, who arranged for an ambulance.

Collett had become increasingly short of breath over the preceding two weeks and had low haemoglobin.

Ambulance staff decided instead to take him to Taranaki Base Hospital ED and he arrived at about 5.30pm, was triaged and taken to a bed space.

At around 10.10pm, while waiting to be transferred to the ward, Collett was seen struggling to get back to bed after visiting the toilet (unassisted).

A nurse went to get him a wheelchair. However, he was then seen sitting on the end of the bed.

Around a minute later, a loud noise was heard, and Collett was found on the floor. It was immediately assessed that he was in a critical condition.

Emergency treatment, then resuscitation, was started immediately.

Unfortunately, despite extensive efforts, he could not be revived, and one of the attending doctors formally verified Collett’s death.

An internal inquiry into Collett’s death found that the fall was preventable, the falls assessment protocol was not followed, and a falls risk assessment was not completed.

At the time, the Emergency Department was five patients “over capacity”.

A review recommended a falls risk assessment on all patients be undertaken within two hours in the ED and six hours in wards, as per the updated policy.

An audit was to be completed within six months – to show at least 90 percent compliance – while a “falls icon” was also to be used on the department’s whiteboard to improve awareness of potential falls risk to patients.

In his findings, Coroner Telford noted that a falls risk assessment had not been implemented by February 2024 and there was no evidence of a further audit being done within the six month timeframe.

After considering the evidence of an expert witness on nursing practice and the prevention of falls, the coroner found the nursing assessment of falls risk was either inadequate or entirely absent, and there was a failure to implement appropriate interventions and monitoring to safeguard someone as vulnerable as Collett.

Coroner Telford said oral evidence given at the inquest provided some assurance that improvements to nursing processes were underway and continued to be developed.

“However, it was evident that such changes will have only limited impact unless and until the broader systemic issues are also addressed.

“Put simply, if this Emergency Department continues to operate without adequate staffing and an appropriate skill mix to safely care for and monitor patients, the risk of another catastrophic event occurring remains high.

“At the very least, it is hoped that Len’s case puts a face to the consequences of consciously deciding to operate an ED with 15 fewer full-time staff than it has been assessed as requiring.”

Coroner Telford said Collett’s death, and the trauma surrounding it, continued to be deeply felt by his wife, family, and all who knew and loved him.

“HNZ Taranaki has advised me that those involved in this incident were significantly affected. I accept this without hesitation and recognise that, in the context of the ongoing under-resourcing described [in evidence], some staff members may be left questioning their role and future within a healthcare system that is in such urgent need of their dedication and expertise.”

Coroner Telford said although resourcing issues were well known, a copy of his findings would be provided to the Ministry of Health and Health New Zealand and likewise to the Nursing Council and the New Zealand Nurses Organisation.

He made a raft of recommendations including:

  • That ED’s nursing admission documentation have its Falls Risk Assessment section revised to align with expert evidence and literature in a way that leads to the clear identification of risk status.
  • Its Fall Prevention Actions Taken section be revised and simplified to reflect the recording of nursing actions should be individualised, clear, easily read, and identifiable. This section should also record that risks and actions have been communicated to the patient and family.
  • Adapt the admissions documentation and departmental policy to require nurses to routinely assess falls risk at triage or at the same time as their primary assessment when patients are received into the treatment area.
  • Revise current policy and provide educational opportunities for all staff to foster a culture in which falls risks are communicated to patients, family and amongst staff members using direct, focussed, and targeted language.

Heath NZ Taranaki has welcomed the recommendations and intends to incorporate them.

Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero, a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.

– Published by EveningReport.nz and AsiaPacificReport.nz, see: MIL OSI in partnership with Radio New Zealand

Hīkoi mō Te Tiriti: A year on from one of Aotearoa’s largest protest movement

Source: Radio New Zealand

Scenes from Day 3 of Hikoi mō Te Tiriti in Tāmaki Makaurau, Auckland. RNZ / Cole Eastham-Farrelly

One year ago, a dawn karakia at Te Rerenga Wairua marked the beginning of Hīkoi mō Te Tiriti – a nationwide march opposing the Treaty Principles Bill and government policies impacting Māori.

Organisers framed it as more than an activation, calling it a step “towards our own liberation as a people” and a reminder of tino rangatiratanga.

The ACT Party’s Treaty Principles Bill was a key driver of the hīkoi, with organisers hoping to reach Parliament for its first reading.

The Waitangi Tribunal’s interim report said the government breached its Treaty obligations in developing the Bill, warning it could advance assimilation and undermine Māori as tangata whenua. The legislation was introduced shortly after, earlier than expected.

Across nine days, thousands walked, sang waiata and carried the colours of tino rangatiratanga across the motu, united in a call to protect Te Tiriti o Waitangi.

On the final day alone, an estimated 100,000 people filled the streets of Wellington, arriving on Parliament’s doorstep.

While the hīkoi was massive nationwide, its impact was global – captivating audiences around the world.

These are some of the faces and moments that defined that haerenga (journey).

Marchers in the hīkoi gather before dawn at Cape Rēinga. Hīkoi mō te Tiriti, 11 November 2024. RNZ/Peter de Graaf

From the mist-covered peaks of Te Rerenga Wairua

A mist-covered dawn karakia at Te Rerenga Wairua (Cape Reinga) on 11 November marked the beginning of the hīkoi to Parliament.

Hundreds were welcomed onto Pōtahi Marae in Te Kao the night before, some travelling from as far as Waikato.

Speaking at the pōwhiri, Hone Harawira celebrated the wave of new, young leaders taking the helm of the protest movement, calling them the “sunrise generation”.

Riders in the mist at Cape Rēinga. Hīkoi mō te Tiriti 11 November 2024. RNZ/Peter de Graaf

Hīkoi leader Eru Kapa-Kingi addresses the crowd in the early morning mist at Cape Rēinga. Hīkoi mō te Tiriti 11 November 2024. RNZ/Peter de Graaf

The next stop was Kaitaia, where thousands marched through the town’s main centre. Supporters lined the streets with flags, and local cafes offered free water and coffee. The sound of waiata and chants echoed across the town.

From there, the hīkoi travelled to Kawakawa and on to Whangārei, where hundreds were welcomed at Kaka Porowini Marae after covering around 280 kilometres.

Marchers carry a banner down Kaitāia’s Commerce Street. Hīkoi mō te Tiriti, 11 November 2024. RNZ/Peter de Graaf

Tahlia, 10, has made sure she’s got the best view as the hikoi arrives in Kawakawa. Hīkoi mō te Tiriti, 11 November 2024. RNZ/Peter de Graaf

Children from Te Kura Kaupapa Māori o Taumarere line the main street in Moerewa. Hīkoi mō te Tiriti 11 November 2024. RNZ/Peter de Graaf

On day two, thousands gathered at Laurie Hill Park in Whangārei, where rangatira acknowledged the scale of support and significance of the kaupapa.

The hīkoi then made its way to Dargaville, where manawhenua Ngāti Whātua, Te Roroa and Te Uri o Hau welcomed marchers. Hundreds filled Selwyn Park for waiata and kanikani, ready to activate.

The ordinarily quiet streets of the small town heard waiata and haka echo through them as the hīkoi made its way through the main centre.

Residents could be seen peeking through windows to watch the hīkoi pass, with locals leaving their workplaces to see the march.

The group later visited the Kaipara District Council to deliver a statement of support for former Māori ward councillor Pera Paniora, whose seat was disestablished by the council after changes to the Local Government Act.

A young kōtiro gets a better view of the crowd making its way down the road. Layla Bailey-McDowell / RNZ

Young kaihoe usher the hīkoi through the street. Layla Bailey-McDowell / RNZ

The hīkoi passes through Dargaville, Tuesday, 12 November 2024. Layla Bailey-McDowell / RNZ

The hīkoi at the Kaipara District Council building. Layla Bailey-McDowell / RNZ

Auckland’s Harbour Bridge sways

On day three, the hīkoi crossed Auckland’s Harbour Bridge under a sea of tino rangatiratanga flags.

Led by kaihaka, tamariki and kaikaranga, the bridge shook beneath thousands performing waiata and haka – a sight reminiscent of the 1975 Land March and the 2004 Foreshore and Seabed protest.

Kaumātua Herbert Manupiri, the son of a 28th Māori Batallion, reflected on that legacy, saying it was vital for young people to carry it forward.

“It has to come through our young people,” he told RNZ. “Our old people have to teach them.”

After stops at Takaparawhau (Bastion Point) and Ihumātao to acknowledge past struggles over Māori land, the hīkoi reached Huntly, where they were welcomed by mana whenua.

Trees were planted at Ihumātao, and organisers reaffirmed their call for kotahitanga before moving on to Rangiriri Pā – the site of a major Waikato War battle.

RNZ / Layla Bailey-McDowell

RNZ / Layla Bailey-McDowell

RNZ / Layla Bailey-McDowell

A participant in Hikoi mō Te Tiriti stands near State Highway One before the group crosses the Habour Bridge holding the United Tribes of New Zeland flag. RNZ / Cole Eastham-Farrelly

Te Pāti Māori co-leader Rawiri Waititi leads the hīkoi over Auckland’s Harbour Bridge. RNZ / Layla Bailey-McDowell

Crowds await hīkoi at Ihumātao. Layla Bailey-McDowell / RNZ

The following morning, the hīkoi entered Hamilton, where thousands gathered in Garden Place.

Te Pāti Māori MP Hana-Rāwhiti Maipi-Clarke welcomed the crowd, shifting the chant from “Ka whawhai tonu mātou” (we will fight on) to “Ka ora tonu mātou” (we will live on).

Organiser Eru Kapa-Kingi told the crowd the hīkoi was not about politicians in Wellington but about “standing up for future generations of Māori”.

Up to 6000 people filled Hamilton’s streets, with locals crowding balconies and side streets to watch. Waiata filled the air, kai was shared, and tamariki from Te Wharekura o Kirikiriroa joined in support.

RNZ / Layla Bailey-McDowell

RNZ / Layla Bailey-McDowell

The hīkoi fills Hamilton’s Victoria Street as it makes its way to Garden Place. Layla Bailey-McDowell / RNZ

Haka in the streets and in Parliament

That same day, the Treaty Principles Bill had its first reading in Parliament.

The debate grew heated. Labour’s Willie Jackson was ejected after refusing to withdraw comments accusing ACT leader David Seymour of “rewriting the Treaty” and being a “liar”. Green co-leader Chlöe Swarbrick urged National MPs to “listen to their conscience”.

When the final votes were called, Maipi-Clarke stood and interupted, leading the haka Ka Mate – a moment that shook a nation. Speaker Gerry Brownlee later ruled her actions “grossly disorderly”, suspending her from Parliament for 24 hours.

Despite opposition from Te Pāti Māori, the Greens and Labour, the Bill passed its first reading and went to the Justice Select Committee.

Te Pāti Māori’s Hana-Rawhiti Maipi-Clarke interrupted the vote on the Treaty Principles Bill’s first reading with a haka taken up by members of the opposition and people in the public gallery. RNZ / Samuel Rillstone

Te Pāti Māori MP Hana-Rawhiti Maipa-Clarke was among those to perform a haka, at Parliament, after the first reading of the Treaty Principles Bill, on 14 November, 2024. RNZ/ Samuel Rillstone

Te Pāti Māori’s Hana-Rawhiti Maipi-Clarke interrupted the vote on the Treaty Principles Bill’s first reading with a haka taken up by members of the opposition and people in the public gallery. RNZ / Samuel Rillstone

VNP/Louis Collins

The cavalry arrives

From Hamilton, the hīkoi pressed on through the rain to Rotorua, where an estimated 10,000 people filled Fenton Street, undeterred by the weather.

Marchers left Apumoana Marae at dawn, heading to Village Green Park for kōrero and waiata.

Te Pāti Māori co-leader Rawiri Waititi told the crowd that neither the rain nor politicians in Wellington could dampen the kaupapa.

“This is about the mana and tapu of Te Tiriti o Waitangi, nobody in that House has a right to debate that,” he said.

He also praised MP Hana-Rāwhiti Maipi-Clarke for performing a haka in Parliament the day before, calling it a continuation of tikanga Māori in debate.

As the hīkoi moved through the city, a group of horsemen – dubbed by RNZ kaimahi as “the cavalry” – joined the front line, while prominent Māori activist Tame Iti walked alongside marchers.

Steam rising from Rotorua’s geothermal fields marked the end of the march, as thousands gathered beneath flags and raincoats.

Patariki Hill holds a Tino Rangatiratanga Flag atop his horse Shadow. RNZ / Layla Bailey-McDowell

Young wāhine holds a picture of Māori war hero Robert ‘Bom’ Gillies, who died the week before the hīkoi began. Layla Bailey-McDowell / RNZ

RNZ / Layla Bailey-McDowell

Rotorua activates. Layla Bailey-McDowell / RNZ

RNZ / Layla Bailey-McDowell

RNZ / Layla Bailey-McDowell

From there, the hīkoi travelled to Hawke’s Bay, where more than 3000 people marched through central Hastings chanting “Treaty Principles Bill nehua” (bury the Bill).

Despite the rain, spirits remained high.

Toitū te Tiriti spokesperson Eru Kapa-Kingi said the scale of support had been “unfathomable”.

“Everywhere we go, there’s whānau on every corner waving flags,” he said. “It hasn’t let up once.”

As the hīkoi moved south, locals across Manawatū and along State Highway 2 staged their own roadside hīkoi, waving flags and joining in as the convoy passed through.

The runners

Alongside the main convoy, groups of runners were seen hitting the pavement – rain, hail or shine.

Each group covered part of the distance travelled by the wider hīkoi, often starting before dawn and rejoining the convoy each evening.

Organisers had said the running crews played a special role, keeping alive a tikanga from the 1975 Land March.

“The runners or the running crew are almost like an elite unit,” Kapa-Kingi said, “because it’s one of the tikanga from the ’75 march that the whenua is covered.”

“I suppose that’s a representation of tangata whenua, tūrangawaewae, those things.”

Each region the hīkoi passed through organised its own group of runners to carry the kaupapa across their rohe before handing it on to the next.

Tipene Kapa-Kingi, chief executive of iwi organisation Te Rūnanga Nui o Te Aupōuri and triplet brother of hīkoi leader Eru Kapa-Kingi. Peter de Graaf / RNZ

Some participants in the Hīkoi mō te Tiriti are opting to run parts of the route. These runners arrived in Kawakawa on Monday afternoon after travelling the hard way from Moerewa. Hīkoi mō te Tiriti, 11 November 2024. RNZ/Peter de Graaf

For the next leg of the hīkoi, the Square in central Palmerston North was packed with about 5000 people ready to activate.

From there, the convoy continued south to Levin for another rally before heading to Porirua for a rest day.

A contingent from Te Waipounamu had also travelled from Christchurch to Picton, crossing by ferry to join the North Island convoy in Wellington.

Arriving on Parliament’s door

The final day of Hīkoi mō Te Tiriti brought thousands to the capital, marking the end of a nine-day journey from the very top of the North Island.

Marchers set off from McEwan Park in Petone before dawn, walking the 14 kilometres into Wellington alongside convoys from across the motu. Māori wardens and police helped guide the hīkoi, while passing motorists tooted in support.

A carkoi destined for Parliament moves through the city as the sun rises in the capital. RNZ / Samuel Rillstone

RNZ/Samuel Rillstone

RNZ/Samuel Rillstone

By mid-morning, Wellington’s waterfront was painted red, white and black as crowds gathered at Waitangi Park. From there, thousands moved through the city’s main streets towards Parliament, where Māori Queen Te Arikinui Kuini Nga wai hono i te po joined them – only months after the passing of her father, Kiingi Tuheitia.

Those marching performed waiata such as Ngā Iwi E, while Tapeta Wehi and his students revived Tiriti o Waitangi – a haka written by his father Ngāpo Wehi in 1986.

At Parliament, the forecourt and surrounding streets quickly filled. Police estimated around 42,000 people attended, though some placed the number much higher.

ACT leader David Seymour was met with chants of “Kill the bill, kill the bill” when he walked out of the Beehive for a brief appearance at Parliament’s forecourt, before waving to the crowd and returning into the building.

RNZ/Samuel Rillstone

Speaker Gerry Brownlee watches the protest from the tiles ahead of Question Time on Tuesday afternoon. RNZ / Anneke Smith

The hikoi against the Principles of the Treaty of Waitangi Bill reaches Parliament. VNP / Phil Smith

The hīkoi protesting against the Treaty Principles Bill in Wellington on 19 November 2024. RNZ / Reece Baker

Scenes from the 2024 Hikoi to Parliament in protest against the treaty principles bill. VNP / Louis Collins

RNZ/Mary Argue

Hīkoi participants outside Parliament perform a well-known haka written by Ngapo Wehi. Layla Bailey-McDowell / RNZ

A Ngāti Whakaue rangatahi-led petition signed by more than 200,000 people opposing the Treaty Principles Bill was then presented to MP Hana-Rawhiti Maipi-Clarke.

Kapa-Kingi thanked attendees for their kotahitanga, and told the crowd the hīkoi was not a reaction, but rather, a response.

“The Māori nation has been born today,” he said. “Te Tiriti is forever.”

The day ended with kai, waiata and a concert at Waitangi Park, closing a historic week-long movement that drew an audience from across Aotearoa and beyond.

Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero, a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.

– Published by EveningReport.nz and AsiaPacificReport.nz, see: MIL OSI in partnership with Radio New Zealand

Hopes a vast fire at Tongariro won’t turn the tourists away

Source: Radio New Zealand

The Tongariro National Park fire is leaving the surrounding sky covered in hazy smoke Supplied

In Tongariro, locals pin their hopes on rain to put out a massive blaze, so their summer incomes don’t get burnt with the regions vegetation.

Rain carries the hopes of a region, as it comes to the aid of fire fighters battling a massive blaze at Tongariro National Park.

Locals are worried that the destruction of part of this unique area will add to the string of setbacks that’s hit tourism in the region.

The burning tussock and regenerating native bush has seen the Tongariro Crossing, the major attraction for visitors in the area, close for at least a week.

But it’s not just the economy that could be dealt a blow.

“I’m grieving today. I’m feeling quite impacted by it to be honest,” says ecologist Nick Singers.

This is the kind of highly flammable vegetation which has been burnt showing inanga (Dracophyllum filifolium) (red front), mānuka (Leptospermum scoparium) and mountain toatoa (Phyllocladus alpinus) Nick Singers

He’s the Technical Advisor for Project Tongariro, a volunteer group that works closely with the Department of Conservation in the area where the fire has ripped through.

Singers says the blaze has undone decades of work by conservationists, and put back its reforestation by more than a century.

“The Tongariro National Park is an area that’s regularly affected by disturbance – whether it’s volcanic disturbance – ash showers, lahars, lava flows, etcetera – and so it’s quite a dynamic landscape. It’s also been affected by humans, both Māori and European.

“The area that was burnt was successional vegetation, so it had regenerated from past fires. There was a very large fire in 1918 and then there was another one in 1947, and so that vegetation is around 78 to 105 years old. Or was.

The fire in the Tongariro National Park has covered 2800 hectares. Supplied

“Historically it would have been forest, and that’s where it was heading. There was lots of woody vegetation. But – one of the key things about that area were that it was full of plants with very oily resinous wood material – things like turpentine scrub; phyllocladus, which is alpine celery pine; manuka; and there was also the exotic weed calluna.”

Most of the calluna had been killed by the heather beetle, and Singers believes that’s why the fire was so vigourous.

Smoke from the Tongariro National Park fire can be seen from a property more than 25km away. Supplied

“A lot of that was sitting as dry tinder kindling that had been killed, so it was sort of this layer of thatch ready to go up,” he says.

“The vegetation was full of volatile oils so once it gets going, all of that stuff burns very, very hot.”

In the podcast, Singers explains the history of heather in the park and how the eradication of it became the world’s most successful weed bio-control operation, defoliating thousands of hectares.

