Source: Radio New Zealand

Witnesses are being sought in relation to the grounding of a catamaran at Akaroa on Banks Peninsula.

The Black Cat Cruises catamaran was beached at Nīkau Palm Valley Bay, after it got into trouble on Saturday afternoon – requiring more than 40 people to be rescued.

Environment Canterbury (ECAN) said the first phase of the recovery operation – fully submerging the catamaran in deep water to prevent further damage – is expected to get underway on Monday.

The second phase to remove it from the water, depended on the weather and safety requirements, it said.

ECAN said it was working with the Conservation Department, iwi, and Black Cat Cruises on the recovery and salvage, while the Transport Accident Investigation Commission said it would be investigating.

The commission’s chief investigator Louise Cook, told Morning Report, a team of investigators were in Akaroa and would be focusing on people’s memories and digital information regarding the grounding in the first instance.

Cook said the aim of the investigation was to ensure a similar incident did not happen again and would look at aspects including survivability and environmental impact.

She said witnesses to the incident were being sought and anyone who was present on the day should go to the commission’s website where they could submit information about it including photos and videos.

The inquiry could take between 12 months to two years to complete, Cook said.

Black Cat Cruises was approached for comment.

Longtime tourism operator, Tony Muir – who runs Coast Up Close – said the grounding hadn’t put a hold on scenic tours, but the exclusion zone around it, had changed what’s offered.

“Where they have it is right in the marine reserve, right at one of the highlights of the marine reserve.

“[On Sunday] afternoon we took a tour to the south, which is just fine as long as the weather conditions are fine… it’s a beautiful trip.

“But… this is one of the jewels in the Akaroa crown, where this vessel has been positioned.”

ECAN said the vessel was more significantly damaged than it anticipated and it was likely that all the fuel on board had leaked into the water.

It said the environment was coping, with oily sheens decreasing over time, and there were no signs of wildlife in distress.

A spokesperson said no fuel was able to be pumped out of the boat due to the nature of the incident.

“Most was discharged (likely in the early stages of the incident) due to the significant damage to the hull.”

Muir said it “wasn’t an ideal situation” but accidents happened and commended the crew for getting everyone off safely.

“It’s [now] up to all the powers that be to lessen the impacts the best they can.”

Following the near-sinking, Muir took his boat out on the water and helped with the clean-up.

“We went around and picked up a whole lot of rubbish, and plastic gloves, and puke bags and bits and pieces that had floated off it – we picked up quite a lot of that stuff just to get it out of the water.”

Fellow tour operator, Roy Borelli of Fox II Sailing Adventures, said he also scooped up some of the Black Cat’s debris.

He said his yacht, with 24 passengers on board, was one of the first on the scene on Saturday.

After a “wonderful sailing trip” where they’d been surrounded by dolphins, seeing the vessel was a bit of a shock.

“It was very… distressing seeing the boat listing. Because I’ve seen that boat almost every day that I’ve been working for the last 20 years.

“I know that boat. So, when you see it slowly sinking it’s very, very upsetting.”

He said he was one of many boats to offer assistance but ultimately wasn’t needed, and believed the catamaran ran itself aground to prevent it from sinking further.

Borrelli said there was still plenty of wildlife outside of the exclusion zone.

“We don’t know how long this is going to last, but it’s still an amazing harbour, and we have so much to see.

“We typically see dolphins, penguins, seals, and albatross on many of our trips.”

ECAN said the exclusion zone around the boat remained in place, and all non-response vessels must keep clear.

Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero, a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.

– Published by EveningReport.nz and AsiaPacificReport.nz, see: MIL OSI in partnership with Radio New Zealand

Source: Radio New Zealand

Principals fear many of the 15,000 senior secondary students who failed to reach the critical NCEA reading, writing and maths benchmark last year will give up on school or future study.

Figures provided to RNZ by NZQA showed nine percent of students in Year 13 and 15 percent of Year 12s had not achieved the literacy and numeracy co-requisite by the end of 2025.

That equated to about 5000 Year 13s and 10,000 Year 12s who would not receive any NCEA certificates because they had not yet met the requirement.

While most Year 12s would return to school for Year 13, principals told RNZ many of those who failed to meet the co-requisite were likely to lose heart and give up.

The achievement rates were the lowest in the past five years and principals warned they were likely to drag down the number of school-leavers with NCEA qualifications – in 2024 the number of school-leavers without a qualification hit 16 percent.

• Students leaving school with no qualifications highest in a decade

Porirua College principal Ragne Maxwell said some of the students who failed to achieve the co-requisite were in fact literate and numerate, but struggled to pass online exams in reading, writing and maths.

“The concern really is that some people are failing who are literate and numerate,” she said.

“It’s very difficult because they lose hope. It’s all very well to say just keep trying but the resilience to keep trying time after time when you just keep failing, it’s really challenging.”

Maxwell said students who failed were not likely to return to school to keep trying to pass the co-requisite.

Ragne Maxwell RNZ / John Gerritsen

“People who might have come back otherwise who have failed perhaps again in the case of Year 12 – failed in Year 11 … they’re giving up hope and not returning.”

Maxwell said the achievement rate would worsen in 2028 when the alternative pathway for meeting the literacy and numeracy requirement – 20 credits on top of the 60 required for an NCEA certificate – ended and the only way of achieving the co-requisite would be through the online tests.

“We’re just going to see more and more people failing, leaving school with no qualifications and having worse futures as an outcome of this, even though some of them are in fact literate and numerate,” she said.

Co-requisite achievement was lowest in schools serving the poorest communities.

Only 74 percent of Year 12s at those schools met the co-requisite by the end of last year, down from 85 percent in 2021 and for Year 13s the achievement rate was 88 percent, down from 93 percent.

Simon Craggs RNZ / Luka Forman

Papakura High School principal Simon Craggs said the figures were concerning.

Craggs said he hoped senior students who did not have the co-requisite would return, but he feared some would not.

“We’re very much hoping that most of them will come back and I think a significant proportion will, but there will be some students who get disillusioned that they’ve completed Year 12 and they have no qualifications and feel that they’re locked out of qualifications who will leave school.”

Craggs said the co-requisite had a bigger effect on qualification achievement at his school than at others last year.

“Our number of Year 12s that don’t have literacy and numeracy is significantly higher than the national figure or even the equity index band figure, so we’ve got a lot of work to do to support those students to be able to come back.

“Hopefully we don’t lose too many of them and we can continue to work hard with them on getting them across the line so they do leave school with qualifications.”

Mākoura College principal Simon Fuller said his school had NCEA achievement rates above 90 percent last year, well above the average for schools in similar communities.

He said students in Year 11 and some in Year 10 attempted the online reading, writing and maths tests, but those in Years 12-13 reached the benchmark through the alternative pathway of 20 extra NCEA credits in literacy and numeracy.

Simon Fuller RNZ / John Gerritsen

Fuller said the older students would not have performed so well if they had attempted the online tests.

“Those students haven’t had the benefit of the minister’s investment in structured literacy or numeracy,” he said.

“So they wouldn’t have performed so well, I believe, in sitting that external [exam] without the prep work.”

He said the tests were not well suited to schools in poor communities, neurodiverse students and many boys.

Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero, a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.

– Published by EveningReport.nz and AsiaPacificReport.nz, see: MIL OSI in partnership with Radio New Zealand

Source: Radio New Zealand

A world class museum on Canterbury’s picturesque Banks Peninsula will mark 50 years of hosting the South Island’s biggest and longest-running Waitangi Day commemorations on 6 February.

The Okains Bay Māori and Colonial Museum has one of the most significant historical collections in the country.

The museum and annual event were the brainchild of the museum’s founder Murray Thacker, whose passion for preservation formed the foundation of the vast 20,000-object collection of Māori and colonial artefacts, from waka to wagons, taonga puoro (traditional Māori instruments), kitchenalia, a blacksmiths forge and hei tiki.

The first Waitangi Day commemoration was held at the museum site in 1976 when an open day raised funds to finish the buildings, with the museum officially opened a year later on Waitangi Day 1977.

Manager Nigel Intemann said it was difficult to explain the significance of the Okains Bay collection to first-time visitors.

“You can imagine going to a metropolitan museum, you’re going to expect a really amazing collection, but to visit a small town like Okains Bay with so few residents, to come across such an extraordinary collection of national significance, it’s just amazing,” he said.

Intemann did not know the museum existed until he moved to the bay in 2020.

“Of course my first trip out here, I wondered why I’d never been here, then coming through the museum and absolutely realising that every New Zealander should make this journey,” he said.

