From MIL OSI

Why freelance culture in the media makes it so hard for women to report abuse

Source: The Conversation – UK

In the conviction of Russell Brand and the Metropolitan police’s announcement that it has launched an investigation into David Walliams over separate allegations of serious sexual offences, the media industries have come under renewed scrutiny over how workplace cultures enable misconduct and abuse.

The two cases stand at very different legal stages. Brand has been convicted and jailed after a court found he exploited a culture of deference to talent to abuse women with impunity. Walliams has not been arrested or charged, and strongly denies all allegations of criminal behaviour or wrongdoing. He maintains that past relationships with women he met through his public profile were consensual, though he has admitted behaving “thoughtlessly”.

But what about the women working in the media industries who were targets of workplace misconduct and abuse? What made them particularly vulnerable to assault, what prevented them from speaking out and why was it so difficult for those who did to have their stories taken seriously?

My research investigates the media industries and creative work, so I am interested in how working environments make women vulnerable to abuse, while also making it professionally risky to challenge the behaviour of people in positions of power.




Read more:
Russell Brand: how the comedy industry uses humour to abuse and silence women


Abuse in the workplace

Four of the six women who testified against Russell Brand during his trial worked for TV or radio organisations. Some of the assaults happened in the workplace, where Brand felt confident his behaviour would go unchallenged.

One woman – who the prosecution barrister described as “just a woman trying to get on with her work” – was kissed and groped by Brand in front of his entourage. Another was working on a Channel 4 project when Brand asked her to give him a massage and put his head in her crotch, while two male colleagues looked on and laughed.

According to the Telegraph, a junior colleague at Walliams’ publisher HarperCollins raised a complaint in 2023 about alleged inappropriate behaviour. The paper reported that no formal action was taken against Walliams – who has denied wrongdoing – while the woman was given a five-figure settlement, signed a non-disclosure agreement and left the company. HarperCollins only parted ways with Walliams two years later, following a change in management.

During Brand’s trial, his defence barrister repeatedly questioned why the women didn’t speak out at the time, in some cases, waiting decades after the crimes were committed to come forward. There are many barriers to reporting sexual violence, including shame, self-blame, the low rate of successful prosecutions and the prospect of hostile questioning in court. But many reasons why women remain silent are also rooted in the circumstances of their working lives.

Media production is a predominantly freelance industry. Creative workers are typically employed on short-term contracts, moving from one company to the next. In a highly competitive workplace, professional reputation is a form of currency. Being perceived as difficult or troublesome can be a red flag. Workers are hired through informal recruitment networks that are not open to scrutiny and may never know the reason why the phone suddenly stops ringing.

One of Brand’s victims told the court she didn’t complain at the time because she had a mortgage to pay. Another said: “I thought it was my word against his and he was a big famous asset.”

For women in the industry, workplace pressures are compounded by gender inequalities. Research shows that marginalised workers are less able to endure challenging conditions. In an industry where women outnumber men at entry level, evidence shows a mid-career exodus, with many female workers leaving the industry before they are able to progress into senior roles.

But sometimes the women who were abused did speak out. In some cases they complained to line managers, colleagues and HR departments who took little effective action. Formal complaints about Brand’s sexual misconduct were made to the BBC in 2019, yet it was only after allegations were brought to public attention by a 2023 Channel 4 Dispatches programme that the Met Police began an investigation, which the BBC later acknowledged.

Following Brand’s conviction, culture secretary Lisa Nandy has told the media industries that their “time is up” to put systems in place to protect people who speak out against abuse.

Nandy has urged organisations to sign up to the new Creative Industries Independent Standards Authority, which has launched an independent whistleblowing service to encourage greater accountability. But reporting mechanisms are, by their nature, retrospective and not designed to prevent harm from happening in the first place.

Meanwhile, insecure freelance work, informal recruitment practices and ingrained power hierarchies continue to create conditions in which speaking out carries professional risk and make the media industries an unsafe workplace for women.

The Conversation

Emily Coleman receives funding from the Arts & Humanities Research Council and the Economic & Social Research Council.

Original source: https://analysis1.mil-osi.com/2026/11/16/why-freelance-culture-in-the-media-makes-it-so-hard-for-women-to-report-abuse/