A Ruapehu District local can see smoke from their property over 25km away Supplied

Other victims of the fire will likely include freshwater fish, insects and birds.

While species such as the kārearea (falcon) would have been able to get themselves out of reach of the flames, Singers says the smaller creatures may well have been caught.

That includes endangered species such as the whio (blue duck) which lives near the Whakapapa River, pīwakawaka, riroriro (grey warbler) and mātātā (fernbird).

A view of plumes of smoke billowing from the fire in the Tongariro National Park, taken from Bruce road. Supplied

“Particularly fernbirds, they don’t actually fly particularly well, they sort of hop from bush to bush to bush.

“So some of those I suspect would have just been caught up. They wouldn’t have been able to escape. That area was a particular stronghold for the North Island fernbird, it was low and scrubby – that’s what they love. That’ll be a real major loss for that species.”

But he says the greatest threat is the return of weeds such as gorse, broom and heather. Their seeds will be hiding in the soil ready to break out again. Wilding pines had been eliminated from the area too, but after the fire it will be extremely vulnerable to those being re-established.

The fire in the Tongariro National Park is sending clouds of smoke into the air Supplied

This winter hasn’t been a great one for the Ruapehu District as the famous Chateau remains closed, and there’s been uncertainty over the fate of the ski fields that saw a drop in advance bookings. A couple of weeks ago floods closed State Highway 4 into the area. Now, State Highway 47 is closed as firefighters do their work.

Mayor Weston Kirton says initially we were talking about 100 hectares which we thought “was a lot, but now we’re talking about 2800. That’s huge, and it’s left a big scar in our DoC estate, which of course is valuable to our communities,” he says.

Firefighters are likely to be in the area for at least a week and there will be hotspots for a long time.

“We only need a couple of hot days and things start evolving from that,” he says.

A view of the fire in the Tongariro National Park from a popular tourist photo spot along SH47 Supplied

Kirton points out that while this will have some effect on tourism in the northern part of the district, it’s business as usual for most of the rest.

“But what I’m saying here is we might need a helping hand to actually make a recovery, because this has come at a point where we’d normally be buzzing with people going across the Tongariro Crossing.”

His district has been hit by eruptions, floods, mill closures, the Covid downturn, thin ski seasons, ski operators going bust and the historic Chateau closing.

Smoke fills the sky above the Tongariro National Park where a wildfire has been raging since Saturday evening Supplied

“It seems to be a mayor that attracts all these disasters,” he jokes.

But Civil Defence Minister Mark Mitchell and Conservation Minister Tama Potaka have been to visit and he’s optimistic there will be some sort of ‘bounce-back’ funding from the government, whether it’s for replanting or to help encourage tourists to come back.

“They’ve been fully briefed on the situation, they understand the dynamics of this, they understand this is DoC estate that needs to be preserved, and they apparently are going to give us some financial support.”

Check out how to listen to and follow The Detail here.

You can also stay up-to-date by liking us on Facebook or following us on Twitter.

– Published by EveningReport.nz and AsiaPacificReport.nz, see: MIL OSI in partnership with Radio New Zealand

List of products, businesses on Consumer NZ’s anti-awards

Source: Radio New Zealand

Among its winners were Pams plasters, which did not stick for as long as they needed to. 123RF

A lack of understanding from consumers and a lack of enforcement from regulators could be combining to give shoppers a raw deal, Consumer NZ says.

It has released the results of its latest “Yeah Nah” awards, which are designed to highlight consumer problems such as confusing messaging or products that don’t do the job they are meant to.

To be eligible, products had to either fail a legal standard, include hidden charges, make false claims, be an “absolute rip off” or have unclear messaging or design so that consumers were confused.

Pams plasters

Among its “winners” were Pams plasters, which did not stick for as long as they needed to.

“Alongside Pams, we trailed two basic plastic plasters from Elastoplast and Band-Aid.

“Each volunteer chose a place on their body, like their arm or leg, and stuck all three plasters there. Pams plasters just couldn’t hold on,” Consumer NZ chief executive Jon Duffy said.

Foodstuffs has been approached for comment.

HelloFresh

HelloFresh made the list due to hard making it for customers to unsubscribe. RNZ / Dan Satherley

HelloFresh was also given an anti-award for how hard it made it for customers to unsubscribe from the meal kit service.

“The fact that it took four separate confirmations of cancellation before the cancellation was actioned didn’t help – it’s a bit like being stuck in an escape room,” Duffy said.

He said research respondents said it felt like HelloFresh did everything it could to stop them cancelling and one person compared it to a bad relationship break-up.

“Signing up to the service is so easy. But cancelling is significantly harder, which makes HelloFresh’s online design all the more frustrating.”

HelloFresh did not respond to RNZ queries.

It told Consumer NZ that it had a new pause and cancellation process but Duffy said it was not an improvement.

He said it should be as easy to unsubscribe as it was to subscribe in the first place.

“Fair play, If I’m looking to unsubscribe from your service, maybe offer me a special deal to retain me… that’s potentially good business, but the layers upon layers of hurdles and web design that is designed to lead you away from actually what you want to do is quite something to behold with HelloFresh.”

He said there was no law that stopped a business putting someone in a “20-minute downward spiral” of trying to interact with it to unsubscribe.

“We’re arguing there needs to be an amendment to the Fair Trading Act to cover what are called dark patterns. So that’s manipulative web design that’s designed to do what you don’t want it to do, to do something that’s in the interest of the business to your detriment as a consumer.

“Other jurisdictions are beginning to introduce what are called prohibitions on unfair trading practices, which cover this.

“But at the moment our Fair Trading Act has a big gap in it where a business isn’t misleading you by making it difficult for you to unsubscribe. They’re not saying you can’t unsubscribe, they’re just making it virtually impossible for you to technically do it. Which is legally compliant at the moment, but we don’t think it should be.”

Harvey Norman

Consumer NZ also raised concerns about Harvey Norman’s pricing.

Consumer tracked 10 products online over a nine-week period and found that Harvey Norman promised a “great price”, “super deal”, “huge deal” or a “massive stock sellout” every week on most of the 10.

“If a business constantly sells a product at a special price, that ‘special’ becomes the usual selling price. A sale must be a genuine opportunity to save, for a limited time,” Duffy said.

“When something says it’s on sale – you need to be able to trust it really is. Harvey Norman makes that surprisingly difficult to do.”

He said when Consumer asked a Harvey Norman spokesperson about its pricing practices, the spokesperson said the company’s practices were consistent with the “industry approach to pricing and labelling decisions”.

“If that’s the case, we’re giving the ‘industry approach’ a ‘yeah, nah’, too,” Duffy said.

Barkers

Barkers was highlighted for its potentially misleading terms and conditions.

Duffy said Consumer reviewed 30 online returns policies and found Barkers had potentially broken the rules by implying some items could not be returned.

“Our spot check found that Barkers’ online returns policy wasn’t up to scratch. You have the right to return any product that doesn’t meet the guarantees under the Consumer Guarantees Act. It’s that simple.

“A returns policy can’t overrule the law, and we think Barkers risked misleading their customers by setting out a range of limitations that are at odds with the customer’s rights under the Consumer Guarantees Act.

“Our interaction with Barkers has been really good and they’ve certainly taken on board our feedback and are looking to urgently review their policies. So that’s a really beneficial side of us doing this process.”

Other shops had similar issues but not to the same extent, he said.

“They’re obviously concerned that people are buying clothes, perhaps wearing them out to a party and then trying to get a refund for them by claiming that they’re faulty. But actually you’re not covered by the Consumer Guarantees Act if you do that.

“If clothes don’t genuinely have a fault and you just change your mind, you’re not entitled to a refund or a replacement.

“So Barkers don’t need to sail close to the wind with the wording in their policies that say things like there’s a 30-day limit for returning clothes. There is no limit in the law for returning an item if it’s not fit for purpose or it’s broken, or has a fundamental fault with it, you have rights.”

Consumer NZ chief executive Jon Duffy. Jon Duffy

He said another issue that was seen was shops trying to ask people to pay to return items.

“The Consumer Guarantees Act says that it’s the retailer’s responsibility to manage returns.”

He said New Zealand consumers lacked an understanding of their rights and there was a lack of enforcement from regulations.

“I can remember in my 20s, there were quite active campaigns out of what used to be the Ministry of Consumer Affairs publishing set texts around refunds that stores would have on their counters.

“And we don’t see that level of activity anymore… consumer issues generally across government have been sidelined, I think, and particularly under the current government, they’re not a high priority.

“So the funding’s not there to do mass market campaigns and educate consumers.

“Secondly, we’re often dealing with multinationals here where they will write terms and conditions for their bigger markets and New Zealand just becomes a tack-on.

“There might be a lawyer sitting in Los Angeles trying to write a returns policy that complies with New Zealand law, and they might not get everything right because they’re not specialists in the jurisdiction.”

Sign up for Money with Susan Edmunds, a weekly newsletter covering all the things that affect how we make, spend and invest money.

– Published by EveningReport.nz and AsiaPacificReport.nz, see: MIL OSI in partnership with Radio New Zealand

Te Pāti Māori MPs’ expulsions questioned by law expert, former co-leader

Source: Radio New Zealand

Te Pāti Māori’s National Council has decided to expel Mariameno Kapa-Kingi and Tākuta Ferris. RNZ/Liam K. Swiggs

A former co-leader of Te Pāti Māori has expressed his sadness and disappointment at the expulsion of two of its MPs.

Te Pāti Māori’s National Council has decided to expel Mariameno Kapa-Kingi and Tākuta Ferris, a decision both MPs said was “unconstitutional”.

The MPs have vowed to challenge the decision, which one electoral law expert said would hinge on whether the party appropriately followed its constitution, particularly its dispute resolution processes.

Representatives from Kapa-Kingi’s electorate Te Tai Tokerau were excluded from voting, following a resolution to ‘reset’ the electorate executive last month.

The electorate executive in Te Tai Tonga, Ferris’ electorate, abstained. Ferris’ social media post claimed the Hauraki-Waikato electorate also abstained.

Te Pāti Māori co-leader Debbie Ngarewa-Packer said that still meant the decision was “without opposition”.

Former co-leader Te Ururoa Flavell said three electorates out of six voting for expulsion was “not consensus”, and he was saddened and disappointed by the outcome.

“There was an element of hope, that the parties would come together and work things out, especially since our constitution talks about decision-making being by consensus, where you work away and try to get to middle ground.”

Former Te Pāti Māori co-leader Te Ururoa Flavell. RNZ / Rebekah Parsons-King

Flavell said members would expect to see “both sides of the story” first, and for the party to follow a “fair, open, and transparent” process.

“It must have been building for some time. And the downside is it’s so complicated, involving issues of leadership, issues of who said this and who said that, issues of who did this and who did that,” he said.

“And we haven’t necessarily got both sides of the story on the table, and the whole issue investigated to at least determine ‘OK, what have we got here?’ The rhetoric has very much been from one side of the story, and that’s disappointing because you sort of think in the spirit of a fair process and transparency, that all parties get a shot to put their case. That should have, could have, happened at the AGM.”

Flavell said at a time when Māori were facing big issues and looking for someone to challenge and offer alternatives to what the government was doing, the battle had “overshadowed” things, and the negative reaction made him worry about the next election.

“Everything I’ve seen or heard, either social media or personally to myself, has been really negative about what’s going on. And people just want to say come on, come together, show some example, work together, and let’s focus on the big issues that our people face right now.”

Ngāti Kahungunu chair Bayden Barber, who as representative of the National Iwi Chairs Forum had sought to get both factions to a hui this week, said Te Pāti Māori was entitled to go down the path it did under its constitution, but maintained there was still merit in meeting face-to-face.

“What we’ve been hoping and trying to broker between the groups is that hui under our tikanga, on our marae, would be the ideal. It’s not the solution, but it’s a pathway towards reconciliation. So yeah, so this has put a different slant on the context, totally,” he told Midday Report.

Ngāti Kahungunu chair Bayden Barber. RNZ / Kate Green

What does the party’s constitution say?

Ferris and Kapa-Kingi have rejected the decision, with both saying it was “unconstitutional”.

Kapa-Kingi has vowed to appeal the decision “in all respects,” while according to The Post Ferris was engaging legal counsel.

While the co-leaders said the resolution took effect on Monday, Te Pāti Māori’s consitution allowed a member whose membership has been cancelled to appeal the decision at the next national hui.

That hui is set down for 7 December.

University of Otago law professor Andrew Geddis said such an appeal would hinge on whether the party appropriately followed its constitution in expelling the MPs.

The constitution contains a section on dispute resolution, as well as a clause to cancel membership if the council believed that member had ceased to accept or abide by the constitution.

Geddis said a challenge could come if the MPs did not believe the disputes resolution process was properly used.

“They’ll be saying, well, if you had a dispute with us or thought we were acting improperly, you should have used the disputes resolution process to bring the dispute in front of our electorate committee, and then take it further if need be, and so on, rather than jumping straight to I guess you would call the nuclear option, just kicking us out with no process at all, using this general power to remove membership,” Geddis said.

University of Otago law professor Andrew Geddis. RNZ / Cole Eastham-Farrelly

The co-leaders have not publicly said what the breaches of the constitution were that merited Kapa-Kingi or Ferris’ expulsions, only that the constitution had standards of duty, budgetary responsibility, and behaviour, and that the breaches were “serious”.

Te Pāti Māori co-leader Rawiri Waititi had “absolute confidence” the party had followed its constitution, and insisted every attempt was made to resolve the disputes before the National Council turned to expulsion.

“We have had many a conversation one-on-one, two-on-one, group MP huihuis, we have had interventions, we have had many, many hui to try and get to the bottom of this, and we have come short of a resolution and we have tried our best,” he said.

“When tikanga hasn’t been able to do that, then we turn to the kaua.”

Te Pāti Māori co-leader Rawiri Waititi. RNZ / Samuel Rillstone

Waiariki missed out?

Questions have also been raised about consultation in the lead up to the National Council hui.

RNZ has seen emails sent to Te Pāti Māori Waiariki electorate members on Wednesday 5 November, alerting them to a meeting on the afternoon of Sunday 9 November, ahead of the National Council that evening.

“In preparation for this National Council hui, we are wanting to meet with our Waiariki electorate to hui in person,” it read.

“We understand the short notice and apologise.

“We hope to see you there.”

Another email seen by RNZ stated it was cancelled because Rawiri Waititi was “unavailable” to attend.

On Friday 7 November, a follow-up notice was sent out cancelling the Sunday afternoon meeting.

“It has been great to have been able to connect with some of our branches this week!” it read, before stating the scheduled in-person hui was cancelled.

“We apologise for any invonvenience in cancelling this hui.”

On Monday morning, an email went out ahead of the 10am announcement, detailing the decision to remove Ferris and Kapa-Kingi from the party.

“Last night the National Council unanimously decided that Takuta Ferris and Mariameno Kapa Kingi were in breach of the Constitution and therefore decided that the appropriate action is the immediate removal of their memberships from Te Pāti Māori.”

It mentioned meeting with all Waiariki branches, despite the in-person hui being cancelled.

“After meeting with all of the Waiariki branches, we wanted to thank you all for the courageous conversations and the unanimous decision to enable our Waiariki Executive to represent Waiariki at the National Council hui held on Sunday, 9th of November.”

RNZ understands members are frustrated at missing out on an opportunity to discuss the decisions.

A Te Pāti Māori spokesperson told RNZ all electorate matters were managed by their respective electorate executives.

“In Waiariki, all branches were consulted prior to the National Council hui.

“The proposed in-person hui was cancelled once branches confirmed they would not be attending, as their positions were already clear and formally communicated.

Te Pāti Māori co-leaders Debbie Ngarewa-Packer and Rawiri Waititi speak to media after announcing two party members have been expelled from the party. RNZ/Samuel Rillstone

Will the MPs be waka-jumped out?

The next step is for Te Pāti Māori to inform the Speaker that Kapa-Kingi and Ferris are no longer Te Pāti Māori MPs.

The Speaker then tells the House that the MPs are now regarded as independent members.

That then gives the party an opportunity to use the party-hopping, or waka-jumping, legislation to remove them from Parliament entirely.

That would require the party leaders writing to the Speaker of their belief the MPs were disrupting the proportionality of Parliament.

The legislation requires a party to use all of its internal processes first, with Te Pāti Māori’s constitution allowing for an appeal at the national hui.

Rawiri Waititi said using the legislation had not been a consideration at this stage, and any consideration would be for the National Council.

Since the law was re-introduced in 2018, it has been used once, with the Green Party deciding to expel Darleen Tana in 2024.

Geddis said the Greens had used a process that went above and beyond their own constitution in ousting Tana.

“The Greens actually gave Darleen Tana more natural justice, more of a chance to be heard than the constitution actually required of them. In this case, Te Pāti Māori seems to have used the quickest, neatest, cleanest way to get rid of these MPs.”

Former Green MP Darleen Tana. RNZ / REECE BAKER

In Tana’s case, she had already resigned from the party, while Kapa-Kingi and Ferris have been expelled strongly indicating they want to remain in Te Pāti Māori.

“Here, you’ve got a party that has kicked MPs out, and it’s the party’s action that is going to distort Parliament’s proportionality. And so one of the questions is going to be can you use the party-hopping law against an MP that you have kicked out, thereby distorting proportionality, or do you have to point to something that that MP did that caused you to kick them out and therefore cause the action?” Geddis said.

Who will Labour work with?

Rawiri Waititi said Te Pāti Māori had begun “serious and constructive” conversations with Labour and the Greens.

But Labour leader Chris Hipkins denied that was the case, saying there had been no meetings since September’s Tāmaki Makaurau by-election.

Labour leader Chris Hipkins. RNZ / Mark Papalii

While there had been the occasional chat from time to time, including a courtesy call about the expulsion, Hipkins said there had been nothing on any future partnership or any governing arrangement, and re-iterated his stance that Te Pāti Māori needed to sort through its internal issues first.

“I’d like to see Te Pāti Māori, focused on representing the people who voted for them, showing up in Parliament, constructively participating in debates, coming up with some new ideas. I think those are all things that are opportunities available to them.”

Hipkins indicated he would not meet with Kapa-Kingi or Ferris either, especially if they were challenging the decision to expel them from the party.

“That’s something I’m not getting involved in in any way.”

The Prime Minister called Te Pāti Māori a “joke” and also ruled out working with Kapa-Kingi or Ferris.

“To me, it’s just a sheer soap opera. I don’t want to work with them, I won’t be working with the independents, I won’t be working with Te Pāti Māori, I’m pretty clear about that.”

Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero, a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.

– Published by EveningReport.nz and AsiaPacificReport.nz, see: MIL OSI in partnership with Radio New Zealand

‘We’re desperately due’: Trainer Cran Dalgety hopes for first win at Trotting Cup

Source: Radio New Zealand

Cran and Carter Dalgety. SUPPLIED

The veteran trainer of a New Zealand Cup front-runner says a maiden win following a string of podium results would serve as a long-awaited milestone.

Republican Party, trained by Canterbury’s Cran and Chrissie Dalgety, remained the leading homegrown contender for Tuesday’s 122nd running of the New Zealand Trotting Cup at Christchurch’s Addington Raceway.

After more than 30 years, Cran Dalgety’s run at the marquee harness racing event had been marked by a string of near things.

The West Melton trainer has finished with two second places and three thirds in previous cups.

The main prize had however continued to elude him.

“I’d like to think I’ve done my apprenticeship. I’ve been trying to win this race for 34 years,” he said.

“We’ve had 18 shots at it. A lot of seconds and thirds, but second is first beaten so it doesn’t count.

“We’re desperately due.”

Other notable results include a third place for Christen Me in 2013, an historic year in which the Graham and Paul Court-trained Terror to Love triumphed in becoming only the third horse to win the Cup for a third time.

Dalgety’s Bettor’s Strike also had to settle for a second place finish in 2009.

An integral part of the family’s hopes was 22-year-old son Carter who would be driving Republican.