The annual Waitangi event has traditionally been co-hosted with iwi, including a formal powhiri, kapa haka and hangi.

During the 1980s and early 1990s when the Ngāi Tahu claim was before the Waitangi Tribunal, the commemorations were an important platform for the iwi.

Since the late 90s, the iwi began alternating hui at each of the papatipu marae closest to the sites where rangatira signed Te Tiriti at Ōnuku, Te Rau Aroha and Ōtākou marae.

Ngāi Tahu and mana whenua Te Rūnanga o Koukourarata still play intrinsic roles in the museum and the commemorations but during years they are unavailable to co-host, such as 2026, the event becomes a family fun day without a powhiri or hangi.

The first event raised money for the whare taonga roof and was run as a fundraiser over many decades. In recent years, in line with tikanga, it has become a free event.

Intemann said fundraising was always front of mind, despite the day’s popularity and the museum’s national and international significance.

“Funding is one of the hardest aspects, especially in terms of paying bills. People like projects, they love to give you money for a new project, but if you keep building projects, you keep building costs in. Finding the money that keeps the lights on, that keeps the rates paid, is a continual effort,” he said.

On 6 February, blacksmiths fire up the forge, the three-tonne waka Kōtukumairangi is paddled up the Ōpara Stream and competitions including the famous tug o’ war are held in the museum courtyard.

The waka will not be launched this year because of an early high tide but will be on display in the whare waka.

Nor will there be one of the event’s highly sought after hangi in 2026, which feed 500 to 750 people.

However, a 150-year-old colonial oven will pump out hundreds of buns, sausages will be sizzled and stalls sell everything from kai moana to local cheese and wine.

The museum began as Thacker’s private collection, as the great grandson of some of the earliest Pākehā settlers in Okains Bay.

Board chair and Te Runanga o Ngāi Tahu representative Helen Brown said Thacker was drawn to history from an early age, collecting his first toki (adze) pounamu at the age of 9.

He would go on to amass a vast collection of taonga, from the prestigious – such as hei tiki and taiaha – to the less coveted mahinga kai (food gathering) equipment, which has seen the museum possess one of the best collections in the world of objects like nets, hinkai (eel traps) and kō digging sticks.

Brown said Thacker forged important relationships with Ngāi Tahu and Mātāwaka leaders from Ōtautahi (Christchurch) and Te Pataka o Rakaihautū (Banks Peninsula), who had a role in establishing the museum and discussed hosting an annual Waitangi commemoration.

“The Ngāi Tahu rangatira who supported the Waitangi Day commemorations at Okains Bay in those early years were very keen on the opportunity to educate people about Te Tiriti. There was always this idea of education and both tangata whenua and tangata tiriti coming together that was integral to Murray’s vision and was wholeheartedly supported by tangata whenua at the time,” she said.

While the first official Waitangi Day commemoration was held at the treaty grounds in 1934, 6 February did not become a public holiday until 1973 when the name was changed to New Zealand Day.

The Waitangi Day Act 1976 restored the former name, the same year Thacker held the first commemoration at Okains Bay.

Brown said the small museum punched above its weight.

“We care for three collections recognised as being of national significance. The jewel in the crown is the taonga Māori collection, there’s also a really significant antique arms collection and a collection of European boats,” she said.

Plans were underway to redevelop parts of the museum buildings, which were no longer fit for purpose, to protect its precious displays, and a fundraising campaign would be launched in the lead up to the museum’s 50th anniversary on Waitangi Day in 2027.

Visitor host Raukohe Hallett (Ngāti Hine, Tūwharetoa, Ngāti Kahungunu) said the opportunity to show visitors so many historical objects and tell the stories of the people who used them helped to bring the past alive.

Museum patron Nigel Hampton KC, who has been involved with the museum almost from its inception, described the Waitangi Day atmosphere as jubilant.

He said Thacker was ahead of his time in recognising the importance of commemorating beyond the treaty grounds.

“He saw individual events should be held up and down the country and started a trend to have that occur 50 years ago, before the museum was even properly created,” he said.

The museum’s collection of taonga Māori was “up to or beyond the standard of the country’s major metropolitan museums”.

“One of the outstanding things is that so much of the collection is on display, available to be seen and to be explained, and it’s the conversations – and I meant this quite sincerely – you as the viewer can have with the exhibits. They’ve got to commune with you and you with them and you get a much better understanding of the culture that lies behind and in those taonga,” he said.

“As a pākeha, you come to have a better understanding of the people that were here before our predecessors arrived.”

Continued support for the museum was vital, Hampton said.

“It seems extraordinary doesn’t it, that a small valley – not somewhere you pass through and stop but that has to be a destination – that such a place can have such a museum, such a treasure for all New Zealand. We must retain it,” he said.

Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero, a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.

– Published by EveningReport.nz and AsiaPacificReport.nz, see: MIL OSI in partnership with Radio New Zealand

Source: Radio New Zealand

As February begins we enter the last weeks of summer. It’s been a season of extremes, with record-breaking temperatures and heat warnings at the start being swept away by the devastating storms just after the new year began.

Following the warmer, settled weekend, you could be excused for wondering is summer making a comeback?

The short answer is most likely but it’ll be a bit of a roller coaster.

What is coming?

Niwa meteorologist Chris Brandolino said the start of February, although still uncertain, could bring dry clear weather for parts of the country.

“I think the theme for the next sort of probably week, maybe two weeks, is for much of the country, there is likely to be pretty dry conditions.”

That being said, Monday night and through to Tuesday will bring some rain for both islands before clearing out from Wednesday.

The West Coast will be the first to get some rain which would then move to the east coast, particularly Canterbury.

“They could be seeing a really significant drop of rain, now ahead of that rain it’ll be quite warm,” Brandolino said.

MetService had placed heavy rain watch on Fiordland and Westland south of Franz Josef Glacier until Monday.

There is also a heavy rain watch in Marlborough south of Seddon and Canterbury north of the Rangitata River until Tuesday night.

From Tuesday the South Island could see some cooler weather but in the upper north, Brandolino said it would be “grossly humid”.

“So Waikato, Bay of Plenty, Northland, Auckland, it is going to be a hot day.”

But a hot day does not mean a dry one because most of the North Island can expect “pockets of rain” on Monday and Tuesday.

“Because of that warmth and humidity, especially that tropical humidity, there could be some localised heavy showers. But it’ll be localised, it won’t be kind of a widespread thing.”

Despite the rocky start to the week, from Wednesday onwards most of the country was expected to have a “dry lean”, with the exception of some rain in Southland.

Temperatures on a roller coaster

The South Island was still in for a roller coaster ride with temperatures bouncing up and down.

Brandolino used Christchurch as an example saying the temperature could hit 30 degrees on Monday, but could also struggle to hit 20 on Tuesday.

Hawke’s Bay was forecast to see 28 degrees on Monday and Auckland was set to heat up to 28 degrees.

“So this is the up and down sort of roller coaster weather pattern in terms of temperature that’ll be especially prevalent for the South Island. The North Island will still see some variability, but it won’t be as wildly as dramatic as the South Island.”

“The upper North Island, so places like Auckland, places like Northland, they’re more likely to find kind of a steady, persistent sort of like summertime feel.”

Is La Nina still a thing?

New Zealand is currently experiencing La Nina conditions.

Brandolino said February and March have historically been the busiest times of the tropical cyclone season, irrespective of La Nina.

The late summer period sees the warmest ocean temperatures around New Zealand and up to the north of the tropics.

“Warm water is fuel. You need more than that, of course, to get a tropical cyclone, but that’s a key ingredient.”

When La Nina conditions are active, it plays a role in which areas are favoured to see tropical cyclones.

“What it does is it tilts the odds towards something developing between, say, Fiji and the Queensland coast.”

What about those storms brewing in the Pacific?

Brandolino said there had been tropical activity in the pacific, particularly between Fiji and New Caledonia, which had the possibility of moving towards New Zealand and causing a rainy Waitangi Day weekend.

The activity dissipated over the weekend, giving the country a much greater likelihood of a rain-free long weekend.

The impact of this tropical activity will instead be a wave of humidity.

“So, the reason for the warmth and humidity for the North Island on Monday is because what is left over of that tropical low, let’s call it, that was to our North, it’s going to make its way over the North Island.”

“I would say Waitangi is looking promising for people who want to get outdoors from much of the country.”

Brandolino said with so much changeable weather on the horizon, it was important keep up to date with the latest forecasts.

Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero, a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.

