From MIL OSI

Black queer and trans newcomers find safety in Canada, but not always community and belonging

Source: The Conversation – Canada

Each summer, Pride fills the streets across Canada. Pride Toronto organizers estimated 3.1 million attendees in 2024, and more than 900,000 people took part in Fierté Montréal in 2025.

Smaller cities turn out too: about 7,600 attended Windsor-Essex Pride Fest in 2025.

Canada has some of the world’s strongest legal protections for 2SLGBTQI+ people, scoring 94 out of 100 on Equaldex’s legal index as of November 2026. It also presents itself as a refuge.

Ottawa resettles up to 250 2SLGBTQI+ refugees a year referred by Rainbow Railroad, and claims based on sexual orientation or gender identity have made up about six per cent of all refugee claims in recent years.




Read more:
BIPOC or IBPOC? LGBTQ or LGBTQ2S+? Who decides which terms we should use?


But for Black queer and trans newcomers who fled persecution, a harder question remains once the parade ends. Legal protection is not the same as belonging. And the thing that most reliably builds belonging — community — is among the least reliably funded.

Isolated from every direction

As a scholar whose research examines the intersections of migration and LGBTQ+ sexualities, I conducted focus groups with 22 members of the Queer and Trans Migrant Advocacy Alliance of Windsor-Essex (QTMAAWE) in the summer of 2025. The peer-led organization was founded in 2024 by and for queer and trans migrants. All participants identified as Black, and most were refugee claimants from Nigeria, Tanzania, Kenya and Zambia.

The findings appear in a community research report released in August.

Windsor, Ont., is a telling place to ask these questions. As a mid-sized border city, it receives a significant share of Canada’s asylum seekers. Yet until QTMAAWE, no organization in the region catered specifically to Black queer and trans migrants.

Participants described profound isolation, often from the moment they arrived. Many, like Ivan (participants’ names are pseudonyms), had been cut off by family. He said:

“I message them, I text them, I call them. No response.”

In addition, spaces meant to feel safe often were not. Many felt shut out of their own ethnic and faith communities. Susan recalled visiting a local queer-affirming church:

“It was just white people […] I’ve never felt Black in my life — I felt so Black.”

The consequences of this isolation can be severe. As Daniel told me:

“After a year, I ended up getting hospitalized because of loneliness. It affected me mentally in a very serious way.”

Community as the intervention

In that context, participants described QTMAAWE in words rarely used for a service agency. Asked what it represents, one group answered: freedom, home, family, peace.

The organization now connects roughly 600 members. It runs weekly safe-space gatherings and helps people prepare refugee claims, find jobs and navigate housing and health care. One participant said more than 50 people were hired at a single QTMAAWE job fair.

Community participation even carries legal weight. Support letters and attendance records help claimants document their identities for refugee hearings, which matters for people who survived at home by leaving no trace.

Just as important are the shared meals. Ivan described a potluck where someone brought one of his favourite dishes from home. “We used our hands to eat it, and we all had fun,” he said. “And I felt like, this is where I belong.”

This is not only a Windsor story, however. In a national survey of more than 400 Black 2SLGBTQI+ people for The Enchanté Network’s Back to Our Roots report, 85 per cent said they had experienced anti-Black racism in 2SLGBTQI+ spaces. Organizers called for a national Black 2SLGBTQI+ organization “by us and for us.”

Federal data point the same way. In the federal government’s 2019-20 2SLGBTQI+ Action Plan Survey, Black African respondents were less likely than the overall sample to feel included in queer community spaces (50 per cent versus 62 per cent) or to feel a strong sense of belonging to Canada (66 per cent versus 82 per cent).

All of this suggests that Black-led, migrant-led peer organizations may offer one of the most effective ways to ease isolation for these newcomers.

Belonging on borrowed time

Yet this work remains precariously funded. QTMAAWE has received no money from the Federal 2SLGBTQI+ Action Plan, the $100-million program Ottawa launched in 2022. In October, the organization joined more than 40 groups on Parliament Hill calling for the plan’s renewal. Budget 2026 delivered part of what they asked for: $60 million over four years starting in 2027-28, plus $15 million in ongoing annual funding.

Public debate in Canada rarely treats belonging as something worth funding. Coverage tends to frame 2SLGBTQI+ newcomers through persecution abroad or, more recently, through Bill C-12’s one-year rule, under which claims made more than a year after arrival are no longer referred to the Immigration and Refugee Board.

Policy proposals call for culturally informed mental health services. These are real needs, but such proposals overlook the peer-led spaces where racism, homophobia, transphobia and immigration precarity are confronted together.

In Windsor, the result is an essential institution that relies on borrowed space and rests on very few shoulders, above all those of its founder, Anold Mulaisho. He said:

“If you’re not going to give me a seat at the table. I’m going to create my own table.”

Funding belonging year-round

So what would it take to fund belonging year-round in mid-sized cities like Windsor? Participants were clear.

First, a permanent, accessible community space, which participants named as their single most important need. Second, core operating funding rather than short-term project grants.

Third, reliable referral pathways from shelters, settlement agencies, clinics and legal aid, so newcomers don’t have to rely on luck to find community. Fourth, recognition that shared meals, peer support and safe-space gatherings are mental health infrastructure, not extras.

Pride began as advocacy, not only celebration. For Black queer and trans newcomers, honouring that history means making sure Canada’s welcome lasts longer than one festival each summer.

The Conversation

Carlo Handy Charles has received funding from the Social Sciences and Humanities Research Council of Canada (SSHRC) and the Pierre Elliott Trudeau Foundation. Carlo Handy Charles is also a Visiting Scholar in the Department of Sociology at the University of Michigan-Ann Arbor and a Fellow at the CNRS French Collaborative Institute on Migration (Institut Convergences Migrations) in Paris.

Original source: https://analysis1.mil-osi.com/2026/11/16/black-queer-and-trans-newcomers-find-safety-in-canada-but-not-always-community-and-belonging/