The talented driver had made a gradual rise up the ranks, turning heads by securing the Junior Drivers Premiership which capped a red letter year.

“He’s making more positive results than the negative ones. It’s exciting to have him associated with the horse,” Dalgety said.

“If something really good happened and he got victory it would be quite a buzzy day.”

The Republican Party team was buoyed by a good run of recent form courtesy of three straight wins over the past month.

“Like all sport, you prepare and you try your best, and then come the day, you hope for the best,” Dalgety said.

“Everything’s fallen into place and we go in with a bit of confidence.”

New Zealand Cup day was one of the big events on the Canterbury social calendar and the Cup, with a purse of $1 million, was also one of the country’s pinnacle racing events.

“The mana that comes with this particular race is hard to explain. Everyone who can relate to racing, can remember who won the last New Zealand Cup,” Dalgety said.

Last year, Republican Party finished third at Addington, behind Don’t Stop Dreaming and Swayzee, the latter clinching a second straight NZ Trotting Cup.

They will, however, have to overcome the bookies hot pick from across the Tasman.

Leap To Fame, trained and driven by Queensland’s Grant Dixon, sat at $1.60 at the TAB on Monday to win the Cup.

Dalgety was excited by the challenge that laid ahead.

“I’m not an emotional person, but it would test the emotions if it did happen.”

Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero, a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.

– Published by EveningReport.nz and AsiaPacificReport.nz, see: MIL OSI in partnership with Radio New Zealand

Darfuri diaspora – grief and hope from afar

Source: Radio New Zealand

Displaced Sudanese who fled El-Fasher after the city fell to the Rapid Support Forces (RSF), arrive in the town of Tawila in war-torn Sudan’s western Darfur region on 28 October, 2025. AFP

Kadambari Raghukumar produces and presents Here Now, RNZ’s weekly series on people from various global backgrounds living in Aotearoa. Her work in media has taken her from Kenya, to Sudan and across Asia.

Since April 2023, Sudan has been gripped by a brutal civil war between the Sudanese Armed Forces and the paramilitary group, the Rapid Support Forces (RSF).

What began as a power struggle between two generals has devolved into a horrific humanitarian crisis.

More than 40,000 people have been killed and nearly 12 million people have been displaced.

In 2019 I spent time in Khartoum just days after President Omar Al Bashir’s 30 year authoritarian regime ended, and before the transitional government was put in place.

I distinctly recall a sense of optimism on the streets during the revolution and people saying how it felt like a “freedom festival”.

How did such a hopeful time, seemingly the start of a transition to democracy, turn into the unimaginable violence we are seeing now?

In this week’s episode of RNZ’s Here Now podcast, I speak to Darfuri Aucklanders Fathima Sanussi, Izzadine Abdallah, Hassaballah Hamid and Kaltam Hassan.

Hassaballah Hamid came to New Zealand a year ago through the UN refugee pathway. He’s from Darfur, where in the past few weeks, death and destruction is everywhere.

On Oct 26, the RSF took over Al-Fasher, the last major city of Darfur held by the Sudanese army.

The RSF have killed nearly 2000 people there, while tens of thousands are still stranded the city as the militia seize more territory from the army in the south-west and center.

“This is now beyond tribalism, this is a proxy war on Sudan,” Hamid said.

(L to R) Kaltam Hassan, Fathima Sanussi and Izzadine Abdallah. Supplied

The United Arab Emirates (UAE) is widely accused of providing military support to the RSF, but UAE officials deny the allegations despite evidence presented in UN reports and international media investigations.

Famine has gripped the region, a once fertile part of the country known for growing food and pasture lands. While hospitals and schools have been destroyed across the Darfur region.

Over the weekend, Fathima Sanussi, an activist and former refugee from Sudan, organised a solidarity rally in Auckland, calling for an end to the violence.

“I’m from Darfur, it’s more of a reason why this work is so important to me,” she said.

“Right now, with everything that’s happening and being away from home, it allows us to kind of understand the functionality of the way the world works.

“My parents were forcibly displaced. More than ever now, as a Sudanese person and someone that’s particularly from Darfur, I want to be able to go back home one day.”

Darfur is a complex and diverse region where the Fur people, the Masalit and Arab Sudanese have lived for centuries – some semi-nomadic, pastoral communities, others, indigenous to those lands.

Ethnic tensions between what are called Arab and non-Arab groups have simmered for decades in these parts.

Kaltam Hassan and her son Izzadine are Masalit, from Al Genina in Darfur. It’s a region that is familiar with conflict.

In 2003, the Darfur Civil War brought extensive violence to the people of Al Genina, many of whom fled.

Sudan’s vast natural reserves – gold, copper, iron ore, while not the only reason, are said to be one of the major reasons this war has been prolonged and attracted support from external players.

Sudan is Africa’s 3rd largest gold producer and has reserves of iron, uranium ad copper across the country, particularly Darfur and Kordofan.

Fathima said: “It’s not fair that our people have to bear the burden of it all, meanwhile feeding the rest of the world and giving the world luxury goods at the expense of their death.

“The violence in Darfur is a modern-day colonial project. And I think once we start reframing the language of how we start speaking about Sudan is when we’re going to see effective conflict resolution.”

Kaltam Hassan recalls a peaceful childhood and past life in the region, until ethnic tensions spilled over and the Janjaweed militia (from whom the RSF were formed) unleashed violence.

But like others, she also sees external support to the RSF amplifiying the scale of this current conflict.

“What happened in the past, it’s already happened,” Kaltam said.

“But once those people stop funding the RSF, the Janjaweed, then we can figure out how to stop the fighting. But with other people from outside us funding them, giving them more power, it doesn’t matter how much our people are fighting, the problem won’t stop because it’s not just our problem anymore.”

Sudanese across the diaspora wait and watch for the viciousness of this war to end, continuing to wish for a return to how things used to be.

“People in Darfur are agricultural people. If the war stops, all the people even in the refugee camps, they will all go back to Darfur because there’s nowhere like home and they will start growing again.

“And that’s the one thing I want to see, our people going back home and building what’s already been broken down, growing our own food and just living the life that we used to live before all this started” Kaltam said.

Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero, a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.

– Published by EveningReport.nz and AsiaPacificReport.nz, see: MIL OSI in partnership with Radio New Zealand

Being bilingual delays ageing, but being multilingual is even better – study

Source: Radio New Zealand

The more languages people know, the slower their brains age, a new study reveals. RNZ

An international study of more than 80,000 adults shows the more languages people know, the slower their brains age.

The analysis of 51 to 90-year-olds from 27 European countries – published in Nature Aging – found the brains of those who only spoke one language were twice as likely to age faster.

Those who were multilingual were on average about half as likely to experience accelerated ageing, the authors said.

The researchers also found that speaking multiple languages delayed ageing and the more languages spoken, the greater the effect.

They said the results suggest that promoting multilingualism could support healthy ageing strategies.

Dementia researcher and lecturer in psychological medicine at University of Auckland, Dr Etu Ma’u, said the study confirmed what had long been suspected – that being bi- or multi-lingual keeps the brain active and stimulated, which is beneficial for brain health.

Dementia researcher and lecturer in psychological medicine at University of Auckland, Dr Etu Ma’u. Supplied/Pasifika Medical Association

He said the brain shrunk about 5 percent every year from the age of 40.

Ma’u e said the brain’s ageing was a natural process and a balance between incremental damage sustained over a lifetime and things that protect “cognitive reserve” (the brain’s ability to keep functioning despite such changes).

“We’ve known for a while that anything that stimulates our brain is going to be good for cognitive reserve.

“[This] study by Amoruso and colleagues demonstrates that the ability to speak more than one language improves cognitive reserve by slowing brain ageing, and the benefits increase with the number of languages spoken.”

Ma’u said the “massive study” with some “really cool modelling” showed the more languages spoken, the younger the brain.

“If you speak more than one language your brain age, or the health of your brain, is coming in at a couple of years younger than what your chronological age is – a younger brain means a healthier brain, effectively.

“If you just spoke your mother-tongue, you had a higher brain age compared to people who spoke two languages, but they’ve shown that people who spoke three languages, probably had even more of an impact.”

He said dementia was the result of cumulative and incremental damage over the course of someone’s life, as was building cognitive reserve and resilience.

Therefore, guarding against such age-related diseases was something to think about earlier rather than later, he said, and not just on an individual basis, but at an environmental level.

“We need to think about brain health from infancy all the way through. So clearly learning a second language as a child at school or in your community is good, because it keeps your brain active and stimulated.

“It’s never too early and it’s never too late to learn a new language to challenge your brain.”

Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero, a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.

– Published by EveningReport.nz and AsiaPacificReport.nz, see: MIL OSI in partnership with Radio New Zealand

November health strike grows to 16,700

Source: Radio New Zealand

The strike is set for Friday 28 November. RNZ/Samuel Rillstone

Another 5200 health workers will walk off the job at the end of the month, the public sector union says, bringing the total number on strike to about 16,700.

The Public Service Association said more than 3500 mental health nurses and assistants and public health nurses, plus 1700 policy, advisory, knowledge and specialist workers (PAKS) – who provide vital support for health care – have voted to strike on Friday 28 November.

The strike was to support claims for safe staffing and a pay rise that kept pace with the cost of living, national secretary for the Public Service Association Te Pūkenga Here Tikanga Mahi, Fleur Fitzsimons said.

The PSA said these members would join 11,500 allied health workers, including physiotherapists, social workers and technicians, who have also voted to strike on 28 November, after mediation failed.

Fleur Fitzsimons. RNZ / Samuel Rillstone

“These health workers are reluctantly taking strike action. They care deeply about their patients and their work and will ensure life preserving services continue. But they feel they have no choice when their concerns are not responded to,” Fitzsimons said.

“The pay offers for the three collectives still doesn’t keep pace with inflation – they are effectively a pay cut. Meanwhile, there are simply not enough health workers to provide the level of care New Zealanders need.”

Mental health nurses and assistants and public health nurses would have another round of mediation on Friday 14 November, and the PAKS collective on Tuesday 25 November.

Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero, a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.

– Published by EveningReport.nz and AsiaPacificReport.nz, see: MIL OSI in partnership with Radio New Zealand

Fires crews start ‘grunt work’ at Tongariro park

Source: Radio New Zealand

Favourable conditions on Monday meant the fire appeared to be extinguished. Fire and Emergency NZ

Fire and Emergency crews in Tongariro National Park will be back at the scene of wildfires, hoping for more rain to keep hotspots damp.

Favourable conditions on Monday meant the fire appeared to be extinguished.

Thermal imaging drones were expected to be used overnight to check for hotspots after fires that had turned more than 2800 hectares of land to ash.

MetService forecasts rain clearing in region from early Tuesday morning and then fine, aside from isolated showers.

Incident Controller Nigel Dravitzki told Checkpoint the favourable conditions had helped reduce the fire, but there was still a lot of work to be done.

“Visibility it looks out, but we are doing thermal imaging and drones over it tonight to see if we can pick up any activity or hots spots we can’t see.”

He said this type of fire would require walking the perimeter edge and digging up hot spots to confirm there was no fire activity.

“It is tough grunt work,” he said.

Next steps were working on how to manage the situation going forward, he said.

Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero, a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.

– Published by EveningReport.nz and AsiaPacificReport.nz, see: MIL OSI in partnership with Radio New Zealand

Short staffing directly led to man’s death from fall in Taranaki Base Hospital ED, coroner rules

Source: Radio New Zealand

A coroner says the risk of catastrophic events happening at Taranaki Base Hospital’s Emergency Department remains high. Google Maps

A coroner has warned that five years after the death of a “sociable” and “straight-talking” former publican at Taranaki Base Hospital’s Emergency Department, the risk of catastrophic events happening there remains high.

Hāwera man Leonard Collett died following a fall at the ED in July 2020, aged 78, after being admitted with shortnesss of breath.

An inquest was held into his death in September.

Coroner Ian Telford found the primary cause of death was bleeding from injuries caused by the fall, which ultimately led to terminal cardiac arrest.

He said Collett’s fall was both “foreseeable and preventable” and shortcomings in the nursing care provided in the ED – which was 15 full-time staff short and five patients over capacity at the time – directly contributed to his fall

There was evidence that significant changes had not been made and the risk of another ‘catastrophic event’ occurring remained high.

In a statement provided to the inquest and reproduced in full in the Coroner’s finding, Collett’s wife, Vicky, said “everyone knew Leonard as ‘Lenny’ or ‘Len’ and that she called him Len”.

The couple, who were married 39 years and had a blended family with four children, got into the pub business in New Plymouth 1976.

“We started at the Breakwater Tavern and had a real mix of patrons including all the ‘wharfies’. Len was well liked and respected by everyone. Len had a great sense of humour and a real way with words.

“He was sociable but a straight talker as well. He treated everyone the same regardless of their background. I remember that in our first week there Len had to jump the bar seven times to sort things out! It wasn’t unusual to have the bar full by 11 each morning.”

The couple took over the Ngāmotu Tavern in New Plymouth and Rahotu Tavern before retiring from the pub business about 20 years ago.

Collett was then employed at Works Infrastructure and the Manaia waste management centre, before retiring aged 67 due to health problems.

On the afternoon of 16 July 2020, Collett was referred to Hāwera Hospital by his GP Dr R Bruce, who arranged for an ambulance.

Collett had become increasingly short of breath over the preceding two weeks and had low haemoglobin.

Ambulance staff decided instead to take him to Taranaki Base Hospital ED and he arrived at about 5.30pm, was triaged and taken to a bed space.

At around 10.10pm, while waiting to be transferred to the ward, Collett was seen struggling to get back to bed after visiting the toilet (unassisted).

A nurse went to get him a wheelchair. However, he was then seen sitting on the end of the bed.

Around a minute later, a loud noise was heard, and Collett was found on the floor. It was immediately assessed that he was in a critical condition.

Emergency treatment, then resuscitation, was started immediately.

Unfortunately, despite extensive efforts, he could not be revived, and one of the attending doctors formally verified Collett’s death.

An internal inquiry into Collett’s death found that the fall was preventable, the falls assessment protocol was not followed, and a falls risk assessment was not completed.

At the time, the Emergency Department was five patients “over capacity”.

A review recommended a falls risk assessment on all patients be undertaken within two hours in the ED and six hours in wards, as per the updated policy.

An audit was to be completed within six months – to show at least 90 percent compliance – while a “falls icon” was also to be used on the department’s whiteboard to improve awareness of potential falls risk to patients.

In his findings, Coroner Telford noted that a falls risk assessment had not been implemented by February 2024 and there was no evidence of a further audit being done within the six month timeframe.

After considering the evidence of an expert witness on nursing practice and the prevention of falls, the coroner found the nursing assessment of falls risk was either inadequate or entirely absent, and there was a failure to implement appropriate interventions and monitoring to safeguard someone as vulnerable as Collett.

Coroner Telford said oral evidence given at the inquest provided some assurance that improvements to nursing processes were underway and continued to be developed.

“However, it was evident that such changes will have only limited impact unless and until the broader systemic issues are also addressed.

“Put simply, if this Emergency Department continues to operate without adequate staffing and an appropriate skill mix to safely care for and monitor patients, the risk of another catastrophic event occurring remains high.

“At the very least, it is hoped that Len’s case puts a face to the consequences of consciously deciding to operate an ED with 15 fewer full-time staff than it has been assessed as requiring.”

Coroner Telford said Collett’s death, and the trauma surrounding it, continued to be deeply felt by his wife, family, and all who knew and loved him.

“HNZ Taranaki has advised me that those involved in this incident were significantly affected. I accept this without hesitation and recognise that, in the context of the ongoing under-resourcing described [in evidence], some staff members may be left questioning their role and future within a healthcare system that is in such urgent need of their dedication and expertise.”

Coroner Telford said although resourcing issues were well known, a copy of his findings would be provided to the Ministry of Health and Health New Zealand and likewise to the Nursing Council and the New Zealand Nurses Organisation.

He made a raft of recommendations including:

  • That ED’s nursing admission documentation have its Falls Risk Assessment section revised to align with expert evidence and literature in a way that leads to the clear identification of risk status.
  • Its Fall Prevention Actions Taken section be revised and simplified to reflect the recording of nursing actions should be individualised, clear, easily read, and identifiable. This section should also record that risks and actions have been communicated to the patient and family.
  • Adapt the admissions documentation and departmental policy to require nurses to routinely assess falls risk at triage or at the same time as their primary assessment when patients are received into the treatment area.
  • Revise current policy and provide educational opportunities for all staff to foster a culture in which falls risks are communicated to patients, family and amongst staff members using direct, focussed, and targeted language.

Heath NZ Taranaki has welcomed the recommendations and intends to incorporate them.

Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero, a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.

– Published by EveningReport.nz and AsiaPacificReport.nz, see: MIL OSI in partnership with Radio New Zealand

Harare’s street traders create their own system to survive in the city

Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Elmond Bandauko, Assistant Professor of Human Geography, University of Alberta

The informal sector has become a dominant source of livelihoods for urban residents in African cities. Within this sector, street trading is one of the most visible and vital components of urban economies.

In Zimbabwe’s capital city, too, street traders, selling clothing, snacks, fruits and vegetables, household goods, electronics and many other products, are a dominant feature in the economy. As in most African cities, the majority of Harare’s traders operate without licences, and they are often victims of municipal raids and displacements. Yet, despite this hostile environment, street trading continues to flourish.

How do traders organise themselves in such a difficult setting? Who decides who sells where? And how is order maintained in a space where the state’s control is weak or repressive?

I am an urban geographer whose work focuses on urban informality and governance in African cities. These questions are at the heart of a study that was part of my doctoral research on urban governance and the spatial politics of street traders in Harare. I am especially interested in how the urban poor wield their individual and collective agency to challenge urban exclusion.

Drawing on interviews and focus groups with traders in Harare’s central business district, the research explores the invisible systems of informal governance that regulate access to trading spaces. The study shows that street trading is structured by its own internal rules, norms and power relations.

Informality is not the absence of order. It is a different kind of order, rooted in everyday negotiation, social trust, and the shared struggle to survive in an unequal city.

I concluded that city authorities and others should recognise that these informal governance systems are legitimate, and can even be useful when it comes to formalising activities in the city. Ignoring them could lead to conflict and deeper inequalities.

Systems of organisation

Zimbabwe’s economy as a whole has been unstable over the past four decades. As a result, the informal economy has become very important. The relationship between urban authorities and street traders has always been antagonistic, however. That conflict has been the focus of most of the research on street trading. Harare’s city officials, like those in many other African cities, often treat traders as illegal, criminal, or a threat to “modern” urban order.

My research takes a different view: I shift attention away from state repression to the everyday systems of organisation and control that traders themselves have developed.

I conducted 19 semi-structured interviews and three focus groups with traders, to learn about their individual strategies and shared social mechanisms for keeping order on the streets.

Traders in Harare use informal governance mechanisms – unwritten rules, social norms and personal relationships – to decide who can occupy which space, for how long, and under what conditions. These community-based systems are built on mutual recognition and trust, but also shaped by hierarchy, gender and seniority.

Claiming and defending space

The interviews reveal that the most important rule for maintaining order is consistency. Traders often stay in the same spot for years – sometimes decades – to build customer loyalty and to assert their informal claim.

As one vendor explained:

I stay in the same spot so that people always know where to find me … When everyone sticks to their usual place, it reduces disputes.

This practice, described by another scholar, Asef Bayat, as “quiet encroachment”, involves small, everyday acts of claiming space without formal permission. Over time, these acts become socially recognised by other traders and even by local residents or shopkeepers. If a new vendor tries to take over someone’s space, existing traders usually intervene before conflict escalates.

As one woman put it:

No one can just occupy the space without our permission.

This peer-enforced control system maintains order but also reinforces informal hierarchies.