– Published by EveningReport.nz and AsiaPacificReport.nz, see: MIL OSI in partnership with Radio New Zealand

Source: Radio New Zealand

The muse for an iconic Dunedin statue has come face-to-face with her bronzed younger self nearly 60 years later and half a world away.

Catherine Lee was 9 when she posed as Wendy from Peter Pan for British sculptor Sir Cecil Thomas OBE in London.

The statue has been a beloved part of the Dunedin Botanic Garden since the 1960s, and on Sunday, Lee shared her experiences during a public talk before fairies and pirates descended for a Peter Pan-themed storytime picnic.

For Lee, now 68, seeing her younger self immortalised in bronze was like a homecoming.

She has been wanting to visit the sculpture for years and said seeing it was an arresting sight.

“I just remember taking this sharp intake of breath, sort of going ‘oh my god, it really exists on the other side of the world. It’s there. It’s me’. So it was a really heart stopping moment,” she said.

It all started nearly 60 years ago when her father answered a small ad posted in the window of a local shop.

She met Sir Cecil Thomas OBE, who gave his approved, before she started posing in his studio in South Kensington after school on Wednesdays.

She had to kneel on a hard stepladder with her arms out diagonally, looking upwards to capture Wendy in ‘flight’.

“Very precarious for the model,” Lee said.

It was incredibly uncomfortable so she could only hold the pose for 10 minutes at a time, but she enjoyed the overall experience, she said.

She never got to meet the two boys who posed as her brothers or the dog who sat in for Nana, but had a photo of the sculpture sitting on her mantle.

“Peter Pan has just always been a part of my life and I’ve read it obviously. We did the play at my school and I was the understudy for Wendy, but I actually played one of the Lost Boys,” she said.

“It’s sort of woven into the fabric of my life.”

Although this was her first New Zealand visit, she already knew the sculpture had made an impression – it is one of two Peter Pan-themed sculptures in the garden.

“When a friend of my father’s visited Dunedin and told the ladies in the gift shop that she knew the Wendy model, she was showered with free postcards of the statue with a message to the ‘Wendy Child’ written on the brown paper bag containing the postcards,” she said.

Lee did not get paid for the experience, but said Sir Cecil was extremely kind and good to her.

“He talked me a little bit like an adult, I think, and it made me feel quite grown up.”

Pirates, Wendy Darling and a Tinker Bell or two joined the Peter Pan storytime picnic.

Dunedin resident Katy Sinnott said generations of her family had loved the sculpture, including her mum.

“She has memories of them here when she was a child, and so it was really fun to bring my kids back to see them,” she said.

Sinnott grew up watching the Disney movies and reading the books and was excited to share that with her kids.

She spent the night before making a Tinker Bell costume for her 3-year-old daughter Sophie and they watched Peter Pan.

“Sophie loves the Peter Pan one and she loves seeing all of the Lost Boys all around the bottom and fairies and things like that, and pointing out little mice. And obviously, sitting on Nana the dog,” she said.

Ann remembered visiting the statue with her children during the school holidays.

“My children loved coming here to the gardens and the reason that dog’s nose is quite polished was partly their doing,” she said.

The sculpture – along with another Peter Pan sculpture by Sir Cecil – were the result of a donation by Green Island resident Harold Richmond.

Dunedin Botanic Garden manager Catherine Bradley said he was known for being a frugal man, but he loved to give back to the community.

He used to take orphans on outings.

“At the end of his outings, he would give the children a copy of the J.M.Barrie Peter Pan book. It was something that was very nostalgic to him and he thought all children should have the pleasure of reading, she said.

Wendy and her Attendants, also known as The Darling Children Learning to Fly, had been an iconic part of the garden for decades, she said.

“People come here with their grandchildren and children and share memories of when they were children, sitting on Nana the dog. It’s a very well polished sculpture which is what the purpose was for … for members of the public to enjoy,” she said.

There were not many sculptures in the garden, and Bradley said it was important that those included were a place for people to stop, take in their surrounds and spark joy or reflection.

She was delighted Lee could visit and share her experiences.

It was made possible in collaboration with the Dunedin Library and Friends of the Dunedin Botanic Garden, as well as through the generosity of Lee, Bradley said.

Since her Wendy days, Lee has studied in Oxford, ran a small opera company in Italy before returning to join the British Civil Service and eventually become the director-general in charge of policy at the Ministry of Justice.

She was a Commander of the British Empire in 2012 for her services to justice, and received the medal from the now King Charles III.

Lee flies home on Monday, but said the reunion had been the highlight of her trip.

“It’s so familiar, it’s been a really nice sort of homecoming.”

Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero, a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.

– Published by EveningReport.nz and AsiaPacificReport.nz, see: MIL OSI in partnership with Radio New Zealand

Source: Radio New Zealand

New rules allowing GPs and nurse practitioners to prescribe drugs to treat ADHD increase the risk of over-diagnosis, over-prescribing, addiction, psychosis and other harms, some clinicians are warning.

Christchurch hospitality worker Caity became increasingly anxious in the month after starting on ADHD medication.

“I just couldn’t shut my brain off at night, so I went 11 days without sleeping, which was definitely not fun.”

Then the TV started talking to her.

Caity had been prescribed atomoxetine by her GP while on the waiting list for an ADHD assessment.

It is not a controlled stimulant drug like Ritalin – but in rare cases, it can also trigger psychosis.

Admitted to Hillmorton Psychiatric Hospital, she was discharged too quickly.

“At that point I still believed probably about 50 percent of my psychosis, but I wasn’t a danger to myself or others so they didn’t really have a place for me.

“I was back within a month, and they were like ‘What happened? Why did you stop taking your meds?’ And I was ‘I don’t know’.”

Caity has since been diagnosed with ADHD but does not currently take medication, and has not had another psychotic episode.

Prescriptions rising

Since GPs lost their authority to prescribe stimulants in 1999 – due to worries about the potential for abuse – only psychiatrists and paediatricians have been able to initiate treatment.

Yet prescriptions for ADHD medications increased more than tenfold in the last two decades.

Wellington psychiatrist and addiction specialist Dr Sam McBride said it was “inevitable” that having more prescribers (GPs and nurse practitioners) would lead to more prescribing – and more negative impacts.

As happened now, some drugs would end up being “diverted” into the hands of people who had not been prescribed them, he said.

“A certain number of people come to harm from abusing them. A small proportion will develop addiction in the context of exposure to stimulants.

“We can expect a small number of people to have psychosis precipitated by these medications. And we can also expect some people will have physical effects due to exposure to stimulants.”

Those physical reactions could be short-term, like an irregular heartbeat, or become chronic, long-term problems.

There was also a risk to the wider health system: high demand for ADHD services could take “scarce medical resource” away from other parts of the health system.

“We’ll see the development of private providers meeting the need. And I’m unclear whether we’ll see the equity gains that were intended from the changes.”

Accused of ‘drug-seeking”‘

The lack of capacity in the public health system in the last few years has forced many people to pay hundreds or even thousands of dollars for an ADHD assessment.

Bella* waited more than nine months and paid nearly $1000 for an ADHD assessment by a psychiatrist – but felt “let down” by the experience.

“He said something along the lines of ‘a lot of people come in and try to get diagnosed so they can re-sell the medication’. It was like he had an idea of what I was trying to do that was completely inaccurate.”

Bella said she had already told the doctor she was not interested in medication, she just wanted a diagnosis.

“I cried throughout most of that session because I thought I was finally in a space where I was going to get answers and support, and to be put down in that way … I wasn’t expecting that at all.”

Three years on, she remains “really hurt” by the experience.

“I haven’t gone for a second opinion because I’m honestly worried that I won’t be seen for who I am or the mental hurdles that I overcome each day.”

However, she has researched widely and found her own ways to mitigate some of the problems, including turning off social media notifications, exercise, proper sleep and good food.

“It’s a lot of work and can be tiring, but the results have really paid off. I’ve also gone to therapy to work through some of the more ingrained habits and thought patterns, and I’m learning to accept myself and encourage the positive aspects of ADHD.”

She thinks she will “most likely” go to her doctor for a second opinion at some point, but is in no hurry.

It’s ‘big business’ – psychologist

A psychologist who worked at a private clinic specialising in neurodiversity said she left after witnessing “unethical and lazy practices”.

There were clinicians who treated it like “a box ticking exercise” or ignored red flags.

“I saw people being diagnosed that I am confident did not have ADHD and when I raised it, it was like I was stepping out of line,” said the woman, whom RNZ has agreed not to name.

In one devastating case, a teenager died of suspected suicide within weeks of being diagnosed with ADHD.