Leadership and street apprenticeship

Although there are no official leaders, senior traders – those with long experience or strong social influence – often act as custodians of space. They mediate disputes, mentor newcomers and enforce unspoken rules.

alt
Market, Harare.
Shack Dwellers International, Wikimedia Commons, CC BY

New entrants typically undergo an informal “street apprenticeship”, during which they learn how to operate, when to display goods, how to evade municipal police, and whom to approach for protection. Newcomers cannot simply choose a spot and start selling. They must seek the approval of those already established. This process reflects an internalised authority system rooted in social norms rather than written law.

Social networks and inheritance

The study also uncovers how social capital – networks of trust, kinship and friendship – plays a central role in accessing space.

Many traders gain their first selling spot through relatives or friends who are already part of the informal economy. In this way, street trading becomes an intergenerational practice, often “inherited” from parents or grandparents.

One participant explained that her grandmother had traded in the same area for decades, and when she lost her formal job, she joined the family business. Others said they felt morally obliged to reserve a deceased vendor’s spot for their children or relatives.




Read more:
Ethiopian quarter: how migrants have shaped a thriving shopping district in South Africa’s city of gold


Competition and exclusion

However, these systems are not equal or fair. Power among traders is unevenly distributed. Long-term vendors and those with strong social connections often dominate lucrative areas, while newcomers (especially young people, women and persons with disabilities) struggle to gain a foothold.

For example, male traders often control spots near busy transport hubs, which are more profitable but also riskier. Women, who are concerned about safety or need to balance caregiving duties, tend to occupy less visible areas. One visually impaired trader said he relied on others to protect his spot, showing how trust and vulnerability shape spatial access.




Read more:
Why do identical informal businesses set up side by side? It’s a survival tactic – Kenya study


There are also reports of traders using aggressive tactics to defend their territory. Some long-time vendors admitted to “chasing away” new sellers or even tipping off municipal officers to get competitors arrested. These practices reveal how informal governance can both protect livelihoods and reproduce exclusion.

Everyday politics and quiet power

My study shows that power in Harare’s informal economy is not only top-down, from the state to the traders, but also horizontal, negotiated among the traders themselves.

Those with seniority or strong networks act as gatekeepers, deciding who can sell where. Women traders often face verbal or physical harassment from male counterparts but also develop their own strategies of resistance: confronting aggressors, forming alliances, or using moral arguments about fairness to defend their right to trade. These acts of quiet defiance demonstrate that informal governance is a site of both control and agency.




Read more:
How the informal economy solves some urban challenges in a Zimbabwean town


Beyond stereotypes of chaos

What emerges from this research is a more nuanced picture of Harare’s informal economy. Street traders are not simply victims of a repressive state or chaotic actors in an unregulated market. They are also self-organising agents who build complex systems of order, reciprocity and social regulation in the absence of formal protection.

At the same time, these systems are not utopian. They involve competition, hierarchy and exclusion. Informal governance is both a survival mechanism and a structure of power.

Understanding this duality is crucial for policymakers who wish to design fairer urban policies.

The Conversation

Elmond Bandauko works at the University of Alberta as an Assistant Professor of Human Geography. He received funding from the Social Sciences and Humanities Research Council of Canada (SSHRC), International Development Research Centre (IDRC) and the International Journal of Urban and Research (IJURR) Foundation to conduct this research.

ref. Harare’s street traders create their own system to survive in the city – https://theconversation.com/harares-street-traders-create-their-own-system-to-survive-in-the-city-268996

SAS forces used in search for fugitive father Tom Phillips, military confirms

Source: Radio New Zealand

One of the campsites Tom Phillips lived in with his children. RNZ / Supplied / Police

The military has confirmed members of its elite special forces were used to search for fugitive father Tom Phillips and his children.

Phillps was shot by police on 8 September – four years after he disappeared with the family in December 2021.

The defence force has confirmed members of the SAS were involved in the search for Phillips and his children on three occasions.

It said the service usually operated overseas, but in this case it was cleared to help Police.

The Herald reported that up to four SAS members – including expert trackers – helped police search for the family in remote Waikato bush in 2024 and 2025.

Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero, a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.

– Published by EveningReport.nz and AsiaPacificReport.nz, see: MIL OSI in partnership with Radio New Zealand

National ticketing system on public transport rolls out in Christchurch

Source: Radio New Zealand

Te first stage of the $1.4 billion National Ticketing Solution’s latest iteration, known as Motu Move, has been launched in Christchurch. RNZ / Nate McKinnon

When the New Zealand Transport Agency signed off on an integrated national ticketing system in 2009, John Key was prime minister, Avatar ruled at the box office and a pound of butter cost about $3.60.

After more than 16 years, the first stage of the $1.4 billion National Ticketing Solution’s (NTS) latest iteration, known as Motu Move, was launched on Monday in Christchurch, rolling out contactless payment options on bus and ferry services across Greater Christchurch.

The option to pay with contactless debit or credit cards and digital payments like Apple Pay and Google Pay on phones or smart watches on buses and ferries will work on three hundred buses across Christchurch, Waimakariri and Selwyn, but only for those paying full fare.

A system to enable concession holders to pay less and the Motu Move cards themselves have been relegated to later stages.

RNZ / Nate McKinnon

The programme, a partnership between the NZTA, Auckland Transport and a dozen regional and city councils – will be rolled out in Wellington next, and it’s hoped the whole country (except for Marlborough and the West Coast) will be part of the long awaited integrated system by the end of 2027.

Following repeated delays and a critical independent review earlier in the year, the planned launch in Timaru and Temuka was scrapped in favour of a phased approach, which saw the launch relocated to Christchurch.

It was also downsized to just the first phase, contactless payment, after delays to “some of the more complex system components” saw the rollout changed to “a phased approach”, according to NZTA.

Transport Minister Chris Bishop. RNZ / Nick Monro

The NTS was slated to be launched in South Canterbury in 2024, but by the middle of this year, Transport Minister Chris Bishop weighed in, saying the project was facing technology, delivery and governance issues and was “not on track”.

Bishop said nothing was “off the table”, as consultants conducted an independent review of the project.

Councils in Auckland and Wellington raised concerns, and some councillors publicly mused about pulling out of the scheme.

The wide-ranging – though heavily redacted – review was released in September.

It raised concerns about the capacity of the US multinational transport and defence contractor delivering the system, Cubic Corporation, and stated the company “must commit additional global expertise dedicated to the programme”.

The review found deficiencies in a number of areas including poor communication, “optimism bias” from some senior programme leaders, limited public transport and ticketing knowledge, slow decision making, the “urgent need” to support legacy fare collection systems, pressure on budgets and the “very high likelihood of further significant delays”.

In the meantime, a pilot of contactless payment options on Christchurch’s Airport to City bus – which began in December 2024 – saw more than a third of adult passengers using the debit or credit card option.

Canterbury Regional Council chair Dr Deon Swiggs. RNZ / Nate McKinnon

Canterbury Regional Council chair Dr Deon Swiggs said the launch had been a long time coming.

“We are proud Canterbury has taken a lead role in this nationally significant evolution of a payment system in New Zealand.

“Our region has a history of contributing nationally to public transport innovation and we are pleased to be trusted with the first step of the national ticketing system.”

Swiggs said more than 500 people had already taken advantage of the new payment system by the time he addressed the launch at 1pm.

Previously, using cash to pay instead of a Metrocard incurred an extra dollar charge.

The project had seen the regional council work closely with central government, Cubic, bus and ferry operators and other regional councils.

Swiggs acknowledged the complex programme of work hadn’t been “always easy”, but said strong relationships and customer focus had got the launch over the line.

“We wanted to get the base functionality right – because we’ve been saying this is coming, this is coming, this is coming – so with the vendor, we’ve said let’s get the base functionality right, get people used to tapping on, the new system – you’ve got the dual system at the moment – get people used to interacting with it.”

Concession holders will have to continue to use their Metrocards until the next phase of the project is rolled out.

Card readers allowing users to ‘tag off’ will be introduced in later stages, as will a physical Motu Move card.

The card would allow those who cannot or will not use bank cards or digital payments to continue to load money onto a card once the Metrocards are defunct, NZTA chief customer and services officer Sarina Pratley said.

“We want to make sure public transport is accessible to everybody – there are unbanked people… also students who may not have a bank card and also people who just prefer not to [use a debit or credit card].”

New Zealand would be the third country with a national ticketing system, along with the Netherlands and Singapore, Pratley said.

It was hoped making payment easier would encourage more use of public transport, and provide councils with “better data” on public transport use, the regional council said in a statement.

Cubic has previously declined to answer questions from RNZ on what data it would collect after concerns were raised by privacy advocates in the United States about the collection and use of data gathered by the company.

Peace organisations called on the government to cancel the deal when it was announced in 2022.

The group’s criticised the use of tax dollars to a company whose defence arm, Cubic Surveillance and Reconnaissance, developed intelligence systems for US Special Operations drones.

Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero, a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.

– Published by EveningReport.nz and AsiaPacificReport.nz, see: MIL OSI in partnership with Radio New Zealand

View from The Hill: Albanese says Whitlam’s dismisssal ‘calculated plot’; Liberals consumed by current battle

Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Michelle Grattan, Professorial Fellow, University of Canberra

Anthony Albanese has denounced Gough Whitlam’s dismissal from office in 1975 as “a calculated plot, hatched by conservative forces which sacrificed conventions and institutions in the pursuit of power”.

Albanese said the election that followed – won by Malcolm Fraser in a landslide – did “not wash any of that away”.

The prime minister was speaking during a conference at Old Parliament House to mark the 50th anniversary of the November 11 1975 sacking of the Labor government by then governor-general, Sir John Kerr.

Albanese said the Fraser opposition had preyed on Kerr’s “desire to be at the centre of events”. It also “cultivated his paranoia, his fear that Whitlam was planning to replace him,” he said.

The Coalition had been aided by Whitlam’s “unshakeable belief – right up until the moment he was handed the letter of dismissal – that Kerr was a proper person, who would do the right thing”.

Albanese said the 1975 crisis was a “partisan political ambush”, not a constitutional crisis.

Despite what happened to him, Whitlam remained an optimist about what our democracy could achieve, he said.

“And, in a remarkable lesson to anyone in public life who might be tempted to hold on to resentment or bitterness he rebuilt a friendship with Malcolm Fraser.

“When we think of those two giants now, we remember them campaigning for a Republic together.

“Or we picture that line up of former prime ministers on the morning of the National Apology to the Stolen Generations, with Gough’s hand resting on Malcolm’s shoulder.”

The current Governor-General, Sam Mostyn, has said she would not behave as Kerr had done.

“I would not act in that way,” she said in an interview with The Australian.

“I don’t believe a governor-general should ever be in the business of surprising a prime minister.”

“If a government starts to behave irresponsibly, the role of the governor-general will be to have those conversations with the prime minister, with the ministers of the crown, early enough to say ‘there’s trouble ahead’,”she said.

“The holder of this office is there to protect the Australian public against the potential of irresponsible government,” Mostyn said.

Albanese announced the government will commission a statue of Whitlam.

Liberal moderates up the ante in climate war

As Labor looks back on a dramatic turning point in its history the Liberals, still shattered by their worst-ever election rout, are focused on the here-and-now of a defining policy struggle over climate.

Liberal moderates are publicly conducting a rear guard action against the conservatives’ strong push to totally scrap any reference to net zero.

The moderates accept the present commitment net zero by 2050 will be dropped from Liberal policy. But they want some reference to net zero retained, in terms of aspiration or pushed into the future.

On Monday moderate senator Maria Kovacic, shadow assistant minister to opposition leader, Sussan Ley, said: “I’m on the record as being someone who supports our commitments to net zero”.

She said those who wanted the words net zero removed at any cost were focused on “the ideology of that rather than what we are going =to do about the grid”.

The opposition needed to talk to those Australians who had moved away from it – they lived in metropolitan cities, she said.

She also criticised conservative senator Sarah Henderson’s attack last week on Ley, whom Henderson said was losing support. “My view is that we back in our leader”, Kovacic said. Henderson’s comments were not helpful and “unnessary”.

On Sunday another moderate, Senator Andrew Bragg, mounted a strong defence of net zero. “You can’t have a fatwa on two words. This is the international standard,” he said on the ABC. “Trying to pretend that you’re not going to say two words is absolutely ridiculous.”

On the other side of the debate, opposition communications spokeswoman Melissa McIntosh, who is member for the Sydney seat of Lindsay, said she had surveyed her community and “my community is super strong on not wanting net zero. It is killing them,” she said.

“They don’t want net zero, they are struggling under energy prices. Small businesses are closing, manufacturers are closing. I think this is a really important position for us to make and I hope we do the right thing by the Australian people.”

The Conversation

Michelle Grattan does not work for, consult, own shares in or receive funding from any company or organisation that would benefit from this article, and has disclosed no relevant affiliations beyond their academic appointment.

ref. View from The Hill: Albanese says Whitlam’s dismisssal ‘calculated plot’; Liberals consumed by current battle – https://theconversation.com/view-from-the-hill-albanese-says-whitlams-dismisssal-calculated-plot-liberals-consumed-by-current-battle-269395

New Pacific Media journal launched in APMN and USP partnership

Asia Pacific Media Network

Pacific Media, a new regional research journal, made its debut today with a collection of papers on issues challenging the future, such as independent journalism amid “intensifying geostrategic competition”.

The papers have been largely drawn from an inaugural Pacific International Media conference hosted by The University of the South Pacific in the Fiji capital Suva in July last year.

“It was the first Pacific media conference of its kind in 20 years, convened to address the unprecedented shifts and challenges facing the region’s media systems,” said conference coordinator and edition editor Dr Shailendra Singh, associate professor in journalism at USP.

The cover of the first edition of Pacific Media. Image: PM

“These include pressures arising from governance and political instability, intensifying geostrategic competition—particularly between China and the United States—climate change and environmental degradation, as well as the profound impacts of digital disruption and the COVID-19 pandemic.”

Topics included in the volume include “how critical journalism can survive” in the Pacific; “reporting the nuclear Pacific”; “Behind the mic” with Talking Point podcaster Sashi Singh, the “coconut wireless” and community news in Hawai’i,; women’s political empowerment in the Asia Pacific; “weaponising the partisan WhatsApp group in Indonesia; and “mapping the past to navigate the future” in a major Pacific Islands News Association (PINA) publishing project.

Other contributors include journalists and media academics from Australia and New Zealand featuring a “Blood on the tracks” case study in investigative journalism practice, and digital weather media coverage in the Pacific.

This inaugural publication of Pacific Media has been produced jointly by The University of the South Pacific and the New Zealand-based Asia Pacific Media Network (APMN), with Dr Amit Sarwal, one of the conference organisers, joining Dr Singh as co-editor.

Designer is Pacific Journalism Review’s Del Abcede.

APMN managing editor Dr David Robie welcomed the new publication, saying “this journal will carry on the fine and innovative research mahi (work) established by Pacific Journalism Review during a remarkable 30 years contributing to the region”.

It ceased publication last year, but is still ranked as a Q2 journal by SCOPUS.

Associate Professor Shailendra Singh (left) and Dr Amit Sarwal. Image: PM

The new journal will open up some new doors for community participation.

Both the PJR and PM research archives are in the public domain at the Tuwhera digital collection at Auckland University of Technology.

Khairaih A Rahman has been appointed by APMN as Pacific Media editor and her first edition with a collection of papers from the Asian Congress for Media and Communication (ACMC) conference in Vietnam last October will also be published shortly.

Published with permission from Asia Pacific Media Network.

Article by AsiaPacificReport.nz

Nine rangatahi Māori depart for the Brazillian Amazon for COP30

Source: Radio New Zealand

Te Kāhu Pokere outside Parliament. Supplied/Pou Take Āhuarangi

A group of nine rangatahi Māori are making their final preparations to depart for Belém in the Brazillian Amazon to represent their iwi and Aotearoa at the 30th United Nations Climate Change Conference (COP30).

The group Te Kāhu Pōkere, established under Pou Take Āhuarangi the climate change arm of the National Iwi Chairs Forum and is the first iwi-mandated Māori youth delegation to attend a global COP.

While world leaders come together to negotiate COP also includes an outer zone with business leaders, young people, climate scientists and Indigenous Peoples sharing their perspectives.

Delegate Kyla Campbell-Kamariera told Morning Report that Te Kāhu Pokere will be part of those conversations, especially sharing stories and solutions to the climate crisis with indigenous peoples.

“Indigineous peoples have been doing this work for hundreds and thousands of years so it’s nothing new to each of us.”

The group is not part of the official New Zealand government delegation at COP but will spend some time with Minister for Climate Change Simon Watts at the conference, she said.

“We’ve met with the minister and some of his officials a few times prior to heading to COP as well so there is some alignment there but he also is understanding that there are some challenges between Māori-Crown solutions and our delegation is absolutely one hundred percent in support of spreading the stories and the strategies and the solutions of Māori.”

Campbell-Kamariera said each of the delegates comes from different perspectives across each of their iwi and so provide different strategies and solutions, but for her it was about whakapapa.

“We whakapapa to the land, to the sea, to the sky, and that’s really important to show the commitment that we have to climate justice and the climate crisis is that if we view the land and the sea and the sky as our relation, we look after them as if it were a brother or a sister or a mother or a father.”

It was about reiterating that kaitiakitanga is climate justice, she said.

Campbell-Kamariera said after four months of preparation the group will begin their travels on Monday night, arriving in Belém early on Wednesday morning New Zealand time.

While backed by Pou Take Āhuarangi the group are self-funded, with most of the financial backing coming from their iwi.

Te Kāhu Pōkere delegates:

– Harris Moana (Waikato-Tainui, Ngāti Maniapoto)

– Te Rina Porou (Ngāti Tūwharetoa, Ngāti Porou, Te Aitanga-a-Māhaki)

– Waimarama Hawke (Ngāti Whātua Orākei)

– Shannon Mihaere (Rangitāne o Tamaki nui-ā-Rua, Ngāti Porou, Ngai Tai ki Tāmaki)

– Taane Aruka Te Aho (Ngāti Korokī Kahukura, Te Whānau-ā-Apanui, Te Aitanga-a-Māhaki)

– Aaria Rolleston (Ngāi Tahu, Ngāi Te Rangi)

– Kyla Campbell-Kamariera (Te Rarawa Kaiwhare, Taranaki Tūturu)

– Macy Duxfield (Ngaa Rauru, Te Ātihaunui-a-Pāpārangi)

– Tahua Pihema (Te Aitanga-a-Māhaki, Ngāti Whātua Nui Tonu)

Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero, a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.

– Published by EveningReport.nz and AsiaPacificReport.nz, see: MIL OSI in partnership with Radio New Zealand

Contactless payments on public transport rolls out in Christchurch

Source: Radio New Zealand

Unsplash

When the New Zealand Transport Agency signed off on an integrated national ticketing system in 2009, John Key was prime minister, Avatar ruled at the box office and a pound of butter cost around $3.60.

After more than 16 years, the first stage of the $1.4 billion National Ticketing Solution’s (NTS) latest iteration, known as Motu Move, was launched on Monday in Christchurch, rolling out contactless payment options on bus and ferry services across Greater Christchurch.

The option to pay with contactless debit or credit cards and digital payments like Apple Pay and Google Pay on phones or smart watches on buses and ferries will work on three hundred buses across Christchurch, Waimakariri and Selwyn, but only for those paying full fare.

A system to enable concession holders to pay less and the Motu Move cards themselves have been relegated to later stages.

The programme, a partnership between the NZTA, Auckland Transport and a dozen regional and city councils – will be rolled out in Wellington next, and it’s hoped the whole country (except for Marlborough and the West Coast) will be part of the long awaited integrated system by the end of 2027.

Following repeated delays and a critical independent review earlier in the year, the planned launch in Timaru and Temuka was scrapped in favour of a phased approach, which saw the launch relocated to Christchurch.

It was also downsized to just the first phase, contactless payment, after delays to “some of the more complex system components” saw the rollout changed to “a phased approach”, according to NZTA.

Transport Minister Chris Bishop. RNZ / Nick Monro

The NTS was slated to be launched in South Canterbury in 2024, but by the middle of this year, Transport Minister Chris Bishop weighed in, saying the project was facing technology, delivery and governance issues and was “not on track”.

Bishop said nothing was “off the table”, as consultants conducted an independent review of the project.

Councils in Auckland and Wellington raised concerns, and some councillors publicly mused about pulling out of the scheme.

The wide-ranging – though heavily redacted – review was released in September.

It raised concerns about the capacity of the US multinational transport and defence contractor delivering the system, Cubic Corporation, and stated the company “must commit additional global expertise dedicated to the programme”.

The review found deficiencies in a number of areas including poor communication, “optimism bias” from some senior programme leaders, limited public transport and ticketing knowledge, slow decision making, the “urgent need” to support legacy fare collection systems, pressure on budgets and the “very high likelihood of further significant delays”.

In the meantime, a pilot of contactless payment options on Christchurch’s Airport to City bus – which began in December 2024 – saw more than a third of adult passengers using the debit or credit card option.

Canterbury Regional Council chair Dr Deon Swiggs. RNZ / Nate McKinnon

Canterbury Regional Council chair Dr Deon Swiggs said the launch had been a long time coming.

“We are proud Canterbury has taken a lead role in this nationally significant evolution of a payment system in New Zealand.

“Our region has a history of contributing nationally to public transport innovation and we are pleased to be trusted with the first step of the national ticketing system.”

Swiggs said more than 500 people had already taken advantage of the new payment system by the time he addressed the launch at 1pm.

Previously, using cash to pay instead of a Metrocard incurred an extra dollar charge.

The project had seen the regional council work closely with central government, Cubic, bus and ferry operators and other regional councils.

Swiggs acknowledged the complex programme of work hadn’t been “always easy”, but said strong relationships and customer focus had got the launch over the line.

“We wanted to get the base functionality right – because we’ve been saying this is coming, this is coming, this is coming – so with the vendor, we’ve said let’s get the base functionality right, get people used to tapping on, the new system – you’ve got the dual system at the moment – get people used to interacting with it.”

Concession holders will have to continue to use their Metrocards until the next phase of the project is rolled out.

Card readers allowing users to ‘tag off’ will be introduced in later stages, as will a physical Motu Move card.

The card would allow those who cannot or will not use bank cards or digital payments to continue to load money onto a card once the Metrocards are defunct, NZTA chief customer and services officer Sarina Pratley said.

“We want to make sure public transport is accessible to everybody – there are unbanked people… also students who may not have a bank card and also people who just prefer not to [use a debit or credit card].”

New Zealand would be the third country with a national ticketing system, along with the Netherlands and Singapore, Pratley said.

It was hoped making payment easier would encourage more use of public transport, and provide councils with “better data” on public transport use, the regional council said in a statement.

Cubic has previously declined to answer questions from RNZ on what data it would collect after concerns were raised by privacy advocates in the United States about the collection and use of data gathered by the company.

Peace organisations called on the government to cancel the deal when it was announced in 2022.

The group’s criticised the use of tax dollars to a company whose defence arm, Cubic Surveillance and Reconnaissance, developed intelligence systems for US Special Operations drones.

Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero, a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.

– Published by EveningReport.nz and AsiaPacificReport.nz, see: MIL OSI in partnership with Radio New Zealand

Tongariro fire: Threatened species in area ‘so unique, sacred and spectacular’

Source: Radio New Zealand

The Tongariro National Park is home to a range of threatened plants, butterflies and moths. Supplied / Max Rayner

The Department of Conservation (DOC) says Tongariro National Park is home to threatened species of flora and insects, as fire-fighters wait to see if a wildfire in the area has really been extinguished.

Fire and Emergency said an observation flight this afternoon has found “no visible signs of fire” after rainfall in the area.

But the impact on biodiversity was expected to be significant.

DOC director terrestrial biodiversity Tim Bamford told Checkpoint the park is home to threatened species.

“It’s home to a range of threatened plants, such as orchids, and also a range of threatened butterflies and moths as well,” he said.

“But it is a resilient environment and it’s been shaped by a range of volcanic activity and fires over the last few hundred years.”

Bamford said there were birds living in the edges of the area – such as New Zealand falcon and whio – but they were feeling positive they would have flown away to escape the blaze.

Bamford hoped the area will regenerate over the next few years, but had concerns about weeds over taking native bush.

“The species in there and the plants are generally quite slow growing, whereas invasive weeds like heather, and broom, and gorse, are really fast growing,” he said.

He said they wanted to put monitoring in place to understand what vegetation was re-establishing in the area, and to make a plan if it were the invasive weeds, to stop them spreading

“That will really smother the plants and the species that make this place so unique, sacred and spectacular.”

Bamford said there was a conversation to be had about restoring the scorched area, including how long walking tracks would remain closed.

Ngāti Hikairo ki Tongariro has placed two rahui on parts of the national park, in which the wildfire has burnt through more than 2500 hectares.

The first covers the Tongariro Alpine Crossing and will remain in place for a week.

The second applies to any burnt areas, and will remain in place for an extended period to allow the land to regrow and heal.

“Given the slow growing environment, I think there is a conversation for restoration, about what that looks like, so in terms of access to infrastructure, and for people, to the park, that’s seven days, and the 10-year rahui is focused around allowing the land to regrow and heal through restoration of that environment rather than the use of it,” Bamford said.

‘It looks out’ – thermal imaging to check hotspots

Fire and Emergency told Checkpoint they would be doing thermal imagery of Tongariro National Park tonight to see if the blaze that left more than 2800 hectares in ashes is truly out.

An observation flight this afternoon has found “no visible signs of fire” after rainfall in the area.

Ground crews have also been working on the flanks of the fire to strengthen the containment lines.

Incident controller Nigel Dravitzki said favourable conditions had reduced the blaze.

“Visibly, it looks out,” he said.

“We’re doing thermal imaging drones over it tonight to see if we can pick up any activity or hotspots that we can’t see.”

Concerns raised for wildlife welfare

DOC’s Damian Coutts said the impact on biodiversity was going to be significant.

“It’s going to take us weeks once we can get our ecologists in to really understand that,” Coutts said.

He said he did not know when the national park’s facilities will reopen.

Meanwhile, the charitable foundation that manages the Kaimanawa wild horses said they were in no danger at present from the massive blaze on the Central Plateau.

In a social media post, the Kaimanawa Legacy Foundation said it had received many messages asking if the herd was safe.

It confirmed there was no immediate threat to their habitat.

The fire was about 30 kilometres from the horses’ territory, and they were monitoring the situation closely

Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero, a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.

– Published by EveningReport.nz and AsiaPacificReport.nz, see: MIL OSI in partnership with Radio New Zealand

Cyclone Gabrielle inquest: Timing of emergency mobile alert explained

Source: Radio New Zealand

Images of those who died in relation to the cyclone are on display in the courtroom. RNZ / Alexa Cook

The man in charge of the emergency response during Cyclone Gabrielle in Hawke’s Bay was worried about putting people in danger if he issued an evacuation alert earlier, a coronial inquiry has heard.

‘The last safe moment to evacuate may have already passed’

The acting group controller for Civil Defence in Hawke’s Bay has explained why he did not issue an emergency evacuation alert to residents earlier in the night.

He said there was a lack of information and it was hard to get a reliable picture of what was happening due to the darkness, so they agreed the best option was for people to “shelter in place”.

Lennan admitted he was “aware that there were significant gaps” in his “situational awareness”. He feared that issuing an EMA “was the more dangerous course of action”.

His reasoning was that an EMA would not be any help to people already experiencing significant flooding or anyone who had climbed onto their roofs, and worried it may lead to people putting themselves into danger by trying to drive when there was a risk of slips, falling trees and being trapped in floodwaters.

“I considered that it was possible that the last safe moment to evacuate may have already passed, without anyone involved in the emergency response realising that was the case,” said Lennan.

The entire Esk Valley began filling with fast flowing floodwaters during the storm. Supplied / NZDF

Last month the inquest heard from the hydrologist in charge of flood forecasting during the deadly Cyclone, who could not explain why it took two hours for him to tell Civil Defence about a failure with the river level monitoring equipment due to a power outage.

The third week of the Hawke’s Bay phase of the inquest began this morning with Land Search and Rescue capability and development manager Edaan Lennan giving evidence.

When Cyclone Gabrielle struck the region on 13 February 2023, Lennan was employed by Hawke’s Bay Regional Council (HBRC) in Hawke’s Bay Civil Defence Emergency Management (HBCDEM) Group Emergency Management Office.

Because the main group controller for civil defence, Ian Macdonald, was away on leave during the cyclone, he put Edaan Lennan and Iain Maxwell into the top role in his absence.

An EMA (Emergency Mobile Alert), was not issued for Esk Valley until 5:19am on 14 February, by which time two people had already drowned and many more residents were clutching onto their rooftops, desperately hoping to be rescued.

Damage from Cyclone Gabrielle in Hawke’s Bay RNZ/ Alexa Cook

Lennan told the court that at some point between 3am and 3.30am on 14 February, he held an emergency style meeting with local civil defence controllers and the emergency services to decide what to do next.

The decision was made not to issue an EMA at that point. Although the coroner’s lawyer Nick Whittington pointed out that an email at 2.10am from the hydrologist clearly told civil defence the Esk River was at the highest level ever recorded.

“Is that not a clear indication that what ever it looks like out there… the predictions are out the window?

“Was there no consideration of sending an EMA at this point?” asked Whittington.

“Not that I recall”, said Lennan.

Lennan said “you wouldn’t want to send an EMA without understanding what was happening on the ground”, but Whittington disagreed. He queried whether residents could have been sent a message about the record river levels.

“Isn’t this a wake up call? Don’t they need to be alerted to the fact this is going on?” said the lawyer.

Lennan agreed they could have possibly issued the mobile alert earlier to inform residents about the situation, but he also believes evacuating people in the middle of the night could have put people in harm’s way.

Edaan Lennan giving evidence in the Cyclone Gabrielle Coronial Inquiry RNZ / Alexa Cook

A state of emergency was not declared until about 4am on 14 February, and Whittington questioned Lennan about whether there was a link between civil defence waiting for an emergency declaration before issuing an EMA.

Lennan was hesitant to say if that was the case, instead pointing to the risk of issuing too many emergency mobile alerts, saying it can cause anxiety and result in a less responsive public response.

“You can create a lot of harm to society in over-alerting… or create independence on an alerting system,” he said.

Whittington pressed him further, asking if civil defence has a pre-conceived view that a mobile alert should only come after a declaration of emergency.

“It’s something I’ve thought about… I don’t personally think I had that pre-conception,” said Lennan.

‘Skeleton’ Civil Defence crew on overnight

On 13 February there were about 30 people in the Group Emergency Coordination Centre, but by about 10pm most of those staff had gone home or were heading home.

Lennan said they had “skeleton staff” overnight, which included himself and several liaison officers from different emergency services.

Whittington asked Lennan why there were not more staff working overnight, when the cyclone was expected to intensify.

Floodwaters in Esk Valley. Supplied

Lennan explained the complications behind using council staff for civil defence jobs.

“There are challenges with staff personal circumstances and the human factors as well, with asking, say a person employed to be a librarian – to then come in and work in an emergency coordination centre,” he said. Lennan said finding people who were willing and able to pick up civil defence shifts could be tough, for example they may have whanau or animals they need to look after, or childcare challenges.

“It’s not only that we couldn’t find people for overnight, but also that we wanted to be a bit strategic with our rest period, send people home so we could get them back early the next day,” said Lennan.

Whittington asked Lennan whether the issue of finding enough civil defence staff was a persistent issue that had never been solved.

“It’s been a continual known challenge in Hawke’s Bay and across the country,” said Lennan.

Coroner’s lawyer Nick Whittington questioning Edaan Lennan RNZ / Alexa Cook

Lennan was also questioned about a conversation with Hawke’s Bay area commander Inspector Lincoln Sycamore, in which he requested extra army unimogs to be sent from the New Zealand Defence Force’s Linton base.

Whittington said this conversation took place on Sunday, 12 February, but Lennan said he doesn’t recall it.

“I only remember talking to him once on a Friday, nothing on the Sunday.”

Whittington said Sycamore wanted extra unimogs in the region in case the cyclone struck with greater intensity than forecast.

Sycamore’s witness statement said Lennan told him that it was not necessary.

“I would like to think I was not dismissive to the head of police in Hawke’s Bay… doesn’t sound like the type of person I’d like to be,” said Lennan.

In his evidence, Lennan stated that Civil Defence was not authorised to deploy police resources.

Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero, a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.

– Published by EveningReport.nz and AsiaPacificReport.nz, see: MIL OSI in partnership with Radio New Zealand

Pilot reveals chaos amid Whakaari eruption aftermath

Source: Radio New Zealand

Whakaari/White Island eruption in December 2019 from a helicopter.

WARNING: This story includes content that may be distressing to some readers.

A helicopter pilot, who was the first civilian to land on Whakaari/White Island after its 2019 eruption, has revealed the chaos of tending to survivors while the volcano threatened to blow again.

Kahu NZ Helicopters director Robert Mark Law is giving evidence this week in Auckland at the ongoing Coroner’s Inquiry into the tragic events of 2019.

The pilot, who has military experience in the SAS, said he saw the eruption happen while he was driving between Tauranga and Whakatāne and immediately organised to fly to the active volcano and help.

He was accompanied by staff who flew other helicopters.

He ensured they carried water, gas masks, helmets and fire proof clothing they typically used when assisting in firefighting.

Once he arrived to the island and assessed the scene from the air, it was immediately apparent a strong eruption had occurred – noticing a damaged helicopter which had been blown off a helipad.

He continued to circle before noticing what looked like people on the ground.

“It was just right beside the column of ash and that’s when I started to see, you know, a lot of people, once my eye tuned into, you know, looking for humans in the ash.

“I then realised very quickly that there was a whole bunch more (people) there. I didn’t miss a beat.

“You just keep looking around and then straight away you’re thinking, okay, you know, these people, they need help.”

Law said he did not see any movement from the bodies and that he realised how challenging conditions were immediately once landing on a helipad nearest to where he could see people.

“As soon as I cracked the door open and started, you know, breathing the local environment, it was brutal. So at that stage, chucked the mask on and proceeded on towards where the folks were.

“Started walking through the ash towards where the people were, there was a lot of noise, hissing, roaring, coming from the volcano vent and obviously there was ash falling.”

Law said it was difficult to see the extent of the injuries on people.

He said the ash was a lot like talcum powder making it difficult to identify blood or wounds.

“From a distance, burn injuries weren’t as obvious because there’s a thick layer of ash on people.

“But when we got close and right down, I could see, for example, people were missing eyebrows or had no skin left on their faces.

“Once we started handling people to get them into the helicopters, it immediately became clear how serious the injuries were. Skin was separating from bodies as we lifted them up.

“Some people had full blisters down their entire limb that slipped off and or hung down when we lifted them up.”

The pilot said while he and staff were on Whakaari, the volcano was constantly making noise and ashing.

“At one point, it made a big enough noise that we were concerned it would erupt again, and we were preparing to throw ourselves over the individuals.

“It was a hell of a noise and so we both just dived down over people and then once it sort of passed and nothing happened, we looked at each other and you both could tell a bit of a sigh of relief,” he said.

Law and his co-workers from Kahu NZ Helicopters, moved through the island trying to identify the deceased and survivors.

He said they provided aid where they could by going person to person.

“Most had ash covering their faces, so I just tried to clear their mouths and noses so they could breathe. It was a very intense situation and a real mix.

“Some I could tell were clearly dead. Others I thought were in the early stages of dying. Others seemed to be in marginally better shape, but everyone was covered in ash and debris.

“When you give someone a really good old shake, get down and have a listen, because you’re down there cleaning the ash out of their mouth and trying to free up their airways, you’re looking for dust moving around their nostrils, their face, trying to feel their chest for rise, things like that.”

Law said he did have first aid experience due to his military background and had assessed people being deceased before the 2019 eruption.

He said while doing his best to triage and provide aid to survivors he was suprised to hear emergency services wouldn’t be coming.

The inquest has been told that all 39 people rescued from the island on the day of the eruption, was done entirely by civilian boats and helicopters.

He said tragically, there were instances when victims died while they were in the process of loading them into the aircraft or during the flight back to the mainland.

“I had my headset on, so things were a bit muffled by way of voice. I was looking around all the time at people and calling them.

“I had an issue with the windscreen, it was caked in ash. So I was sort of, couldn’t really see out the front properly. I was just sort of flying through the little gap and then looking out the side of the aircraft.

“The priority was just to keep talking, you know, and hopefully people responded to that voice going on in the helicopter.”

Law will continue to give evidence at the inquiry on Tuesday 11 November.

The coronial inquest in Auckland aims to re-establish the facts of the case and make findings and recommendations to prevent similar disasters.

Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero, a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.

– Published by EveningReport.nz and AsiaPacificReport.nz, see: MIL OSI in partnership with Radio New Zealand

BBC resignations over Trump scandal show the pressures on public broadcasters – and why they must resist them

Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Denis Muller, Senior Research Fellow, Centre for Advancing Journalism, The University of Melbourne

The resignations of BBC Director-General Tim Davie and CEO of BBC News Deborah Turness over dishonest editing of a speech in 2021 by US President Donald Trump raise several disturbing questions.

These concern the effectiveness and integrity of the BBC’s internal editorial procedures for investigating complaints, and the pressure being brought to bear on the BBC by conservative political and media forces in the United Kingdom.

The Trump controversy originated from the editing of a BBC Panorama documentary called “Trump: A Second Chance?” It went to air a week before the 2024 US presidential election, and contained replays of sections of the speech Trump had made to his supporters just before the insurrection in Washington on 6 January 2021.

In the speech, Trump said at one point: “We’re going to walk down to the Capitol, and we’re going to cheer our brave senators and congressmen and women.” Fifty minutes later, in the same speech, he said: “I’ll be with you. And we fight. Fight like hell.”

According to the BBC’s own account, these two quotes were spliced together to read: “We’re going to walk down to the Capitol […] and I’ll be there with you. And we fight. We fight like hell.”

The effect was to give the impression Trump was egging on his supporters to violence.

At that time, a journalist called Michael Prescott was working as an independent external adviser to the BBC’s editorial standards committee. According to The Guardian, Prescott’s appointment to this role had been pushed by a BBC board member, Robbie Gibb, who had been communications chief for the former Conservative prime minister Theresa May and had also helped set up the right-wing broadcaster GB News.

Prescott left the BBC in June 2025, but during his time there he wrote a letter to the BBC board drawing their attention to what he saw as problems of “serious and systemic” editorial bias within the broadcaster. The dishonest editing of the Trump speech was one example he gave to support his case.

He wrote that when these lapses had been brought to the attention of editorial managers, they “refused to accept there had been a breach of standards”.

That letter came into the possession of London’s Daily Telegraph, a conservative newspaper. On November 3 it published a story based on it, under the headline: “Exclusive: BBC doctored Trump speech, internal report reveals”. The sub-heading read: “Corporation edited footage in Panorama programme to make it seem president was encouraging Capitol riot, according to whistleblower dossier”.

It is not known who the whistleblower was.

The Trump White House was on to this immediately, a press secretary describing the BBC as “100% fake news” and a “propaganda machine”. Trump himself posted on his Truth Social platform that “very dishonest people” had “tried to step on the scales of a Presidential Election”, adding: “On top of everything else, they are from a Foreign Country, one that many consider our Number One Ally. What a terrible thing for democracy!”

News Corporation’s British streaming service TalkTV predicted Trump will sue the BBC. As yet there have been no developments of that kind.

The Prescott revelations come only three weeks after the BBC reported that the British broadcasting regulator Ofcom had found another BBC documentary, this time about the war in Gaza, had committed a “serious breach” of broadcasting rules by failing to tell its audience that the documentary’s narrator was the son of the Hamas minister for agriculture.