The psychologist believes no one adequately explored what was really going on for him.

A proper assessment should involve digging deep into family history, home-life, school, relationships, what trauma (even intergenerational trauma) could be involved.

“I don’t want to discredit it as a genuine diagnosis but I am really skeptical about the diagnostic framework, particularly as used by clinicians who claim to specialise in this area.

“It’s being used as an explanation for people’s difficulties too easily without considering other things.”

It was hard to say “no” to a client or parent who was desperately seeking a diagnosis, she said.

“There’s also a financial incentive to give people the answers they want.

“You’re talking about a private business that’s incentivised to keep clients on, send them onto the psychiatrist. It’s big business, and it’s concerning that the public don’t know that, you’ve got very vulnerable people coming in.

“It’s very frightening because the consumer has to come in with a lot of knowledge if looking for a diagnosis for themselves or their child.”

Furthermore, the huge pressure on mental health services meant there was also political pressure to get people seen quickly, she said.

“I’m really concerned about this pathway of making it easier and faster for less qualified people to diagnose ADHD.”

McBride said when a diagnosis was correct and properly managed and people were “well supported”, stimulants were useful.

They could even reduce the risk of people engaging in other addictive and risk-taking behaviour, he said.

However, they did not work for everyone, and treating ADHD was often much more complicated than just popping a pill.

“And I’m concerned that at present there’s been really little consideration given to monitoring any of these issues, educating the public about these issues, educating clinicians about these issues, and looking to contain some of these harms.”

Ministry to monitor

The Ministry of Health said only vocationally registered specialist GPs and nurse practitioners who had knowledge and skills in ADHD assessment and treatment would be able to diagnose and start patients on stimulant medicines.

“They must be confident they can do this safely, follow accepted clinical guidelines, and meet the professional standards set by their regulatory authorities.”

Prescribing would continue to follow “existing regulatory and clinical guidelines to ensure quality care and prevent misuse”.

“As with any regulatory change implemented by the Ministry, we will continually monitor the new framework to mitigate any risk.”

Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero, a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.

– Published by EveningReport.nz and AsiaPacificReport.nz, see: MIL OSI in partnership with Radio New Zealand

Source: Radio New Zealand

The recovery of a catamaran that grounded at Akaroa on Banks Peninsula is expected to begin on Monday.

The Black Cat Cruises catamaran was beached at Nīkau Palm Valley Bay, after it got into trouble on Saturday afternoon – requiring more than 40 people to be rescued.

Environment Canterbury (ECAN) said the first phase of the recovery operation – fully submerging the catamaran in deep water to prevent further damage – is expected to get underway on Monday.

The second phase to remove it from the water, depended on the weather and safety requirements, it said.

ECAN said it was working with the Conservation Department, iwi, and Black Cat Cruises on the recovery and salvage, while the Transport Accident Investigation Commission said it would be investigating.

Black Cat Cruises was approached for comment.

Longtime tourism operator, Tony Muir – who runs Coast Up Close – said the grounding hadn’t put a hold on scenic tours, but the exclusion zone around it, had changed what’s offered.

“Where they have it is right in the marine reserve, right at one of the highlights of the marine reserve.

“[On Sunday] afternoon we took a tour to the south, which is just fine as long as the weather conditions are fine… it’s a beautiful trip.

“But… this is one of the jewels in the Akaroa crown, where this vessel has been positioned.”

ECAN said the vessel was more significantly damaged than it anticipated and it was likely that all the fuel on board had leaked into the water.

It said the environment was coping, with oily sheens decreasing over time, and there were no signs of wildlife in distress.

A spokesperson said no fuel was able to be pumped out of the boat due to the nature of the incident.

“Most was discharged (likely in the early stages of the incident) due to the significant damage to the hull.”

Muir said it “wasn’t an ideal situation” but accidents happened and commended the crew for getting everyone off safely.

“It’s [now] up to all the powers that be to lessen the impacts the best they can.”

Following the near-sinking, Muir took his boat out on the water and helped with the clean-up.

“We went around and picked up a whole lot of rubbish, and plastic gloves, and puke bags and bits and pieces that had floated off it – we picked up quite a lot of that stuff just to get it out of the water.”

Fellow tour operator, Roy Borelli of Fox II Sailing Adventures, said he also scooped up some of the Black Cat’s debris.

He said his yacht, with 24 passengers on board, was one of the first on the scene on Saturday.

After a “wonderful sailing trip” where they’d been surrounded by dolphins, seeing the vessel was a bit of a shock.

“It was very… distressing seeing the boat listing. Because I’ve seen that boat almost every day that I’ve been working for the last 20 years.

“I know that boat. So, when you see it slowly sinking it’s very, very upsetting.”

He said he was one of many boats to offer assistance but ultimately wasn’t needed, and believed the catamaran ran itself aground to prevent it from sinking further.

Borrelli said there was still plenty of wildlife outside of the exclusion zone.

“We don’t know how long this is going to last, but it’s still an amazing harbour, and we have so much to see.

“We typically see dolphins, penguins, seals, and albatross on many of our trips.”

ECAN said the exclusion zone around the boat remained in place, and all non-response vessels must keep clear.

Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero, a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.

– Published by EveningReport.nz and AsiaPacificReport.nz, see: MIL OSI in partnership with Radio New Zealand

Source: Radio New Zealand

Home loan borrowers are switching banks in record numbers, chasing cash back incentives.

But who’s paying the price?

Reserve Bank data shows there was $14.1 billion of home loan lending in December, $3.6b more than the previous strongest month, which was March 2021.

Cotality chief property economist Kelvin Davidson said it was a “large spike” in lending activity, for both owner-occupiers and investors.

He said some of it was for people buying houses but the bulk of the activity came from people switching banks.

There was $5.8b in home loan lending refinanced in the month, more than double the previous high. Switches made up 41 percent of the total movement of lending, compared to the previous highest level of 30 percent in June.

Davidson said it was all driven by increased “cashback” activity – where banks try to tempt borrowers in by offering them a percentage of their loan total, in cash.

“Remember that the banks were all offering 1.5 percent cash for lending for a period of time in November, which then fed into December’s strength once the loans had actually been drawn down.”

Davidson said it seemed that borrowers with large loans and large incomes were playing a key role in the activity.

“The share of lending being done at a high debt-to-income lending (DTI) actually dropped fairly sharply in December; or in other words, a lot of lending or switching was done at lower DTIs. For example, in relation to investment collateral, high DTI loans fell from nearly 17 percent of the total in November before exemptions to around 12 percent in December.”

He said December’s data was a story of “huge gross churn”.

“Borrowers will have been the winners, although some banks may have gained market share.”

Not every borrower benefits?

But chief executive at mortgage broking firm Squirrel, David Cunningham, said not every borrower would benefit.

Those who could move banks would get the extra cash, but those who were not able to could end up paying a higher price.

People usually cannot move without paying break fees if some of their lending is on a fixed term, or for a number of years after they accept a cash back offer.

“What you end up with is your new customers get their 1.5 percent cashback, but existing customers go well, hold on, why are they getting this deal?”

People who could move might have decided to take up the offer at another bank instead, he said, creating a giant “pass the parcel” scenario of borrowers.

He said it left the question of what fixed rates the banks would be offering if they were not funding cash backs.

“I’d argue we would have got the one-year down at four percent, but cash backs have become the new battleground.”

He said banks no longer tried to compete with lower interest rates to get new business.

Those lower interest rates would also benefit existing borrowers who would be able to claim them when they came to refix even part of their mortgage, and they would not have to change banks to do so.

But Claire Matthews, a banking expert at Massey University, was not so sure that existing borrowers were losing out.

“I’m not convinced that cashbacks would be having a significant impact on interest rates because they are only generally available to a subset of customers, and they are a standard time of marketing tool to attract new customers.

“Despite cashbacks, I think banks do still compete on interest rates, because that is still a key driver for borrowers given the longer impact and they will be important to a large portion of customers. And if they don’t qualify for the cashback, borrowers can negotiate with their bank for a better deal.”

ANZ, which initiated the 1.5 percent cashback offer, said it was committed to offering competitive home loan rates, too, for existing borrowers and new customers.

“Customers consider a number of things when choosing who to get a home loan from – pricing, approval times and other incentives on offer. Cash contributions give customers extra support upfront, helping with the cost of moving, refinancing or other expenses.

“Our recent cash contribution campaign was distinct from our choices on interest rate settings. We saw strong demand for the cash contribution campaign but for commercial reasons we cannot release details of specific amounts.”