Ofcom concluded that the program, called “Gaza: How to Survive a War Zone” was materially misleading by failing to disclose that family link.

These are egregious errors, and the journalists who made them should be called to account. But the resignation of the director-general and the CEO of news is so disproportional a response that it raises questions about what pressures were brought to bear on them and by whom.

The Daily Telegraph and the Daily Mail ran hard for a week on the Trump story, and this generated pressure from the House of Commons culture committee to extract explanations from the BBC.

Politically, the timing was certainly inconvenient. The BBC is about to begin negotiations with the government over its future funding, and perhaps a calculation was made that these might proceed more fruitfully with a new director-general and head of news after a procession of controversies over the past couple of years.

On top of that was the Trump factor. Were there diplomatic pressures on the British government from the White House to see that some trophy scalps were taken?

Davie and Turness have each said that mistakes had been made, that the buck stopped with them, and that they were resigning on principle. Perhaps so, but the sources of pressure – the White House, the House of Commons, the conservative media – are such as to invite a closer scrutiny of the reasons for their departure.

They also seemed unable to respond effectively to the week-long onslaught from The Telegraph and Mail, either by defending their journalists or admitting mistakes had been made and that they had taken remedial steps.

It is also a reminder to public broadcasters like Australia’s ABC, that in the current political climate they are high-priority targets for right-wing media and politicians. The ABC has had its crisis with the Antoinette Lattouf case, which cost it more than $2.5 million for its management’s failure to stand up for its journalists against external pressure.

Fortunately it coincided with the planned departures of the chair and managing director, giving it the opportunity of a fresh start. The BBC is about to get a similar opportunity. Clearly it needs to more effectively enforce its editorial standards but it also needs to stand up for its people when they are unfairly targeted.

Denis Muller does not work for, consult, own shares in or receive funding from any company or organisation that would benefit from this article, and has disclosed no relevant affiliations beyond their academic appointment.

ref. BBC resignations over Trump scandal show the pressures on public broadcasters – and why they must resist them – https://theconversation.com/bbc-resignations-over-trump-scandal-show-the-pressures-on-public-broadcasters-and-why-they-must-resist-them-269388

Tongariro fire: Tourists helicoptered out as ash fell from sky

Source: Radio New Zealand

  • Tourist describes ash falling from the sky before he was helicoptered from hut
  • He was then evacuated from Whakapapa
  • Residents in affected area can return home, but businesses not sure yet when they can reopen
  • Business owners hope for short closure of Tongariro Crossing.

A tourist helicoptered out of the Tongariro National Park to avoid the fire burning through the region has described the dramatic moments he realised there was danger in the air.

Matthias Gerold was taken to Whakapapa village, and was then evacuated from there as the blaze continued.

Wet weather has provided hope today for business owners nearby, who have worried a long-term closure of the Tongariro Crossing could prove catastrophic for the region.

Emergency services delivered good news this afternoon, saying there was a significant improvement in conditions and residents were allowed to return to Whakapapa.

Tourist Matthias Gerald. RNZ/Dan Jones

Ash falling from sky

Gerold spoke to RNZ as he waited at the Waimarino railway station for a train to Wellington, after an eventful few days.

“I did the alpine crossing – and arrived at the hut, pitched my tent and saw a lot of smoke in the air.”

Everyone at the Tongariro National Park hut saw the smoke, he said.

“A guy called 111. First they told us we were safe and we could stay there for the night.”

RNZ/Dan Jones

But as the fire tore through the area on Saturday, conditions rapidly changed.

“Twenty minutes before the helicopter arrived there was not only smoke in the air, there was ash falling down. Then we were a bit scared.

“The ash was not glowing and there was nothing burning. It [the fire] always seemed far away,” he said.

“They flew us out to the state highway.”

He was taken to Whakapapa Village, but yesterday evening after going out walking, he realised that was also evacuated.

“I went to the campground six kilometres from [Waimarino] and then I was picked up by the police. They were really friendly and they drove me here.

“They dropped me at the car park here and allowed me to camp at the green spot.”

After packing his tent this morning, Gerold said he would continue his adventures in the South Island.

RNZ/Dan Jones

‘Spectacularly wild and hot’

Sam and Kaz Clarkson, who own the Skotel Alpine Resort in Whakapapa Village, were among the more than 30 people evacuated from there last night.

They were heading back from Waimarino – formerly National Park – this afternoon, saying they had plenty to do.

“What we’re dealing with out there in the park is fundamentally a brush fire rather than a forest fire.

“Although it’s spectacularly wild and hot as it burns, once it’s burned it’s gone. It doesn’t linger. Even a small amount of rain is going to make a difference.”

It did just that, with today’s rain breaking the back of the fire.

Sam and Kaz Clarkson spent last night in Waimarino after their hotel, Skotel, was evacuated. RNZ / Jimmy Ellingham

Sam Clarkson said an area of beech forest near the village would act as a natural fire break if flames had come that way.

Emergency services were expected to make a decision tomorrow about whether tourists could return to Whakapapa and surrounding, and when roads would open.

The wet weather’s dousing of the flames was good news for business owners, such as Gillian and John Visser at the Adventure Lodge and Motel, who feared long-term closures of the popular track.

“We might as well shut down and walk away. Even though 70 percent of the income’s in summer, it’s still very much hand to mouth living here,” John Visser said of what would happen if there was a long closure.

“Everything can change. Weather can change. The mountain can spit a couple of rocks out.”

John and Gillian Visser say a long-term closure of the Tongariro Crossing would be devastating. RNZ / Jimmy Ellingham

Tongariro Crossing Lodge owner Louis van Wyk – a volunteer firefighter who assisted with efforts to battle the blaze yesterday – was also feeling some effects of the crossing’s closure.

Officials said it was too early to know when it could reopen

“We’ve had a couple of cancellations because of the fire, because a lot of people are coming to do the crossing, and that’s closed for the next week because of the rāhui, and it’s not safe at the moment anyway,” van Wyk said.

“Other people have inquired if it’s safe to still come to us and they’ve decided to still come and stay, because they can still do other things.”

Tongariro Crossing Lodge owner Louis van Wyk. RNZ/Dan Jones

The Hillary Outdoors Education Centre, between Waimarino and Tūrangi, is closed too, meaning schools have had to postpone their visits today.

Safety manager Graeme Swift said staff were waiting to see what happened next.

“Staff were evacuated from the centre as a precaution via advice from the Civil Defence yesterday.

“We were outside the area that is directly affected and they were just evacuating just as a precaution, because that fire was still in that state of not being totally under control.”

Graeme Swift says Hillary Outdoors staff are waiting for news about when they can return to work. RNZ / Jimmy Ellingham

Fire and Emergency NZ said the visible signs of the fire were out but checks of hot spots were needed. Thermal imaging drones would go up tonight.

Fire investigators were looking into the cause of the blaze.

Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero, a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.

– Published by EveningReport.nz and AsiaPacificReport.nz, see: MIL OSI in partnership with Radio New Zealand

‘Dinner or debt’: Pensions cut to cover student loan payments

Source: Radio New Zealand

Taupō woman Fenella says the pension and her accommodation supplement barely cover weekly bills and rent. File photo. 123RF

Some people receiving the pension are being forced to choose between eating dinner and playing off their debt, after taking on student loans later in life.

One Taupō woman says she is still facing a $58,000 student loan from a business degree she took two decades ago.

Her repayments are now being docked from her pension and it is forcing her to sacrifice the basics so she can afford rent and power.

It has prompted calls for better guidelines on student loan eligibility and better communication between Inland Revenue and older students.

Taupō woman Fenella took out a student loan 20 years ago, to cover the fees for a business degree as she embarked on a new chapter in her life.

From 2007, her partner was helping her pay off her loan, but the relationship ended. One day she noticed $40 missing from her pension.

She said the pension and her accommodation supplement barely covered weekly bills and rent.

“I wasn’t eating so I’ve been selling my possessions just to get cat food and food for me.

“Apart from the fact of a 44-year relationship ending like it did, it’s been devastating.”

To save on power, Fenella turned off her hot water during the day and during winter she wrapped up in blankets and only used one small heater.

“We’re having to survive day by day without anything else happening to us.”

Inland Revenue takes 12 percent of every dollar earned over $24,128 a year for student loan repayments.

A single person living alone on the pension, getting $32,604 a year before tax, is caught by this threshold.

Former prosecutor for the IRD and tax barrister Dave Ananth has been helping people with student loans to negotiate repaying their debt.

He has had 10 people receiving the pension in the past month asking him for help.

“Do I pay my student loan or do I deprive myself of groceries? That’s not what the student loan scheme was designed for, at 70 you shouldn’t need a spreadsheet to decide between dinner and debt.”

Ananth said the student loan system needed to be re-looked at.

“Taking a loan is a responsibility, it’s tax-payer funded so it’s got to be paid back.

“I’m not in any way advocating that we write off things, I’m saying look at the system again, do you really need to give out this loan, can you avoid it or is there another way?”

Age Concern chief executive Karen Billings-Jensen said 40 percent of older New Zealanders only have superannuation as their income.

“When we see other fixed costs going up, like rates, electricity and insurance it’s really hard.

“What we’re seeing is people potentially cutting back on food, which is the only discretionary part of their income or budget.”

Billings said she would like to see more consistency on how debt can be repaid without someone falling into financial hardship.

“Interested in knowing that the settings to ensure that for repayments of any debt to the government doesn’t cause that level of financial hardship.

“It’s probably wanting some consistency across IRD, MSD, wherever the debt might sit.”

From the end of June this year, more than 23,000 people aged 65 and older had student loans. Of these, almost 6000 were based overseas.

In a statement to Checkpoint, Minister of Revenue Simon Watts said New Zealand super was taxable income and therefore subject to deductions for outstanding student loans.

He was not currently considering changes to the student loan system that fit within his responsibilities.

He said the government had measures to reduce the burden of student loan debt, such as minimum income repayment thresholds and no interest for most borrowers who stay in New Zealand.

But he said student loans still must be repaid.

The Department of Inland Revenue said they encouraged people who were having difficulty meeting their obligations to contact them.

Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero, a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.

– Published by EveningReport.nz and AsiaPacificReport.nz, see: MIL OSI in partnership with Radio New Zealand

A Roman emperor grovelling to a Persian king: the message behind a new statue in Tehran

Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Peter Edwell, Associate Professor in Ancient History, Macquarie University

A new statue unveiled in recent days in Iran depicts a Roman emperor in subjection to a Persian king.

Erected in Tehran’s Enghelab Square, the statue titled Kneeling Before Iran shows the emperor grovelling before Shapur I (who ruled around 242–270 CE).

But where did this imagery come from? And why has this statue gone up now?

The rise of Shapur

In the third century CE, a new dynasty known as the Sasanians came to power in ancient Iran.

Within a few years, the first Sasanian king, Ardashir I, threatened Roman territory in Mesopotamia (in modern-day Turkey, Iraq and Syria). The Romans had captured this territory from the Parthians, the predecessors of the Sasanians.

Now Ardashir wanted to recover some of the territory previously lost to the Romans. He met with some successes in the 230s. But his son and successor, Shapur I, took this to another level.

Shapur defeated an invading Roman army in 244 CE, leading to the death of the teen Roman emperor Gordian III.

In the 250s CE, Shapur invaded Roman territory across Iraq, Syria and Turkey. Two large Roman armies were defeated and dozens of cities were captured.

In 253 CE, Shapur captured the city of Antioch, one of the most important cities in the Roman empire. Some of its citizens were at the theatre and fled in terror as arrows rained down from above.

Capture of an emperor

While the Persian capture of Antioch was a major loss for the Romans, the events of 260 CE were earth-shattering.

After a battle between the Romans and Persians at Edessa (modern-day southern Turkey), the emperor Valerian was captured. This was the first and only time a Roman emperor was taken alive by the enemy.

Valerian was taken back to Persia, along with thousands of other captives.

Legendary stories about his fate as a captive later emerged. In one, Valerian and captive soldiers were forced to build a bridge over the river Karun at Shushtar. The remains, known as the Band-e Qayṣar (emperor’s bridge) can still be seen today.

Roman-built Band-e Kaisar in Shushtar, Iran, said to have been built by Roman prisoners during the reign of Shapur I.
The remains of the bridge, known as the Band-e Qayṣar (emperor’s bridge) can still be seen today.
Ali Afghah/Wikimedia

In another tale, Shapur demanded Valerian stoop on all fours to be used as a footstool so the Persian king could mount his horse.

Shapur supposedly ordered Valerian’s body preserved, stuffed and placed in a cabinet after his death.

With this, Valerian’s humiliation was complete.

Depictions of Shapur’s victories over Rome were put up all over the Persian empire. A number of carved rock reliefs celebrating these victories survive.

Perhaps the most famous is at Bishapur in southern Iran, where Shapur built a magnificent palace.

In this image, Shapur is spendidly dressed and sits on a horse. Underneath the horse is the dead Gordian III. Behind is the captive Valerian clasped by Shapur’s right hand. The figure in front is the emperor Philip I (ruled 244–249 CE) who replaced Gordian. He is begging for the release of the defeated Roman army.

Bishapur, Relief 2, Central scene: Shapur, Gordian, Philip, Valerian, courtiers
In this image, Shapur sits on a horse, under which is dead Gordian III. Behind is the captive Valerian.
Marco Prins via Livius, CC BY

Shapur also carved an enormous inscription in three languages, which partly celebrated his great victories over the Romans. Known today as the SKZ Inscription, it can still be seen at Naqsh-i Rustam in southern Iran.

The great Roman empire had been thoroughly humiliated. The Persians took huge resources (including skilled people such as builders, architects and craftsmen) from the captured cities. Some cities in the Persian empire were populated with these captives.

A new statue celebrating an old victory

The new statue recently unveiled in Tehran appears to be a partial copy of a celebratory Sasanian rock relief at Naqsh-i Rustam.

The kneeling figure is reported to be Valerian. If it is indeed modelled on the Naqsh-i Rustam relief, then the kneeling figure is usually identified as Philip I (as in the original relief Valerian is standing before Shapur). Nevertheless, official statements identify the kneeling figure as Valerian.

Mehdi Mazhabi, head of Tehran’s Municipal Beautification Organization, is quoted in one report as saying:

The Valerian statue reflects a historical truth that Iran has been a land of resistance throughout history […] By implementing this plan in Enghelab Square, we aim to forge a bond between this land’s glorious past and its hopeful present.

Shapur’s great victories over the Romans are still a source of national Iranian pride.

The statue has been described as a symbol of national defiance following the American bombing of Iran’s nuclear facilities in June.

While Shapur’s victories occurred more than 1,700 years ago, Iran still celebrates them. The statue is clearly aimed at an internal audience following the American attacks. Only time will tell if it is also a warning to the west.

The Conversation

Peter Edwell receives funding from the Australian Research Council.

ref. A Roman emperor grovelling to a Persian king: the message behind a new statue in Tehran – https://theconversation.com/a-roman-emperor-grovelling-to-a-persian-king-the-message-behind-a-new-statue-in-tehran-269367

Christchurch council gets green light to withdraw from part of housing plan

Source: Radio New Zealand

Christchurch City Council has confirmed its housing plan provides for future growth, Chris Bishop says. RNZ / Maree Mahony

Christchurch can withdraw from part of a plan change aimed at increasing housing density, because it has met its housing growth target, says RMA Reform Minister Chris Bishop.

Bishop said Christchurch and Auckland councils had argued the Medium Density Residential Standards, which are part of Plan Change 14, were not right for their cities.

In August, Parliament passed a bill allowing the cities to withdraw Plan Change 14, provided the council could prove it had provided for 30 years of sufficient feasible housing capacity, with a 20 percent contingency margin.

Bishop said based on advice from officials, including two peer reviews provided by the council from Urbanomics and Sense Partners, he had decided the Christchurch Council has met this requirement.

“Christchurch City Council has confirmed its housing plan provides for future growth, with modelling showing plan enabled feasible housing capacity for at least 68,200 homes, exceeding the 65,640 homes needed to meet the statutory requirement for 30 years of adjusted demand,” Bishop said.

“Freeing up land for development by removing unnecessary planning barriers is essential to increasing housing supply.

“The evidence is clear that more housing capacity leads to more homes being built, which helps bring down rents and make housing more affordable. The council has delivered on this, and it’s a great result for the city.”

He said ministerial decisions were still pending on two heritage sites, Antonio Hall and Daresbury, and a special character area around Piko Crescent, but these will be considered in the coming months.

– Published by EveningReport.nz and AsiaPacificReport.nz, see: MIL OSI in partnership with Radio New Zealand

Cyclone Gabrielle inquest: Delay in emergency mobile alert explained

Source: Radio New Zealand

Images of those who died in relation to the cyclone are on display in the courtroom. RNZ / Alexa Cook

The man in charge of the emergency response during Cyclone Gabrielle in Hawke’s Bay was worried about putting people in danger if he issued an evacuation alert earlier, a coronial inquiry has heard.

‘The last safe moment to evacuate may have already passed’

The acting group controller for Civil Defence in Hawke’s Bay has explained why he did not issue an emergency evacuation alert to residents earlier in the night.

He said there was a lack of information and it was hard to get a reliable picture of what was happening due to the darkness, so they agreed the best option was for people to “shelter in place”.

Lennan admitted he was “aware that there were significant gaps” in his “situational awareness”. He feared that issuing an EMA “was the more dangerous course of action”.

His reasoning was that an EMA would not be any help to people already experiencing significant flooding or anyone who had climbed onto their roofs, and worried it may lead to people putting themselves into danger by trying to drive when there was a risk of slips, falling trees and being trapped in floodwaters.

“I considered that it was possible that the last safe moment to evacuate may have already passed, without anyone involved in the emergency response realising that was the case,” said Lennan.

The entire Esk Valley began filling with fast flowing floodwaters during the storm. Supplied / NZDF

Last month the inquest heard from the hydrologist in charge of flood forecasting during the deadly Cyclone, who could not explain why it took two hours for him to tell Civil Defence about a failure with the river level monitoring equipment due to a power outage.

The third week of the Hawke’s Bay phase of the inquest began this morning with Land Search and Rescue capability and development manager Edaan Lennan giving evidence.

When Cyclone Gabrielle struck the region on 13 February 2023, Lennan was employed by Hawke’s Bay Regional Council (HBRC) in Hawke’s Bay Civil Defence Emergency Management (HBCDEM) Group Emergency Management Office.

Because the main group controller for civil defence, Ian Macdonald, was away on leave during the cyclone, he put Edaan Lennan and Iain Maxwell into the top role in his absence.

An EMA (Emergency Mobile Alert), was not issued for Esk Valley until 5:19am on 14 February, by which time two people had already drowned and many more residents were clutching onto their rooftops, desperately hoping to be rescued.

Damage from Cyclone Gabrielle in Hawke’s Bay RNZ/ Alexa Cook

Lennan told the court that at some point between 3am and 3.30am on 14 February, he held an emergency style meeting with local civil defence controllers and the emergency services to decide what to do next.

The decision was made not to issue an EMA at that point. Although the coroner’s lawyer Nick Whittington pointed out that an email at 2.10am from the hydrologist clearly told civil defence the Esk River was at the highest level ever recorded.

“Is that not a clear indication that what ever it looks like out there… the predictions are out the window?

“Was there no consideration of sending an EMA at this point?” asked Whittington.

“Not that I recall”, said Lennan.

Lennan said “you wouldn’t want to send an EMA without understanding what was happening on the ground”, but Whittington disagreed. He queried whether residents could have been sent a message about the record river levels.

“Isn’t this a wake up call? Don’t they need to be alerted to the fact this is going on?” said the lawyer.

Lennan agreed they could have possibly issued the mobile alert earlier to inform residents about the situation, but he also believes evacuating people in the middle of the night could have put people in harm’s way.

Edaan Lennan giving evidence in the Cyclone Gabrielle Coronial Inquiry RNZ / Alexa Cook

A state of emergency was not declared until about 4am on 14 February, and Whittington questioned Lennan about whether there was a link between civil defence waiting for an emergency declaration before issuing an EMA.

Lennan was hesitant to say if that was the case, instead pointing to the risk of issuing too many emergency mobile alerts, saying it can cause anxiety and result in a less responsive public response.

“You can create a lot of harm to society in over-alerting… or create independence on an alerting system,” he said.

Whittington pressed him further, asking if civil defence has a pre-conceived view that a mobile alert should only come after a declaration of emergency.

“It’s something I’ve thought about… I don’t personally think I had that pre-conception,” said Lennan.

‘Skeleton’ Civil Defence crew on overnight

On 13 February there were about 30 people in the Group Emergency Coordination Centre, but by about 10pm most of those staff had gone home or were heading home.

Lennan said they had “skeleton staff” overnight, which included himself and several liaison officers from different emergency services.

Whittington asked Lennan why there were not more staff working overnight, when the cyclone was expected to intensify.

Floodwaters in Esk Valley. Supplied

Lennan explained the complications behind using council staff for civil defence jobs.

“There are challenges with staff personal circumstances and the human factors as well, with asking, say a person employed to be a librarian – to then come in and work in an emergency coordination centre,” he said. Lennan said finding people who were willing and able to pick up civil defence shifts could be tough, for example they may have whanau or animals they need to look after, or childcare challenges.

“It’s not only that we couldn’t find people for overnight, but also that we wanted to be a bit strategic with our rest period, send people home so we could get them back early the next day,” said Lennan.

Whittington asked Lennan whether the issue of finding enough civil defence staff was a persistent issue that had never been solved.

“It’s been a continual known challenge in Hawke’s Bay and across the country,” said Lennan.

Coroner’s lawyer Nick Whittington questioning Edaan Lennan RNZ / Alexa Cook

Lennan was also questioned about a conversation with Hawke’s Bay area commander Inspector Lincoln Sycamore, in which he requested extra army unimogs to be sent from the New Zealand Defence Force’s Linton base.

Whittington said this conversation took place on Sunday, 12 February, but Lennan said he doesn’t recall it.

“I only remember talking to him once on a Friday, nothing on the Sunday.”

Whittington said Sycamore wanted extra unimogs in the region in case the cyclone struck with greater intensity than forecast.

Sycamore’s witness statement said Lennan told him that it was not necessary.

“I would like to think I was not dismissive to the head of police in Hawke’s Bay… doesn’t sound like the type of person I’d like to be,” said Lennan.

In his evidence, Lennan stated that Civil Defence was not authorised to deploy police resources.

Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero, a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.

– Published by EveningReport.nz and AsiaPacificReport.nz, see: MIL OSI in partnership with Radio New Zealand

Three hours of free power sounds great – but it could raise other costs and hamstring rooftop solar

Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Bruce Mountain, Professor and Director, Victoria Energy Policy Centre, Victoria University

moisseyev/Getty

It was the news that rippled around the nation – and then the world: at least three hours of free grid-supplied electricity for Australian households, every day.

The new Solar Sharer program announced by Federal Minister for Energy Chris Bowen would require retailers to offer at least three hours of power daily during the sunniest period to homes with smart meters. It would begin next year in New South Wales, south-east Queensland and South Australia.

On the surface, this seems like a win. Australia now has so much solar that wholesale power prices are often very cheap or even negative during the sunniest periods with abundant supply.

But there’s a problem. Wholesale supply is only part of the cost. Mandating free retail power during some hours will require cross-subsidy of these other costs. Under Bowen’s plan this will inevitably raise prices for other customers and it is likely to destroy the rooftop solar market. There’s no such thing as a free lunch.

What’s wrong with free power?

Minister Bowen’s plan borrows heavily from energy offers in the market now, which include three free hours of power.

Bowen’s policy will be delivered through the Default Market Offer, a unique regulated retail plan which retailers in Queensland, NSW and South Australia are obliged to offer. If you don’t choose a market offer, you will be placed on the default offer.

There’s nothing new about free electricity from the grid. Consumers can choose their electricity retailer in NSW, Victoria, South Australia and much of Queensland. In these states, it’s been possible for over a decade to find offers with free electricity at certain times. These deals typically offered free power for an hour a week, and usually on the weekend. Few customers chose them.

But in 2023, OVO Energy started offering a “three for free” deal with free power from 11am to 2pm daily. I was one of their first customers, and I calculated OVO would make a loss on me given I used the free power to charge my electric vehicle. Other retailers such as Globird and Red Energy have followed suit since AGL bought OVO’s Australian arm in 2024.

Power prices outside the free hours have roughly doubled since I took up OVO’s offer two years ago. But it’s still worthwhile for me as a way to charge my EV for nothing.

These offers make most sense for EV owners, as few customers can shift most of their consumption to the free period.

charging electric vehicle.
EV users are making most use of free hours of power at present.
Chuttersnap/Unsplash, CC BY-NC-ND

From market to regulation

Minister Bowen’s move might be seen as a form of mandatory expansion of these niche retail offers. But changing a niche to a mainstream offer will bring drastic change.

In the electricity market, retailers offering “three for free” deals recoup the costs of supplying “free” electricity by increasing prices charged in the “non-free” hours. These costs include the network use, renewable energy subsidies, generation costs and internal costs and margins which make up about 75% of the average bill

To make his offer widely attractive, Bowen will pressure the Australian Energy Regulator to avoid significantly increasing power prices at other times in the default market offer. Otherwise, substantially higher prices outside the sunny period would discourage consumers and mean Solar Sharer would remain a niche product, just like existing three-for-free offers.

If retailers have to offer free power and keep their prices down at other hours, they will have to make up the difference in higher prices paid by all their other customers. Someone has to pay for the free lunch.

Bowen has form here, as he previously intervened in the regulator’s determination of default offer prices.

Hobbling rooftop solar?

Over the past 20 years, solar feed-in tariffs have fallen off a cliff as millions of Australians have added panels and solar system costs have collapsed.

This means the main reason to go solar is no longer exporting power to the grid, but rather to consume as much produced power as possible to avoid buying from the grid.

If Bowen’s policy comes into effect, it will hobble the market for the installation of rooftop solar. There’s little point installing solar if grid-supplied power is free at the times when most of the rooftop solar production occurs.

Will Australia’s four million existing solar homes be worse off? Not necessarily. Existing panels are a sunk cost, so households will likely continue using them as before.

But existing solar home owners may see this as a breach of trust, having spent thousands of dollars going solar to avoid pricey power from the grid – encouraged by ministers, including Bowen, to do this.

Will more Australians install household batteries to soak up free power? That’s unlikely. The government’s home battery subsidy only applies when paired with rooftop solar. If regulation undermines the economics of rooftop solar, battery-backed solar will be less attractive too.

Out of the blue

It’s not clear the government considered the wider effects of the policy before announcing it. Last week’s announcement took the industry by surprise. Australian Energy Council CEO Louisa Kinnear said retailers were “disappointed the Government didn’t consult with us ahead of time”.

The move is a sharp reversal of the retail pricing policies put in place when the energy market was created almost 30 years ago. These longstanding policies sought to ensure prices reflect costs, at least in regulated retail offers.

Australians love rooftop solar. It’s now the biggest source of clean electricity in Australia, growing even as fewer wind and solar farms proceed. The last time a politician tried to undermine rooftop solar was over a decade ago. Now we have a federal Labor minister who is an avowed fan of rooftop solar putting forward a policy which will effectively strangle it.

Bowen has backed himself into a corner. Making free electricity widely available will undercut the economics of rooftop solar and raise prices for other customers. Is this really what he intends?

The Conversation

Bruce Mountain is an OVO Energy customer.

ref. Three hours of free power sounds great – but it could raise other costs and hamstring rooftop solar – https://theconversation.com/three-hours-of-free-power-sounds-great-but-it-could-raise-other-costs-and-hamstring-rooftop-solar-269184

In pictures: The devastating impacts the Tongariro National Park wildfire has had on our landscape

Source: Radio New Zealand

A huge wildfire in Tongariro National Park is expected to have significant impacts on biodiversity.

The large fire on the Central Plateau broke out on Saturday afternoon, triggering evacuations of trampers and residents, including Whakapapa Village.

Firefighters have been battling the fire for three days, which has since grown to over 2800 hectares.

Here’s how it unfolded in pictures:

Pictures from Saturday, 8 November

A view of the fire from Tongariro Crossing. RNZ / Hamish Cardwell

Tongariro on Saturday, a few hours after the fire broke out. Supplied/ Liz Brooker

The fire in Tongariro National Park as the sun starts to set on Saturday evening. Supplied / David Golding

Tongariro on Saturday 8 November 2025, a few hours after the fire broke out. Kristina Montgomerie / @kristinamonts

The fire in Tongariro National Park, on the night of Saturday 8 November, 2025. Supplied

Pictures from Sunday, 9 November

A huge amount of smoke obscures Tongariro as a wildfire continues to rage into Sunday morning. RNZ / Hamish Cardwell

A number of helicopters with monsoon buckets and planes are fighting the blaze in Tongariro National Park. RNZ / Hamish Cardwell

A view of the Tongariro wildfire taken from SH48. RNZ / Hamish Cardwell

Smoke from the huge Tongariro National Park fire behind the historic Chateau Tongariro on Sunday 9 November 2025. Supplied / Dean Buckeridge

The Tongariro fire as seen from near the summit of Mt Ruapehu. Supplied / Max Rayner

The Tongariro fire as seen from near the summit of Mt Ruapehu. Supplied / Max Rayner

Pictures from Monday, 10 November

Firefighters have been battling the blaze for three days. RNZ/Dan Jones

Officials provide an update on the fire, confirming it has spreads to nearly 3000 hectares. RNZ/Dan Jones

Ruapehu District Mayor Weston Kirton says it’s been a stressful few days for his community. RNZ/Dan Jones

Firefighters continue to battle the Tongariro National Park wildfire on Monday. Fire and Emergency NZ

An aerial view of the fire on Monday. Fire and Emergency NZ

An aerial view of the fire on Monday. Fire and Emergency

Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero, a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.

– Published by EveningReport.nz and AsiaPacificReport.nz, see: MIL OSI in partnership with Radio New Zealand

Politics with Michelle Grattan: Remembering the day Gough Whitlam lost his job

Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Michelle Grattan, Professorial Fellow, University of Canberra

Gough Whitlam address a caught after being dismissed as Prime Minister, November 11 1975 National Archives of Australia, CC BY

Tuesday is the fiftieth anniversary of the Dismissal of the Whitlam government. For those who were alive at the time it’s one of those “where were you?” moments. In this podcast, the Conversation’s politics and society editor Amanda Dunn and I discuss that historic day and its impact on Australia’s federal politics.

On the scene when Gough Whitlam gave his famous speech on the steps of Parliament House (now Old Parliament House):

I was on the steps […] with many, many other people, journalists, staffers, the start of a gathering crowd. Everybody was shocked, amazed. We’d heard only a while before of this act by the governor-general.

Despite Whitlam’s emphatic election loss months later, the mood of his supporters in the campaign was intense:

I travelled a lot with Gough Whitlam [in those weeks] and you really got a quite distorted picture of what was likely to happen [at the election], because there were these immense crowds and people were so enthusiastic about Whitlam that it was easy to get the impression he had more support than of course he did.

The Conversation

Michelle Grattan does not work for, consult, own shares in or receive funding from any company or organisation that would benefit from this article, and has disclosed no relevant affiliations beyond their academic appointment.

ref. Politics with Michelle Grattan: Remembering the day Gough Whitlam lost his job – https://theconversation.com/politics-with-michelle-grattan-remembering-the-day-gough-whitlam-lost-his-job-269387

RSV immunisation could prevent thousands of babies being hospitalised

Source: Radio New Zealand

Pharmac needs to act quickly on the RSV vaccine to ensure it is ready for next winter, say experts. SERGII IAREMENKO/Science Photo Library via AFP

A “game-changer” immunisation that could save thousands of babies from a potentially deadly lung infection is sitting in the hands of Pharmac, according to respiratory health experts.

Pharmac’s Immunisation Advisory Committee met last week to discuss the funding application for nirsevimab to prevent respiratory syncytial virus (RSV) in infants, as well as one for Arexvy, which is already licensed RSV vaccine for adults aged 60 and older.

Asthma and Respiratory Foundation chief executive Letitia Harding said the potential approval of nirsevimab could be “a game-changer” – particularly for Māori and Pacific communities.

“This is the progress we’ve been waiting for.

“RSV hospitalises thousands of children every year, and this treatment has the potential to prevent many of those admissions.”

But Pharmac needed to act quickly to ensure it was ready for next winter, she said.

“We can’t afford delays if we want to save lives of some of our most vulnerable.

“We’re urging decision makers to prioritise funding so that New Zealand infants can benefit as soon as possible.”

Another preventative medicine (Palivizumab) is already available for high-risk babies and young children but requires monthly hospital visits for injections.

Nirsevimab can be given by GP clinics, pharmacists or midwives and a single injection protects against RSV for five or six months.

gives protection over the entire RSV “season”.

It is a monoclonal antibody, which gives passive immunity rather than stimulating the immune system to make its own antibodies, like a vaccine.

Foundation medical director Professor Bob Hancox said the opportunity to introduce a more effective and accessible RSV immunisation was “a critical step for child health”.

“RSV is one of the most common and serious respiratory infections in infants, and it places enormous strain on our hospitals every winter.

“This new treatment could dramatically reduce hospitalisations and health inequities,” he said.

RSV immunisation is used in 40 other countries, and data shows it can cut RSV hospitalisations among babies by up to 90 percent.

Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero, a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.

– Published by EveningReport.nz and AsiaPacificReport.nz, see: MIL OSI in partnership with Radio New Zealand

Black Caps, West Indies fourth T20 rained out

Source: Radio New Zealand

Mitchell Santner. Chris Symes / www.photosport.nz

The fourth T20 international between the Black Caps and West Indies has been wiped out by rain in Nelson.

There were just 6.3 overs played before rain took hold at Saxton Oval and didn’t abate enough for a return to the field.

The Black Caps lead the series 2-1, with the final match due to be played in Dunedin on Thursday afternoon.

Play was first halted after five overs, with the West Indies 30 for none after Mitch Santner won the toss for the Black Caps and decided to bowl.

Drizzly weather turned to steady rain and the players retreated to the pavilion.

There was a break in the weather a short time later but they only managed 1.3 overs before the rain returned. In that time the West Indies progressed to 38 but lost the wicket of Alick Athanaze who skied a delivery from Jimmy Neesham, and Daryl Mitchell took the catch.

The players were fated not to return and the skippers shook hands with the decision to abandon the match at 4.08pm.

Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero, a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.

– Published by EveningReport.nz and AsiaPacificReport.nz, see: MIL OSI in partnership with Radio New Zealand

NZTA discovers 440 fake commercial driver licences

Source: Radio New Zealand

NZTA is in the process of contacting the individuals involved. 123RF

The New Zealand Transport Agency has discovered and revoked 440 fake commercial driver licensees.

NZTA said they discovered false or altered documentation that converted overseas licences to New Zealand licences.

The discovery was made in an audit during the “conversion process” in July 2025.

“We have systems in place to identify, investigate and respond to suspected fraudulent activity and we will act swiftly when we find it by holding people to account,” deputy director of land transport Mike Hargreaves said.

NZTA is in the process of contacting the individuals involved.

Providing false or misleading information as part of driver licence application is an offence under the Land Transport Act 1998, punishable by an infringement fine of up to $750.  

Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero, a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.

– Published by EveningReport.nz and AsiaPacificReport.nz, see: MIL OSI in partnership with Radio New Zealand

Wellington teens do the heavy lifting to help full the new library’s shelves

Source: Radio New Zealand

A group of Wellington students has turned a page on history, moving some of the last books into the capital’s redeveloped central Library.

Te Matapihi has been closed since 2019 after it was deemed earthquake-prone.

Following years of construction, the library is set to reopen in March next year. Now, its shelves are starting to be filled once again with books, thanks to the helping hands of 50 students from Rongotai College.

About 10am on Monday, a queue of boys snaked outside the library as they lined up behind a red Crown moving truck ready to slide boxes of books to the students.

The human train walked back into the building and up its three levels to where empty bookshelves and librarians were waiting for them.

It harkened back to when students from the same school moved books into the old city library in 1940.

Rongotai College Deputy Principal Geoff Hall told RNZ they had just 45 minutes to move the books.

“I’d be more than happy for it to go on a little bit longer than that, I think it is really good that these boys are giving back to the community as much as anything.

“And every time I suppose they shift a book, they feel that story.”

Hall said it was great to context with the school’s past 85 years on.

“We have got our centenary in two years’ time, so it is sort of a good way to kick start that I think.”

Wellington City Council head of Creative Capital Gisella Carr told RNZ the event links the past with the present.

“As we said to the boys this morning, in 85 years’ time through our archival function those future schoolboys will be looking at pictures of these schoolboys.”

Carr said every inch of the building has been redesigned with the public in mind.

“We are standing on the floor now where there is 30 percent more public space available so it is amazing.”

She said alongside the books the library would offer a range of services such as recording studios for bands and podcasters and a green screen for film makers.

Wellington Mayor Andrew Little helped out the students by bringing a box of books into the space.

Little told RNZ it was his first time seeing the library fully fitted out after it shut in 2019.

“Seeing it like this yeah, just stunning it is actually just amazing.”

– Published by EveningReport.nz and AsiaPacificReport.nz, see: MIL OSI in partnership with Radio New Zealand

Te Pāti Māori purge fails to end the party war

Source: Radio New Zealand

Te Pāti Māori co-leaders Debbie Ngarewa-Packer and Rawiri Waititi. RNZ/Samuel Rillstone

Analysis: As the Iwi Chairs Forum fought fruitlessly to keep Te Pāti Māori together last week, spokesperson Bayden Barber offered a warning: a split tōtara is only good for the fire.

Now Te Pāti Māori finds itself in an inferno.

The slow-burn conflagration has been smouldering for so long, it’s easy to miss the magnitude. But this is no small matter.

This is a party ousting a third of its caucus, citing “irreconcilable differences” and “serious breaches” of its constitution.

Fronting reporters on Monday morning, co-leaders Debbie Ngarewa-Packer and Rawiri Waititi wished their former colleagues “all the best of luck” and waved them on their way.

“We had to bring this to a close, and we must move on.”

But that seems overly hopeful. Both Mariameno Kapa-Kingi and Tākuta Ferris were quick to declare the move “unconstitutional” and are threatening to challenge it “in all respects”.

The party’s National Council has also yet to consider whether to invoke the waka-jumping provision and eject the MPs from Parliament altogether.

That would require agreement of the two other remaining MPs – Hana-Rawhiti Maipi-Clarke and Oriini Kaipara. It’s unclear yet where they stand in all this.

Either outcome is ugly. If the “rogue” MPs remain, they will serve as a constant reminder of division. If they’re booted, two by-elections loom, sure to be bitter and bruising.

At least a public contest might shed more clarity on what’s behind the weeks of infighting, with voters so far largely left in a cloud of smoke.

Asked to clarify on Monday exactly what the MPs had done to deserve expulsion, the co-leaders refused: “You’re not going to get that detail here in this press conference.”

From what has dripped out over the past six weeks, it seems the feud is driven more by personality than principle.

Party president John Tamihere has accused the two MPs of plotting a failed coup. Kapa-Kingi and Ferris have declared no confidence in Tamihere, with their supporters decrying toxic dictatorial leadership.

Supporters are right to feel aggrieved. A year ago, Te Pāti Māori was riding a wave of unity and purpose, as a driving force behind the historic Toitū Te Tiriti hikoi.

Mariameno Kapa-Kingi and Tākuta Ferris. RNZ/Liam K. Swiggs

It boasted its largest-ever caucus, having swept six of the seven Māori electorates in a dominant 2023 result.

Ironically, the roots of the recent crisis lie in that rapid expansion.