BNZ said it would look at each customer’s situation individually to ensure it was meeting their needs and giving them the best overall value.

“Cashbacks are one tool that can help customers with costs when purchasing their first home, moving house, or switching banks,” general manager of home lending product James Leydon said.

“We currently have a cashback offer for first home buyers, offering at least $5000 cash back on new home loans of $250,000 or more, even with a deposit as low as 5 percent.”

Sign up for Money with Susan Edmunds, a weekly newsletter covering all the things that affect how we make, spend and invest money.

– Published by EveningReport.nz and AsiaPacificReport.nz, see: MIL OSI in partnership with Radio New Zealand

Source: Radio New Zealand

The mayor of Tauranga says they’ll start opening up the area around Mount Maunganui when it’s safe to do so, as police finish their recovery efforts following the deadly landslide.

All six victims of the slip that hit the Mount have been recovered and identified.

Police on Sunday stood down their operation at the mount, and the scene is expected to be handed back to local council in the coming days.

Tauranga Mayor Mahé Drysdale told RNZ the area was still dangerous.

“We need to understand how we can make that as safe as possible, what that impacts, what we can and can’t open, and as soon as we’ve done that we’ll get to work to do what we need to, to get as much of the area open as we can,” he said.

Drysdale said he was hopeful streets could be reopened in a number of days.

As for Mauao itself, Drysdale said it could be a matter of months before it could be reopened.

He said they would work with local Iwi to assess the situation.

“We’ll be working closely with them to come up with a plan to firstly assess the damage, understand what we’re dealing with, and then put in a plan in place to get that opened up,” he said.

“But, looking at the significant damage, I think we are talking months at least until we can open that up safely.”

Drysdale said the community was still reeling from what happened.

“We’re going to be feeling this for months, if not years to come,” he said.

“However, knowing that all the bodies have been recovered, and now also identified, it does make things slightly easier knowing that the families can have some peace, knowing that their loved ones are returned.”

Mayor offers condolences, thanks community

The mayor released a statement late on Sunday, sharing his and other councillors’ condolences to the families of those who lost their lives in the slip.

“While loved ones lost in this terrible tragedy have now been returned, we will continue to offer support to the families in the years to come and have been blown away by the care they have been provided by the police family liaison team,” he said.

“We extend our profound gratitude to all the emergency workers and volunteers who have worked tirelessly and with immense care to bring the missing loved one’s home to their families.”

Drysdale said it had been humbling to see how hard everyone worked and came together to give the families with closure.

He also acknowledged and thanked the community response to the disaster.

“In times of tragedy, the true strength of Tauranga is revealed in our unity and compassion. We will continue to support one another in the time ahead as the recovery of this tragedy and Mauao continues.”

Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero, a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.

– Published by EveningReport.nz and AsiaPacificReport.nz, see: MIL OSI in partnership with Radio New Zealand

Source: Radio New Zealand

In less than 10 years, nearly 100 Chemist Warehouses and Bargain Chemists have opened across the country – so where does that leave local pharmacies?

New 12-month prescription rules came into force this weekend, saving time and cutting GP visits for patients – but community pharmacists warn they are the latest in a raft of changes in a sector that is struggling to survive.

The rules mean that people with long-term, stable conditions can now get prescriptions of up to a year from their prescriber, which the government says could save up to $105 in GP fees annually.

Pakuranga pharmacist Vicky Chan says the change has no financial impact on her business but it adds to the hours of unseen, unpaid work she and other community pharmacists do.

“There will be more clinical responsibilities to make sure their health circumstances haven’t changed and that’s almost on us, the community pharmacist,” she says.

Chan, a member of the Independent Community Pharmacy Group, says government funding has not kept pace with other costs and she has to work harder to keep her business viable by offering extra government-funded services such as sleep clinics.

She is looking at buying a $100,000 pill-counting robot for her Auckland pharmacy but she worries that her business may not be able to support the investment in the future, given the threat of increased competition from discount pharmacy chains.

“In east Auckland we have seen another local pharmacy closed three months ago and there will be another closing at the end of the month. If you look at the numbers of pharmacy closures, I think we’re almost 100 community pharmacies down from 2020.

“There are a lot of workforce pressures, smaller operators are finding it harder to recruit and retain, there’s the burnout after the covid response, we did see a lot of people leave the profession.

“The funding hasn’t been recalibrated in a way that fits the model now.”

Chan says she spends a lot of time on tasks that make no money because she wants to do the best for her customers, some of whom are third generation.

A study by University of Otago in 2021 found that unfunded customer services comprise a significant share – between 15 and 50 percent – of a pharmacist’s daily activities, requiring cross-subsidisation using revenue from other activities like dispensing or retail sales.

https://ourarchive.otago.ac.nz/esploro/outputs/doctoral/Investigating-pharmacy-provision-patient-utilisation-and/9926478231001891

“I think a lot of work we do is invisible, that has helped reduce pressures on the GP, but also reduced ED (emergency department) admissions because we were able to pick those things up early, because we have that relationship with our patients,” Chan says.

Wainuiomata pharmacist Clive Cannons says people can come in to ask for a free diagnosis on an ailment or treatment, but there is nothing to stop them going elsewhere to buy the medicine if they think they can get it cheaper online or at a discount pharmacy.

He gets emotional when he talks about the threat to the 1000-odd community pharmacies around the country.

“I’m very worried,” says Cannons, chair of the community pharmacy group.

“We’ve lost our local GPs, we’ve lost those things that hold communities together and the last bastion is the local pharmacy.”

He admits that not all local pharmacies offer a top quality service and the sector needs to help itself to adjust to the growing competition from Chemist Warehouse and Bargain Chemist.

“However, there is a need for that high-service model where the owner knows their community,” he says.

Cannons’ group is calling for country-wide consistency in the way Health NZ grants contracts under the National Pharmacy Agreement.

In his Hutt Valley region he says new pharmacies can only get an agreement if the local funders consider there is a need. In other regions agreements are more accessible but that leads to oversupply.

He calls Pukekohe, on the southern edge of Auckland, “ground zero”. With a population of around 28,000, it has 13 pharmacies clustered in a high-volume area. Other parts of Auckland are also oversupplied, and many community pharmacies are struggling to break even.

Cannons’ group is also fighting industry deregulation proposals that would open up the pharmacies to non-pharmacists by removing the Effective Control Principles. Under those rules, pharmacies have to be more than 50 percent owned by pharmacists.

The associate health minister Casey Costello says deregulation will enable different models for pharmacy ownership, “allowing for more innovative and integrated healthcare that will improve safe access to medicines”.

A supporter of deregulation, Dr Eric Crampton of the think tank NZ Initiative, wrote last year that the existing ownership rules protect pharmacies, calling it an “odd little regulatory cartel”.

He cited a Ministry of Health report that it has not seen any clear evidence that the ownership restrictions contribute to patient safety or service quality.

Cannons disagrees.

“The questions is, what do the people of New Zealand want? What sort of pharmacy industry does the man on the street want. If they want us to go like America then that’s exactly what’s going to happen.”

Check out how to listen to and follow The Detail here.

You can also stay up-to-date by liking us on Facebook or following us on Twitter.

– Published by EveningReport.nz and AsiaPacificReport.nz, see: MIL OSI in partnership with Radio New Zealand

Source: Radio New Zealand

Heavy rain and strong winds are forecast to affect parts of the South Island from early Monday through to late Tuesday, with MetService issuing a series of severe weather watches.

MetService says a front will bring a period of heavy rain to Fiordland and southern Westland from early Monday, before a low-pressure system moves across the South Island on Tuesday, spreading heavy rain to parts of Canterbury and Marlborough and bringing the risk of southeast gales to the West Coast and Fiordland.

A heavy rain watch is in place for Fiordland from 12am to 3pm Monday. A period of heavy rain is expected that may approach warning levels.

The ranges of Westland south of Fox Glacier, including parts of Mt Aspiring National Park, are also under a heavy rain watch from 6am to 9pm Monday. There is a moderate chance the watch could be upgraded.

Further east, a heavy rain watch has been issued for Marlborough, south of Seddon, and Canterbury, north of the Rangitata River, from 2am to 10pm on Tuesday. Periods of heavy rain are expected, with totals that may approach warning levels.

Strong winds are also forecast on Tuesday, with a strong wind watch in place for the Westland and Grey Districts from 3am to 7pm. Southeast winds may approach severe gale strength in exposed places, with a moderate chance that the watch could be upgraded.

A separate strong wind watch covers Fiordland from 2am to 11am Tuesday, where southeast winds may also approach severe gale force in exposed areas.

Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero, a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.

– Published by EveningReport.nz and AsiaPacificReport.nz, see: MIL OSI in partnership with Radio New Zealand

Source: Radio New Zealand

– Published by EveningReport.nz and AsiaPacificReport.nz, see: MIL OSI in partnership with Radio New Zealand

Source: Radio New Zealand

A tourist boat that grounded in Akaroa on Banks Peninsula is more damaged than thought, with Environment Canterbury believing all fuel has leaked into the sea.

The Black Cat Cruises boat remains inside the marine reserve, after it got into trouble on Saturday afternoon – with more than 40 people requiring rescue.

Environment Canterbury (ECAN) said the boat sustained “more significant damage” than anticipated and it was likely that the “full amount of marine diesel fuel” on board was released into the water.

It earlier said the boat was carrying 2240 litres of marine diesel fuel and around 120 litres of other oils in sealed containers and engines combined.

In a statement on Sunday, it said the environment was coping well with the fuel, with oil sheens decreasing over the course of the day.

“Wildlife specialists are on standby, and precautions are in place to mitigate any potential impacts to the surrounding environment. No wildlife in distress have been observed at this time.”

The agency said a recovery plan that minimised further environmental risk was underway in collaboration with iwi, the Department of Conservation, a salvage team and Black Cat Cruises.

It said the first phase of the recovery would see the boat fully submerged in deeper water to prevent further damage.

The second phase to lift the boat out of the water would depend on the weather and safety requirements, it said.

ECAN said the operation would begin in the next 24 hours, with phase one expected to be completed on Monday.

ECAN regional on-scene commander Emma Parr said the recovery operation was complex.

“We appreciate the support of all agencies and the local community as we work through the safest approach.”

Concerns

A conservation group said authorities were not doing enough to protect Hector’s dolphins in Akaroa Harbour.

Maui and Hector’s Dolphin Defenders said tourism pressure in Akaroa Harbour was relentless and oversight hadn’t kept pace.

Its chair Christine Rose said the grounding was a symptom of New Zealand’s commodification of nature for tourist dollars.

Councillor Tyrone Fields said it was the second time a boat had grounded in a sensitive area in three years.

He said he was deeply concerned about the impact the grounding had had on the environment.

The Transport Accident Investigation Commission said it would be on the ground in Akaroa to investigate the grounding of the ferry.

Black Cat Cruises has been approached for comment.

Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero, a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.

– Published by EveningReport.nz and AsiaPacificReport.nz, see: MIL OSI in partnership with Radio New Zealand

Source: Radio New Zealand

A group of dirt bikers in South Auckland have put lives at risk after driving into oncoming traffic, over footpaths and across fields where children were playing, say police.

A number of emergency calls were made at about 3:45pm.

Police said the Eagle helicopter and dozens of staff were diverted to try and split the group up, while police also worked with local petrol stations in case the group attempted to refuel.

At one point, there were 40 bikers, police said.

Tāmaki Makaurau Duty Operations Manager Inspector Kerry Watson said police were asking for the public’s help before someone was killed.

“We’re asking for assistance from the public so we can locate these riders as soon as possible before they kill someone or themselves.

“There are no other words – it was horrifying behaviour, and to see riders speeding across sport fields where young kids are playing… you feel ill, because if something goes wrong, someone is going to be maimed or dead.

“We are combing through CCTV footage, frame by frame, to identify those who were involved in this display of stupidity, and when we find out who they are, we’re going to have words.”

She asked anyone with dashcam or CCTV imagery that may assist to get in touch.

A 25-year-old Ōtara man faces serious charges of reckless driving and aggravated failing to stop.

Inspector Watson said the 25-year-old’s bike had been impounded, and anyone involved would also lose their bikes once caught.

“Losing your bike isn’t the worst outcome when you consider that eventually someone is going to die riding like this, or they’re going to kill an innocent person.”

Anyone with information is asked to make a report at 105.police.govt.nz or by calling 105.

Please use the reference number P065318019.

Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero, a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.

– Published by EveningReport.nz and AsiaPacificReport.nz, see: MIL OSI in partnership with Radio New Zealand

Source: Radio New Zealand

“I can look at our protectors – our maunga – around us and there’s huge slips gashing them,” Civil Defence incident management leader Trudy Nawhare told RNZ’s Checkpoint last Monday.

“One of our whanau described it as just like a movie – or something you might see on the TV.”

She was describing the damage in Te Araroa on the East Cape. At the height of the danger, Newstalk ZB reported Civil Defence officials there telling whanau to tie their tamariki to themselves and wait for rescue from floodwaters.

The disaster-movie scenes Nawhare described also played out on TV news – from Northland, Coromandel, elsewhere in Tairawhiti and the Bay of Plenty – but in Mount Maunganui, it wasn’t just the scars of storm damage on the hillsides.

The catastrophic slip from Mauao onto Beachside Holiday Park killed six campers and became the focus of the media coverage for days.

Eyewitness Alistair McHardy gave TVNZ News chilling phone footage of a slip he filmed in the early hours of the morning. He also gave a chilling account of his own helplessness when disaster struck after 9am.

The Herald vividly described how Morrinsville teacher Lisa Maclennan also raised the alarm and saved lives – but didn’t live to tell the media about it herself.

Images of the giant slip from overhead were heavily used by the media, but perhaps the starkest image this past week was the Bay of Plenty Times front page on Monday.

It bore the names of Maclennan and five other victims on a stark black background, and a statement from Ngati Ranginui: “Those who have passed now become part of the sacred fabric of our Maunga. Their wairua will rest forever, beneath the mantle of Mauao, protected and embraced for all time.”

Pointing the finger

Along with neighbouring Ngāti Rangi and Ngāti Pūkenga, Ngāti Ranginui administers the maunga through the Mauao Trust. The prime minister thanked them all for their support of people who were displaced and traumatised – and for their help with the recovery, but on social media, the iwi were accused of contributing to the catastrophe.

Online posts that claimed the removal of non-native trees for protection of culturally significant sites contributed to the landslide were widely shared.

“It was a day of disappointment, as the prime minister had to shut down what he called racist misinformation over the role of iwi in the landslide,” said ThreeNews on Monday.

[embedded content]

“I’m aware there’s a lot of misinformation and stuff going on out there,” Prime Minister Christopher Luxon told reporters. “The people on the margins with their rhetoric – they just need to frankly keep it to themselves.”

He didn’t name names, but Cameron ‘Whale Oil’ Slater said on X that the landslides “may have been the result of co-governance of the Mount”. He alleged Māori had demanded removal of large non-native trees recently at the main slip site.

Alternative news sites online also aired claims that the deadly landslide was avoidable, and may have been sparked by the removal of stabilising trees and at the iwi’s request.

Several cited the analysis of retired civil engineer Rod Kane, who claimed to have 20 years of experience in slope stability and remediation.

“It’s now fairly evident that the Tauranga council, at the insistence of iwi in using ratepayers money, removed big trees in the area of the slip simply because they were colonial,” Kane said in his own online post. “This is where superstition, stupidity and cultural arrogance hits the brick wall.”

He went on to warn of what he called “fake tribalists” and “12th century spiritual nonsense”, encouraged by what he called “stupid governments and councils and the media”.

Clearly, it wasn’t just geotechnical evidence informing Kane’s conclusion. In a rambling interview with Counterspin Media, Kane and the host claimed the removal of “naughty racist trees” contributed to the slip – and aired concerns about inept politicians, the RMA, “uncontrolled immigration” and Te Pāti Māori “pushing for civil war”.

Broadcaster Duncan Garner was persuaded by Kane’s account, reading it aloud on his MediaWorks podcast ‘Editor In Chief’.

“Colonial trees were removed at the insistence of the owners, the local iwi, not because of science, but because they were colonial trees – despite basic geotech reality, because symbolism mattered more than stability.”

“Six people… died because human decisions altered the land in 2017,” Garner told his listeners.

News media clear up the picture

Under the headline ‘Did tree removal really trigger the Mount Maunganui landslide?’ Dr Andrew Stolter from the University of Auckland’s Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering told Stuff: “Not really.”

Removing trees could contribute to instability, he said, but also tree roots may not be deep enough to control a deep, fast-moving slip like that one. Extreme weather and soil conditions were the big factors, he said.

So did Professor Ewan Mason from the University of Canterbury, who told Stuff the removal of trees in 2022 and 2023 would not be the sole reason for the tragedy.