The co-leaders went from being a dynamic duo to overseeing a more assertive caucus and competing egos.

Tamihere, Ngarewa-Packer and Waititi are all dominant personalities, used to steering their own course.

But both Kapa-Kingi and Ferris regard themselves as electorate MPs first, answerable to their own people, not to the central hierarchy.

Add in the whānau ties on either side, and the conflict shifts from political to personal.

The co-leaders admit the recent disunity has damaged the party’s brand. The enthusiasm of a year ago has turned to disillusionment, with voters now forced to pick sides or to look elsewhere.

When Hone Harawira split from the Māori Party in 2011 to form Mana, both sides eventually vanished. Harawira was sent packing by voters in 2014, and the rest of the Māori Party followed in 2017.

For the wider opposition, there is good and bad here.

The Labour Party will see an opportunity to win over those disenchanted voters and to retake the Māori electorates amidst a more divided race.

But the wider picture is riskier. Centrist voters may well look at the turmoil on the left and decide to stick with the status quo.

Labour leader Chris Hipkins has yet to publicly declare whether he would welcome Te Pāti Māori as part of a future Cabinet.

Those questions will only grow louder now – expanding to include the “rogues”. Where do they stand in any coalition calculation?

The Iwi Chairs Forum had arranged “peace talks” this week, bringing together the two factions at a Wellington marae.

Bayden Barber still thinks that would be beneficial and the co-leaders agree it could still go ahead. But few expect much to come of it now.

The next moment of reckoning may come on 7 December, when members gather in Rotorua for the party’s AGM – and confront how Te Pāti Māori can piece itself together from the ashes.

Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero, a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.

– Published by EveningReport.nz and AsiaPacificReport.nz, see: MIL OSI in partnership with Radio New Zealand

The Democrats are riding a blue wave, but major questions remain for a divided party

Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Liam Byrne, Honorary Fellow, School of Historical and Philosophical Studies, The University of Melbourne

All of a sudden, the Democrats seem to be on a roll.

Last week’s elections in the United States gave the party the boost it has been desperately seeking since Donald Trump recaptured the White House in 2024 and sent the party into a tailspin.

Democrats won governorships in Virginia and New Jersey, and Zohran Mamdani stormed to victory in the New York City mayor’s race in open defiance of Trump.

Perhaps most significant for the Democrats’ chances in the 2026 midterm elections, California Governor Gavin Newsom’s Proposition 50 passed by a wide margin. This measure is intended to reconfigure the state’s electorates counterbalance Republican gerrymandering in Texas and other states.

Meanwhile, Trump’s approval ratings continue to slump in national polls amid a prolonged government shutdown.

But if a week is a long time in politics, the next US elections (due in November 2026) are an eternity away.

And there are still serious challenges ahead for the Democratic Party as it seeks not just to win back control of the House of Representatives, but to resist Trump’s attempts to recast the country in his own authoritarian and reactionary image.

What went right for the Democrats?

Before looking at the challenges, though, it is important to understand what led to last week’s Democratic successes.

Trump governs through crisis and chaos. His pitch to supporters is an existential one, explicitly cultivating white grievance among those voters who feel they have been left behind. He argues that the US political system is so broken, only he can resolve it through extraordinary measures.

Yet, there is a significant gap between Trump’s vision of the United States, and the reality of life for Americans (including many Trump voters).

On the campaign trail in 2024, Trump promised his administration would down bring prices “starting on day one”.

But early evidence from Trump’s tariffs indicates US companies and consumers are bearing the costs. Prices have continued to rise on certain goods, such as apparel, furniture, food items and cars. A recent survey found 74% of respondents had experienced an average increase of monthly household costs by at least US$100 (A$150).

Disappointed expectations are a potent political force that has spelled doom for politicians well before Trump.

The optics couldn’t be worse at the moment, either. Hosting a Great Gatsby-themed party, a brash and boastful display of wealth, at a time when federal food aid is about to end for 42 million citizens is not exactly a public relations coup.

The Democrats that won last week came from different ends of the party’s political spectrum, but there was one thing that united them: a focus on affordability and the cost of living. And they all had a clear message: Trump’s policies are to blame.

This is adept and effective politics. Democrats are identifying the ways that Trump is failing to carry through on his promises, and have been increasingly ruthless in exposing them.

But there are limits to this strategy. To build sustainable electoral coalitions capable of not just winning office but of turning back the larger MAGA tide that swept to victory in 2024, the Democrats need to be able to construct a coherent and compelling vision of the future they want to create.

Can the Democrats unify on a national scale?

The Democrats remain deeply divided over how to respond to Trump – and more broadly, divided over what the party stands for.

The split among Senate Democrats on whether to allow a vote to reopen the government without getting the assurances on health insurance subsidies they’ve been holding out for exemplifies this.

Are the Democrats going to lean into being a moderate and centrist party? Or will they move further left and embrace more progressive positions – those championed by the likes of Bernie Sanders and Mamdani – even if these are to the left of the electorate?

It is not a problem the party is having these debates. Political parties in the US have always been organisationally looser and ideologically broader than those elsewhere.

It is, however, unclear if the party has the institutional mechanisms to synthesise these strongly polarised perspectives into a consistent agenda and program that Democrats can present to a national electorate.

As some commentators have noted, it is relatively easy for Democrats to win low-turnout state and city-based elections without clarifying these matters. But winning a national election, or recapturing the US Senate, is a more difficult task.

Can the Democrats find a way to not just articulate opposition to Trump, but put forth of a common vision of America’s future embraced by these disparate wings of the party?

And how do they turn words into action?

When a political system is in crisis, it is not enough for progressives to repeat over and over what has gone wrong. They also need solutions – a positive case for what they want to achieve and a policy agenda to enact it. Then, they can build a new social coalition around a common sense of purpose.

It is all well and good to denounce Trump’s poor economic management, but will Democrats be able to implement strategies that deliver on their affordability promises?

For this to happen, the party has to agree on concrete plans to reinvigorate economic growth beyond the tech sector and ensure a fairer redistribution of the benefits of this growth. In addition, they’ll need to come together on the right balance of investment in the American people and infrastructure through government spending, and the need to reduce the US’ extraordinary debt levels.

To make things even more difficult, they’ll need to articulate how to achieve this with a Congress prone to partisan gridlock like never before in modern history. So far, the Democrats have no clear answers to these fundamental questions.

The Democrats’ challenge, therefore, is not just to repudiate Trump’s dark vision of America, but to put forward their own positive vision of what the future can be. Recent victories are encouraging, but a lack of this broader imaginative work so far is striking.

The Democrats have come closer to working out how to win – but still need an answer for an even more defining question: what do they want to win for?

The Conversation

Liam Byrne does not work for, consult, own shares in or receive funding from any company or organisation that would benefit from this article, and has disclosed no relevant affiliations beyond their academic appointment.

ref. The Democrats are riding a blue wave, but major questions remain for a divided party – https://theconversation.com/the-democrats-are-riding-a-blue-wave-but-major-questions-remain-for-a-divided-party-269195

Smoke warning as Tongariro fire grows

Source: Radio New Zealand

Firefighters continue to battle the Tongariro National Park wildfire. Fire and Emergency

People living near the Tongariro National Park fire are being warned to take extra precautions to protect themselves, young children and the elderly from smoke.

The Asthma and Respiratory Foundation said residents should close windows and doors if staying inside, and wear a properly fitted N95 or KN95 masks outdoors.

Its chief executive Letitia Harding said bush fire smoke contained “tiny particles” which could irritate the lungs and airways.

That could be particularly risky for children, older people and those with pre-existing respiratory conditions.

“For people with asthma, COPD or other lung conditions, smoke exposure can trigger flare-ups, which in serious cases may require hospitalisation,” she said.

“It’s important to limit exposure and keep medications like reliever inhalers on hand.”

Meanwhile, those travelling in the area should keep car windows closed and set the ventilation system to recirculate air.

Everyone in the wider region should stay informed about smoke conditions, plan activities carefully and take practical steps to protect their lungs, Harding said.

Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero, a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.

– Published by EveningReport.nz and AsiaPacificReport.nz, see: MIL OSI in partnership with Radio New Zealand

ER Report: A Roundup of Significant Articles on EveningReport.nz for November 10, 2025

ER Report: Here is a summary of significant articles published on EveningReport.nz on November 10, 2025.

Oceania ‘voice’ Jacinda Ardern in open letter climate crisis plea in Brazil
Asia Pacific Report In an open letter released at the Belém Climate Summit, special envoys for strategic regions have expressed their support for the COP30 presidency and for all leaders committed to advancing climate crisis action. Former New Zealand prime minister Dame Jacinda Ardern, the “voice” for Oceania, was among the seven climate envoys signing

What is myasthenia gravis, the rare disease tennis great Monica Seles lives with?
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Gozde Aydin, Research Fellow, Centre for Health Economics, Monash University Clive Brunskill/Getty Images Former tennis star Monica Seles recently revealed she is living with the rare disease myasthenia gravis, which affects 12 in 100,000 people globally. Seles explained her first symptoms appeared suddenly around three years ago.

A centuries-old grid of holes in the Andes may have been a ‘spreadsheet’ for accounting and exchange
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Jacob L. Bongers, Tom Austen Brown Postdoctoral Research Associate, University of Sydney An aerial photo of Monte Sierpe, facing northeast. Jacob L Bongers In 1931, geologist Robert Shippee and US Navy Lieutenant George R. Johnson led one of the first aerial photography expeditions in South America. They

Is AI really coming for our jobs and wages? Past predictions of a ‘robot apocalypse’ offer some clues
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Tom Coupe, Associate Professor of Economics, University of Canterbury Getty Images The robots were taking our jobs – or so we were told over a decade ago. The same warnings are regularly heard today about the likely impact of artificial intelligence (AI). Tech breakthroughs have long stirred

Pacific civil society warn of growing militarisation and mining pressure on the ocean
RNZ Pacific Pacific civil society groups say 2025 has been a big year for the ocean. Development Alternatives with Women for a New Era (DAWN) representative Maureen Penjueli said the Pacific Ocean was being hyper-militarised and there was a desire for seabed minerals to be used to build-up military capacity. “Critical minerals, whether from land

Some people choosing DIY super are getting bad advice, watchdog warns
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Di Johnson, Senior Lecturer, Finance and Financial Planning, Griffith University Maskot/Getty It’s no secret Australians are big fans of a do-it-yourself (DIY) project. How many other countries have a weekend sausage sizzle at a hardware store embedded in their national mythology? That DIY attitude may be flowing

How scientists are hacking bacteria to treat cancer, self-destruct, then vanish without a trace
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Josephine Wright, Senior Research Fellow,, South Australian Health & Medical Research Institute Could engineered bacteria, including <i>Listeria monocytogenes</i>, help treat cancer? quantic69/Getty Bacteria are rapidly emerging as a new class of “living medicines” used to kill cancer cells. We’re still a long way from a “cure” for

Brazil claims to be an environmental leader. Are they?
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Pedro Fidelman, Associate professor in environmental policy and governance, The University of Queensland World leaders and delegates are meeting in the northern Brazilian city of Belém for COP30, this year’s major UN climate summit. This is the first time the global climate meeting has been held in

Extraordinary and occasionally inept: before The Dismissal, the Whitlam government changed Australia forever
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Michelle Arrow, Professor of History, President, Australian Historical Association, Macquarie University Wikimedia, facebook.com @Australian Labor Party, facebook.com @Whitlam Institute, Graeme Fletcher/Keystone/Getty Images, Australian Information Service/National Library of Australia When Australians of a certain age imagine Gough Whitlam, they probably think of him standing on the steps of

New interactive map shows how flammable your part of Australia is right now
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Marta Yebra, Director, Bushfire Resaerch Centre of Excellence, Australian National University Vegetation moisture changes in the Lake Magenta region, Western Australia, during 2020. Red shows drier vegetation, blue tones wetter areas. Digital Earth Australia Fuel Moisture Content This year’s fire season in Australia feels unpredictable. One week

Kneecap is revitalising Irish. These 5 artists are doing the same for Indigenous languages
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Jill Vaughan, Senior Lecturer, Monash University Emily Wurramara/Instagram Northern Irish hip hop trio Kneecap have been making waves, not just as musicians, but as language activists who rap in both English and their native Irish. In Belfast’s Gaeltacht Quarter, Irish is a living language. It is also

Caitlin Johnstone: The US empire keeps getting creepier
Report by Dr David Robie – Café Pacific. – COMMENTARY: By Caitlin Johnstone Secretary of War™ Pete Hegseth said during a speech on Friday that the US is at “a 1939 moment” of “mounting urgency” in which “enemies gather, threats grow,” adding, “We are not building for peacetime. We are pivoting the Pentagon and our

The ‘golden tonsils’ of John Laws fall silent, aged 90
Source: The Conversation (Au and NZ) – By Denis Muller, Senior Research Fellow, Centre for Advancing Journalism, The University of Melbourne John Laws was one of the most influential, commercially successful yet polarising figures in the history of Australian radio broadcasting. He has died at the age of 90. He was among a handful of

New Zealand Trotting Cup – all you need to know

Source: Radio New Zealand

Cameron Hart with Swayzee, who won the NZ Trotting Cup in 2023 and 2024. PHOTOSPORT

Partying racegoers at the New Zealand Trotting Cup meeting at Addington in Christchurch will get to see the best pacer in Australasia, the champion Leap to Fame, in action on Tuesday.

New Zealand Cup day is one of the big events on the Canterbury social calendar and the Cup, with a purse of $1 million, is also one of New Zealand racing’s pinnacle events.

Leap To Fame has dominated the pre-race discussion and the betting. On Monday he was a $1.60 favourite on the NZ TAB to win the big race.

Trained and driven by Queenslander Grant Dixon, Leap To Fame is hailed as a harness superstar, with 58 wins from 73 starts and earnings of just a tick over $5 million, an amount far in advance of any of his rivals on Tuesday. One of those wins was in his only start in New Zealand, when he won the $1 million The race by betcha, in Cambridge in April, in a track record.

Leap To Fame is also out to continue Australian and his own family’s dominance of the race in recent years. His half-brother Swayzee proved too good for his Kiwi opponents in the Cup in 2023 and did so again last year.

Swayzee suffered a setback in his preparation for this year’s Cup so isn’t running.

But another Aussie rising star, Kingman, has been a late entry after beating Leap To Fame in the Victoria Cup last month and is considered one of the main challengers.

The Kiwi challengers in the Cup

Republican Party looms as the biggest Kiwi threat to Leap To Fame.

Trained by Cran and Chrissie Dalgety in Canterbury and driven by their son Carter, Republican Party would be a popular winner. Cran Dalgety has had two seconds and three thirds in previous Cups and has joked he has served a 35-year apprenticeship for Tuesday’s Cup.

Blair Orange, NZ’s top harness driver, will pilot We Walk By Faith in the NZ Trotting Cup. Photosport

Republican Party can also surpass $1 million in stakemoney if he runs a top four placing, while Auckland pacer Merlin, who has won $1.6m, looked primed when he won the Kaikoura Cup last week.

Akuta, Don’t Stop Dreaming and We Walk By Faith are also rated solid chances.

Aussies to the fore in Dominion Trot

There are three other Group 1 races on the card, including $400,000 Dominion Trot.

Once again, the Australians have a strong hand, with mare Jilliby Ballerini the favourite and Gus and Arcee Phoenix also chances. The main Kiwi hopes in the betting are Oscar Bonavena, Muscle Mountain, Bet N Win and Mr Love.

The two other Group 1s are for three-year-olds. Race 8 is for the colts and geldings and race 9 is for fillies. Both races are over 1980m for stakes of $200,000.

World Driving Championship decided

The race meeting will also feature the final heat of the World Driving Championship, featuring 10 of the best drivers from around the globe. They have been competing around the country for the past 10 days.

Canadian James McDonald leads the series from Australian Gary Hall Junior, with New Zealand rep Blair Orange in fourth place.

The 20th heat in the series, race 3 at 12.54pm, will determine the winner.

Steph McGreavy (left) and Kit Winter-Davies from Timaru decked out with handmade felt fascinators. RNZ / Nathan Mckinnon

Off the race track, but no less competitive, is the annual fashion competition, with three different categories this year – best dressed, best suited and “something blue”. The winner will be announced after race 6 at 2.30pm.

There will be ongoing entertainment at The Infield, on the grass at the centre of the track. Shapeshifter will be playing there after the race meeting finishes.

Cup day will be followed by the Show Day meeting on Friday. It features two $500,000 slot races for three-year-olds and four other Group 1 races.

Facts

New Zealand Cup

Race 12 at 5:53pm

First run in 1904

Distance: 3200 metres

Winning stake: The winner receives $540,000, second $150,000, third $85,000, fourth $47,500, fifth $27,500, while all other starters receive $15,000.

Three horses have won the Cup three times: Terror To Love (2011-12-13), False Step (1958-59-60), Indianapolis (1934-35-36).

Race record: Lazarus 2016 – 3 minutes 53.1 seconds

Most wins as driver: Ricky May 7, Mark Purdon and Cecil Devine 6

May drives American Me in this year’s Cup, while Purdon pilots Akuta.

Previous Australian winners of the NZ Cup: Steel Jaw (1983), Lightning Blue (1987), Arden Rooney (2015), and Swayzee (2023, 2024).

Kerryn Manning became the first female to drive the Cup winner when Arden Rooney triumphed.

The Dominion Trot

Race 10 at 4.37pm.

Like the Cup, it is run over 3200m, but is a race for trotters rather than pacers in the Cup (despite the Cup being called the NZ Trotting Cup).

The difference between trotters and pacers? Trotters move their legs forward in diagonal pairs (e.g., front right and back left legs hit the ground simultaneously then front left and back right), while pacers’ legs move laterally (front right and back right, then front left and and back left).

Winner receives Lyell Creek (1999-2000-2004) and Sundees Son (2020-21-22) are the only horses to have won the Dominion three times in a row.

Most driving wins in the Dominion: Anthony Butt 8.

The Dominion Trot is two races before the Cup, at 4.37pm.

Gates open at 11am with first race at 12pm.

Betting: Punters bet $7.26 on the TAB on Cup day last year, a record for that day.

General admission: $25. The Infield tickets cost $90.

Weather: MetService is forecasting a sunny afternoon, northeasterly winds and a high of 19deg.

NZ Trotting Cup field:

1 Rakero Rocket

2 Lakelsa (E2)

3 Merlin

4 Pinseeker

5 Republican Party

6 Leap To Fame (Australia)

7 Vessem

8 Sooner The Bettor

9 Wag Star (E1)

10 Akuta

11 Here’s Herbie (E3)

12 Kingman

13 We Walk By Faith

14 American Me

15 Alta Meteor

16 Mo’unga

17 Don’t Stop Dreaming

18 Better Knuckle Up

Dominion Trot field:

1 Maui

2 Jilliby Ballerini

3 Hidden Talent

4 Arcee Phoenix

5 Mystic Max (E2)

6 One Over All

7 Muscle Mountain

8 Mighty Logan

9 Mr Love

10 Oscar Bonavena

11 Love N The Port (E1)

12 Father Time

13 Parisian Artiste

14 I Dream Of Jeannie

15 Midnight Dash

16 Paris Prince (E3)

17 Gus

18 Bet N Win

– Published by EveningReport.nz and AsiaPacificReport.nz, see: MIL OSI in partnership with Radio New Zealand

Two Kiwi perfume rebels invite you on a ‘Journey of Scent’

Source: Radio New Zealand

Self-taught scent artist Nathan Taare and French-trained perfume afficionado Whitney Steel deliver a fresh take on the fragrance world in the new RNZ series Journey of Scent.

While making the show was really fun, Steel says, it was a”nail-biting” moment presenting guests with their personalised perfumes, especially star chef Kia Kanuta.

“Because he has such a refined palate, I was like, ‘Oh my God, I’m going to get exposed … I really, really wanted him to love it,” she tells RNZ’s Afternoons.

This video is hosted on Youtube.