“The surface of it is riddled by past landslides, which have occurred some recently in the last couple of decades, but also some long before European settlement,” University of Auckland professor of Applied Geology Martin Brook also told the Herald Now show.

Martin Brook followed that up with an article widely republished in our media this week, in which he said that the campsite itself was built on deposits from previous slips long ago.

Mauao may have been a disaster waiting to be triggered by extreme weather, but not solely for the reasons that some non-experts claimed online.

News you can trust

Once the emergency subsides, politicians might ponder the benefit of people getting information from accountable news outlets – rather than scattergun blurts on social media, where there’s no real recourse at all for falsehoods and bad-faith opinions.

Co-incidentally, last Wednesday, ACT MP Laura McClure lodged a Member’s Bill to scrap the state-backed agency upholding standards in broadcasting, the Broadcasting Standards Authority.

“In a free country, the ultimate broadcasting standard is the judgment of the audience,” the ACT party said in its announcement of McClure’s move, which would mean broadcasters couldn’t be held to account at all.

“How do you make sure that people have some kind of news that they can loosely trust?” Newstalk ZB’s Ryan Bridge asked her.

“When something big happens, you go to a trusted source. Do you not need some regulation for that?”

“Given the fact that people are consuming media in all kinds of different places, it really is unfair for mainstream media to have to adhere to paying levies,” McClure replied. Broadcasters pay a modest $500 for each $1m in revenue annually for BSA levies.

“I do think it is important for people to have oversight and trust and accountability, and I think that we’ve got enough there.”

She didn’t mention that broadcasters themselves drew up the broadcasting standards, alongside the BSA itself, and those standards mirror their own editorial principles and guidelines. Scraping the BSA complaints system would probably mean more complaints ending up in court – a much bigger liability for broadcasters.

If McClure’s Bill is drawn from the ballot, MPs would have to decide if extending the free-for-all of the internet to broadcasting is really in the interests of New Zealanders, who mostly say they do want news they can trust, when asked in opinion surveys.

What happened – and what happens next

After last week’s tragedy, probing journalism revealed that warnings were missed at Mount Maunganui, emergency calls may have been mishandled and opportunities to save lives possibly squandered.

Under the headline [‘Should warnings have been seen?’ https://www.thepost.co.nz/nz-news/360936602/mt-maunganui-landslide-should-warnings-have-been-seen] the Weekend Post had six senior journalists on the case.

The Post‘ national affairs editor Andrea Vance concluded there was no system to escalate the response in place and critical information stayed in silos.

Last Tuesday, RNZ’s Phil Pennington revealed that, after a big storm in 2005, geotechnical engineers told Tauranga City Council buildings should not be in “run-out zones” that might be inundated in a slip, unless they had been specially protected.

The prime minister was not alone in his surprise to be told this week that landslides have killed more Kiwis in our history than any other natural hazard.

“I had no idea until this week,” Newstalk ZB host Jack Tame said on air last Monday.

“Just as Pike River was a catalyst for huge health and safety law reforms, the Mount Maunganui disaster is fast shaping up as a watershed moment for property owners and councils, when it comes to liability around the country,” Tame said.

The media will have a role in whether it is a watershed or not.

Learning the lessons and making a plan

Some of Tame’s media peers were not so hopeful.

“I’ve seen this too many times with reports into disasters,” RNZ’s Morning Report host Corin Dann said on the political panel show ‘The Whip’ last Wednesday. “They don’t get acted on properly – or they don’t get implemented or it’s taken too long… and then it drags and it gets lost in bureaucracy.”

ZB host Andrew Dickens earlier echoed that fear.

“We’ve had this before,” he said. “Whether it’s Pike River or Cave Creek or the Wahine, after time has passed, we have a review, but by that stage, the heat has gone out of the argument.

“Maybe you should not just blindly trust your fellow citizens who say, ‘Yeah, sweet, it’s never happened before, so don’t worry about it’.”

Talkback hosts change their tune

Coincidentally, Dickens was saying that on ZB last Monday, on the third anniversary of the Auckland Anniversary Day floods. When Cyclone Gabrielle was bearing down on Hawke’s Bay and Coromandel days later, Dickens pushed back hard at talkback callers claiming the warnings were overblown and unnecessary.

The biggest names on the same radio network were also saying that. Mike Hosking, Kate Hawkesby and Kerre Woodham all condemned school closures and evacuation warnings as fear-driven overreactions.

Three years on, after the catastrophes at Mount Maunganui and Welcome Bay, Hosking was this week earnestly pondering whether this would end up changing where we build and live.

He told listeners it was a bit too soon after the tragedy for that discussion, but Woodham did have that discussion on her ZB talkback show last Tuesday, after telling her listeners the deadly landslide was “horrifying, but not unexpected”.

“In some instances, though, do we just need to acknowledge that we are no match for the power of nature, concede defeat and step away?” she asked.

Several ZB listeners got in touch to say it was too soon to ponder that sort of thing and more said the same of claims that the tragedy had been caused by climate change.

Those making that case included the prime minister.

“I’ve talked about that for years,” he told RNZ’s Morning Report on Tuesday from Mount Maunganui.

“I just think, if you’re a doubter of climate change having an impact on extreme weather events, I’d give that up, because there’s no doubt there’s that connection.”

Last weekend’s Otago Daily Times editorial was even more blunt under the headline ‘It’s climate change, stupid’. That was directed at the doubters and deniers, and not the prime minister, but this bit of the editorial was:

“Economy was mentioned 18 times in Christopher Luxon’s State of the Nation speech this week, but climate change? Not once.

“It was a speech about wanting to ensure the best possible future for Kiwis, which completely ignored the most pressing issue the same day.”

The Post editorial the same day was also unequivocal.

“If you ask why this summer’s been wetter than the golden Kiwi summers you remember, the answer is climate change. There’ll be some who say it’s too soon to talk about climate change while the search for bodies is ongoing.

“They’ll say the commentary is politicising the tragedy, but the reality is that rather than too soon – it may be too late.”

Tauranga City Council, which owns Beachside Holiday Park, has commissioned its own review of last week’s disaster and, having seen the damage up close for himself, the prime minister was persuaded to propose a wider one as well.

While arguments fade about ‘the right time’ to talk about those things, the inquiries will be done in the knowledge that what happened at Mount Maunganui and Welcome Bay could happen almost anywhere in the country at almost any time.

Journalists have already identified the issues that need to be tackled.

This week, RNZ’s Kirsty Johnston detailed a “growing gap between disaster recovery and climate preparation.”

It showed a pattern of spending heavily after disasters strike, but investing comparatively little upfront to reduce future risk, even though Treasury has highlighted this growing future fiscal liability for the Crown.

“While we still can and perhaps just still be able to afford it, we must act in unity,” The Weekend Herald editorial said.

AA Insurance’s move this week to halt new home insurance policies in Westport because of flood risk was timely.

“If we continue down the same road of reaction, then some communities will face the prospect of being abandoned, if not by its people, then by those holding the purse strings – the insurance companies and government,” the Weekend Herald said.

Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero, a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.

– Published by EveningReport.nz and AsiaPacificReport.nz, see: MIL OSI in partnership with Radio New Zealand

Source: Radio New Zealand

The biosecurity part of the Border Processing Levy has dropped by 30 percent.

It has reduced from $16.92 to $12.03 for incoming air passengers.

The Border Processing Levy funds x-ray screening, detector dogs and other protections.

Biosecurity New Zealand had raised it to cover border costs and rebuild operations after Covid-19.

Biosecurity Minister Andrew Hoggard said those costs were now paid off, with air travel recovering faster than expected.

“It’s great to be in a position to ease costs on international travellers and Kiwis coming home, while still keeping our border safe from environmental and economic threats,” he said.

Biosecurity New Zealand will also invest in new border technology and more detector dogs.

Hoggard said it had set aside funding for a new digital border programme that would build on the introduction of the New Zealand Traveller Declaration, as well as deliver smarter passenger processing and new x-ray technology.

Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero, a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.

– Published by EveningReport.nz and AsiaPacificReport.nz, see: MIL OSI in partnership with Radio New Zealand

Source: Radio New Zealand

One person has died following a two-vehicle crash on Puketutu Road, near Matamata.

Police were called to the crash between Matai Road and Buckland Road at about 12.15pm Sunday.

The road was closed, while the Serious Crash Unit conducted a scene examination, and it has now been re-opened.

Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero, a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.

– Published by EveningReport.nz and AsiaPacificReport.nz, see: MIL OSI in partnership with Radio New Zealand

Source: Radio New Zealand

– Published by EveningReport.nz and AsiaPacificReport.nz, see: MIL OSI in partnership with Radio New Zealand

Source: Radio New Zealand

Police have officially stood down all recovery operations at Mount Maunganui, following a fatal landslide last month.

Bay of Plenty District Commander Superintendent Tim Anderson said Disaster Victim Identification (DVI) and Search and Rescue teams had stopped all work, and would leave the scene.

“The families were notified of this update yesterday evening. This completes the recovery operation.

“While police will no longer be working at the scene, technology remains in place to monitor any land movements.”

Cordons still in place

Cordons remain in place around Adams Avenue, The Mall and Marine Parade.

Anderson said police would work with council and geotechnical experts to determine when it was safe to reduce the cordons.

“These remain in place for the safety of those who remain on the site, but also for the safety of the public.

“We expect to formally hand the scene over to Tauranga City Council in the coming days.”

Next steps

Police have said they would now support any subsequent coronial inquest into the tragedy.

WorkSafe continues to scope its involvement in the next phase of the response.

Police have signed an operational protocol for information-sharing with WorkSafe New Zealand to avoid duplication of efforts and to facilitate the next stage of inquiries.

“Police will be formally speaking to witnesses and gathering as much information that we can to assist WorkSafe,” Anderson said.

“A number of police staff from around the country will be assisting with this next phase of work.”

WorkSafe’s role would be to look into those organisations with a duty of care for people at the holiday park, and whether they met their work health and safety responsibilities.

All six victims formally identified

Superintendent Anderson said, as of Saturday night, all six victims had been formally identified.

“We are very relieved for the families that all their loved ones have now been returned to them.

“The last 11 days have been extremely difficult for them, waiting for their loved ones to be found and returned to them.”

Police would continue to provide ongoing wraparound support to the families of the victims.

“While we cannot take the pain away, we hope that being re-united with their loved ones can help give them some closure.

“Our family liaison officers have put in an immense amount of work to support these grieving families.

“I could not be more impressed by them in regard to their compassion, dedication and professionalism.”

Hundreds from different regions helped with operation

Anderson commended all agencies involved for their assistance during a difficult operation.

“On reflection, it has been a privilege to work alongside our colleagues, partners and volunteers for a common purpose.

“We have united to bring the families some form of closure out of this absolute tragedy.”

Police have utilised hundreds of staff from across several regions, including specialist staff over the course of this operation.

“At the peak of our operations, close to 100 police staff were assisting on a daily basis.

“We all had one goal and that was to re-unite families with their loved ones, but also to support these families through what has been an incredibly difficult time.

“I’m immensely proud of every single person who has worked tirelessly on this operation.”

Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero, a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.

– Published by EveningReport.nz and AsiaPacificReport.nz, see: MIL OSI in partnership with Radio New Zealand

Source: Radio New Zealand

One person has been seriously injured in a two-vehicle crash on Puketutu Road, near Matamata.

Police were called to the crash between Matai Road and Buckland Road at about 12.15pm Sunday.

Emergency services were at the scene and the road was closed.

The Serious Crash Unit was notified and will examine the scene.

Motorists were advised to avoid the area and expect delays.

Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero, a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.

– Published by EveningReport.nz and AsiaPacificReport.nz, see: MIL OSI in partnership with Radio New Zealand

Source: Radio New Zealand

One person has died after a crash north of Lake Wakatipu.

Emergency services were called about 4.40am Sunday, after two vehicles collided on the Glenorchy-Routeburn Road, police said.

One person died at the scene and one was in a serious condition.

The road was still partially blocked just before 1pm Sunday, as emergency services and the Serious Crash Unit worked at the scene.

“Our thoughts and sympathies are with those involved,” they said.

“There are no available diversions and the road is partially opening when possible.”

Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero, a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.

– Published by EveningReport.nz and AsiaPacificReport.nz, see: MIL OSI in partnership with Radio New Zealand

Source: Radio New Zealand

“There was nothing that could have prepared us for this.”

A memorial ceremony for young landslide victim Max Furse-Kee will be livestreamed, his mother said on Sunday, to remember an impactful life cut short.

The teenager died, along with his girlfriend 15-year-old Sharon Maccanico and four others, after a landslide struck a Mt Maunganui campground on Thursday 22 January. His body was formally identified by a coroner on 28 January, the day that would have been his 16th birthday.

Max’s family was now trying to come to terms with life without him, his mother Hannah Furse said in a statement on Sunday.

“Our beloved Max was suddenly and unimaginably taken from us. Max was our communal baby, a beautiful soul who brought immense light, laughter, and love into our world.

“There was nothing that could have prepared us for this.”

While Max’s life was short in years, it had been “deeply meaningful” for those who knew him, she said.

The family had been “overwhelmed by messages of love, comfort, and support” sent to them from throughout New Zealand and around the world.

“While we do not have the capacity to respond individually, please know that we are reading them all, and they mean more to us than we could ever express.”

Furse said it was special to her that Max was spending time with people who loved him when the tragedy struck.

“Max was not doing anything reckless, and this tragedy was not the result of poor judgement or a lack of care. He simply went to take a shower, in the wrong place at the wrong time.

“We take great comfort in knowing that Max spent his final days with Sharon, someone he loved so deeply, and with her family, who loved him too.”

The memorial ceremony to celebrate his life would be held on Wednesday 4 February, but would be small, his mother said.

“We respectfully ask that attendance be limited to family and close friends. A live stream will be available for those who wish to honour Max from afar.”

The family asked for privacy as they grieved.

“We are grieving not only the person we have lost, but all the milestones, memories, and future moments that will now never be. No words are big enough to capture this pain.

“Please keep Max and all the other affected families in your thoughts. Love your loved ones, life can be heartbreakingly unfair.”

The family also wanted to thank those who had worked at the Mauao scene.

“We would also like to extend our heartfelt thanks to New Zealand Police, Fire and Emergency New Zealand’s Urban Search and Rescue (USAR), the Rapid Relief Team, all the machinery operators who worked extremely carefully, local Iwi, Kaitiaki and our incredible Police Family Liaison Officers.

“You have worked tirelessly to care for us and to bring Max home.

“We have seen how deeply this has affected everyone involved, and your compassion and kindness will help carry us through the days ahead.”

Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero, a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.

– Published by EveningReport.nz and AsiaPacificReport.nz, see: MIL OSI in partnership with Radio New Zealand

Source: Radio New Zealand

New Zealand teenager Sam Ruthe has smashed the under-18 world record for the mile and put the athletics world on notice in a phenomenal run at an indoor meet in Boston.

The 16-year-old ran three minutes 48.88 seconds at the John Thomas Terrier Classic meet at Boston University, leaving the field in his wake.

Ruthe became the youngest athlete to ever a run a mile quicker than 3:50 and eclipsed the overall New Zealand mile record held by Sir John Walker for 44 years.

Walker set his record of 3:49.08 in 1982 outdoors at Oslo.

Athletics indoor and outdoor records are traditionally maintained as separate, distinct, and official, according to World Athletics because of the differences in track size – 200m vs 400m.

Ruthe’s time is also the 11th quickest run indoors by any athlete, although he is still 3.70sec outside the extraordinary world record posted a year ago by Norway’s Jakob Ingebrigtsen.

Ruthe said his time far exceeded his expectations.

“When I was coming into this race I was expecting to run sub 3:55, I wasn’t really expecting a PB,” he told the track broadcast.

Part of his surprise came because he was still feeling the effects of the long journey to the US.

“I flew out here three days ago from New Zealand, 50 hour travel, my legs were feeling heavy a bit before this. I think I can be running faster, but I am super stoked with that.”

Ruthe said it was his first race on an indoor track, as New Zealand doesn’t have them.

“So to come here and run so fast so early on, it just makes me love indoor tracks. I want to come here as much as possible.”

Ruthe said his plan was to sit behind compatriot and training partner Sam Tanner during the race.

“He probably would have beaten me, but about 400m-600m in he did something to his Achilles. I really hope he’s okay.”

Ruthe was in second place heading into the final lap, taking the lead and winning by a comfortable margin.

Last week Ruthe ran 3:53.83sec at the Cooks Classic in Whanganui, beaten by Tanner but breaking the world outdoor record for a 16-year-old to add to a string of other landmarks already achieved.

The Boston race is the first of four of the mile races Ruthe plans to contest this month before returning to New Zealand for the national championships in early March.

Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero, a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.

– Published by EveningReport.nz and AsiaPacificReport.nz, see: MIL OSI in partnership with Radio New Zealand